|
Spoilers btw.
>Intentionally or not, it implies that >stranded Ninth Ward residents not only wanted to stay on their >rooftops but somehow—through their own stubbornness in not >clearing out—deserved to be there. And what's more, that the >best thing to do about it was to leave them alone.
I think the film if anything has a message of NOT leaving others alone. One of the central points of change in Hushpuppy and Wink by the end is they learn that their behavior earlier, in which they stayed on their own and even literally cut themselves off from each other with a line in the room, wasn't the way to live at all.
I don't think the movie implies what's "best" is to leave them alone either. One could argue that Wink might have lived if he stayed away from the Bathtub, and he seemed to know this. The writer and director also emphasize that everything in the bathtub-- plants, animals, eventually people-- are dead. The way of life there isn't sustainable. So while what the characters want complicates things, it certainly doesn't say that what's best for them is to let them die.
Not only do residents of the Bathtub >(the movie's Ninth Ward stand-in) resist government help, but >the authorities fail to understand what they're getting into. >("They say we were here for our own good," Hushpuppy, played >by Quvenzhané Wallis, says after Bathtub residents are >relocated to a hospital—leaving little doubt that she doesn't >think they are.)
SHE'S SEVEN, lol. She doesn't know anything! She talks to a chair and thinks it's her mom! She's a child! We're witnessing these things through the eyes of a child.
Eventually, Bathtubbers stage an an escape >("We're bustin' out of here!") that the movie plays as a >triumph.
It did not play like an unequivocal triumph to me. It played like a triumph of spirit and will, sure. But you are ACUTELY aware that by leaving, Wink will absolutely die.
>The depiction of poverty, too, seems in keeping with a >particular stereotype, in which the poor only lack resources >because of their own failures of initiative. In the Bathtub, >every day is a holiday and no one seems to have much desire to >be employed.
He's reading this in it because he wants to read this in it. The fact is we see them for maybe a day or two before the storm. We don't know what Wink does, and it's not important. The white couple seem to run a store of sorts. The mother figure in the Bathtub that teaches all the children is a positive influence. You can't argue what Keningsburg argues her because we're seeing a very limited portrait, again, through the eyes of a child. How many of you watched your parents work every day, or watched adults go to work every day? How many of you knew, at 7, the intricacies of why your parents were out of work? I just think the author was looking for this read.
Parents are depicted as alcohol-guzzling and >inattentive-bordering-on-deadbeat. "If anything goes wrong, >Walrus is dad," Hushpuppy's father, Wink (Dwight Henry), tells >her, entrusting her to a neighbor in a moment the movie plays >for a laugh.
Walrus is a troublesome character, since his reactions are often played for laughs. But I don't think Dwight Henry delivers that line for a chuckle-- he's earnest.
> And that's to say nothing of the film's charged >racial imagery (e.g., Wink swigging from his booze bottle and >haplessly shooting at storm clouds, or, in a fantastical >flashback, lazing in the sun).
Lazing in the sun? LMAO, he's in love in the flashback admiring the girl of his dreams. What an enormous stretch.
>I doubt that first-time feature director Benh Zeitlin meant >for the movie to play as a magical-realist apologia for Bush's >failings. (Spoiler alert: The Bathtub residents eschew help, >pull themselves up by their bootstraps and learn, as Hushpuppy >explains to one of the eponymous beasts at the end, to take >care of their own.) But it's not a film in control of its own >metaphor, and it poses troubling questions where it likely >intends only uplift.
I agree that the metaphors are messy, but this author went way overboard with his reaches.
My movies: http://russellhainline.com My movie reviews: https://letterboxd.com/RussellHFilm/ My beer TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@thebeertravelguide
|