Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby General Discussion topic #12725065

Subject: "I agree it shouldn't be criminalized, mostly. " Previous topic | Next topic
Buddy_Gilapagos
Charter member
49426 posts
Wed Feb-11-15 02:52 PM

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
12. "I agree it shouldn't be criminalized, mostly. "
In response to In response to 8


  

          

However if a person had the mens rea (is that the word?) to set out and infect someone, that is a criminal act IMHOP.

Generally speaking though I think you probably have a moral obligation to disclose to a sexual partner something that you reasonably believe that they would want to know that is sexually related and may affect their health and/or their decision to want to have sex with you.

If you know that they may not want to have sex with you if they found out you are married, morally speaking you should probably tell them.

Same with HIV status. Minimizing the risk by 94% does not minimize the risk to zero which would be the risk status if a person chose to not have sex with you.


>by making failure to disclose poz status before sex a
>criminal act. i think such laws are completely abhorrent and
>that they only act to increase HIV stigma and don't actually
>encourage the desired behavior - disclosure of poz status.
>
>so i'm glad that this guy hasn't been criminally charged for
>his conduct, AFAIK.
>
>and now that HIV has become such a manageable disease and ppl
>who get treatment are often able to reduce their viral loads
>to undetectable which grossly decreases the chance that they
>will infect anyone...why are we still freaking out about HIV?
>i assume it's b/c ppl aren't aware of the advances in medz.
>also, those of us who are negative can take PREP and if we
>have sex w/a poz partner w/an undetectable viral load the risk
>of transmission is reduced by 92%. so why panic?
>
>it's not a death sentence. it hasn't been for yrs. we need
>to chill.


**********
"Everyone has a plan until you punch them in the face. Then they don't have a plan anymore." (c) Mike Tyson

"One of the most important things in life is what Judge Learned Hand described as 'that ever-gnawing inner doubt as to whether you're r

  

Printer-friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote


Memba that HIV+ Dude at Howard who was smashing chicks?(Swipe) [View all] , Buddy_Gilapagos, Wed Feb-11-15 02:16 PM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
condoms work.
Feb 11th 2015
1
^^here for dis.
Feb 11th 2015
6
i'm generally opposed to criminalization of HIV
Feb 11th 2015
8
     
           it shouldn't be criminalized, period.
Feb 11th 2015
14
                Yeah I think it should be the same for syphilis.
Feb 11th 2015
16
                     moral obligation?
Feb 11th 2015
18
Yea but condoms break
Feb 11th 2015
19
      nvm
Feb 11th 2015
20
      I agree with this immensely.
Feb 11th 2015
21
      accept responsibility and then what?
Feb 11th 2015
23
           Uuhh, I think she is agreeing with you.
Feb 11th 2015
25
                cool
Feb 11th 2015
26
      and condoms almost never break when used correctly:
Feb 11th 2015
22
      plus, that had nothing to do w/my point.
Feb 11th 2015
24
Is he as smug as he sounded on the radio?
Feb 11th 2015
2
I definitely did not like the guy.
Feb 11th 2015
5
I'm under the impression he never infected anyone
Feb 11th 2015
3
uuh, trying to figure if I need spoiler alerts with this.
Feb 11th 2015
4
      no spoiler alerts needed b/c i just read that info in a news story.
Feb 11th 2015
7
           It's that plus a helping of DL fearmongering, even though he wasn't that...
Feb 11th 2015
10
           yeah.
Feb 11th 2015
11
           The take home actually is NOT to always practice safe sex.
Feb 11th 2015
13
                oh okay.
Feb 11th 2015
15
                     It's compelling. Check it out.
Feb 11th 2015
17
Straight Outta Condom
Feb 11th 2015
9

Lobby General Discussion topic #12725065 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com