Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby Okay Activist Archives topic #20329

Subject: "in addition" This topic is locked.
Previous topic | Next topic
janey
Charter member
123124 posts
Wed Oct-04-00 07:32 AM

Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
5. "in addition"
In response to In response to 3


  

          

To add fuel to an already blazing fire, the British promised the same land to BOTH the Palestinians and the Zionists, back when Zionism first got its start, like the turn of the century.

Further, part of the reason that the Israelis are so reactive to the Palestinians is that for decades the spokespersons for the Palestinians was the PLO, which was a radical terrorist organization, rather than the people themselves. Moderate Palestinians would have doubtless negotiated a reasonable deal when heads were cooler and before Israel got too full of itself, but the PLO refused to negotiate. The PLO also kept all the Palestinians evicted from Jewish settled areas in refugee camps. As political pawns. For decades. When there were other Arab nations that were willing to take them in and integrate them.

I'm not saying that the Israelis aren't bad actors. Just that no one is completely without some responsibility. But the real answer isn't found in the question "who's at fault?" but instead "where do we go from here?"

I always found the Israeli position that the Left Bank and the Gaza Strip were essential to be indefensible. Then, once the "buffer zone" of the Sinai desert was ceded, after the peace treaty with Egypt, the rationale for these two areas -- whose population was almost entirely Arab -- seemed even worse.

But, you know, until 1969, the city of Jerusalem itself was partitioned. It was only after the city was united after the 6 Day War that ALL religions were allowed to worship at the holiest sites. I would most like to see Jerusalem in neutral hands, but if that isn't a viable option, I frankly would rather have it in the hands of the Israelis, who haven't sworn as a matter of principle to exterminate any other religion.

Peace.

~ ~ ~
All meetings end in separation
All acquisition ends in dispersion
All life ends in death
- The Buddha

|\_/|
='_'=

Every hundred years, all new people

  

Printer-friendly copy


Jerusalem [View all] , Gloworm, Tue Oct-03-00 09:26 AM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
here's some pointers
Oct 03rd 2000
1
RE: Jerusalem
DGraves
Oct 03rd 2000
2
actually ...
Oct 05th 2000
8
Boodah's Links &
Oct 03rd 2000
3
      RE: in addition
DGraves
Oct 04th 2000
6
      yes, but
Oct 05th 2000
7
      My point exactly
Oct 05th 2000
9
           The damned Nazis started it.
Oct 10th 2000
18
                Hmmm
Oct 11th 2000
19
                RE: Hmmm
Oct 12th 2000
20
                RE: The damned Nazis started it.
Eli B
Nov 13th 2000
23
      RE: in addition
Oct 06th 2000
13
Book
Oct 04th 2000
4
see also:
velodragon
Oct 05th 2000
10
RE: Jerusalem
Oct 06th 2000
11
RE: Jerusalem
DGraves
Oct 06th 2000
12
Well put
Marinera
Oct 07th 2000
14
thank you
Oct 08th 2000
15
thanks! n/m
Oct 08th 2000
16
RE: Jerusalem
Oct 10th 2000
17
RE: Jerusalem
Riggy
Oct 18th 2000
21
BRC statement on conflict
Oct 20th 2000
22
The most fair solution
Eli B
Nov 13th 2000
24

Lobby Okay Activist Archives topic #20329 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com