Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby The Lesson The Lesson Archives topic #161031

Subject: "#musiccivilwar" This topic is locked.
Previous topic | Next topic
imcvspl
Member since Mar 07th 2005
42239 posts
Mon May-02-11 07:04 AM

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
63. "#musiccivilwar"
In response to In response to 0


  

          

Any day now music is going to secede from the industry </hopeful>

In all seriousness though, as guilty as I can be when there isn't a wealth of discussion about actual music, discussing the industry is ho hum. Same goes for academia which is what I was pointing out in a recent post. If you can't talk about the actual music, who gives a fuck about your other thoughts on the matter.

But then again these discussions don't even pose themselves to be about music any more. It's about the media, and in that regard I'm in the AFKAP camp of things. When the media takes precedent over the music.... But of course we are living in the age of "The medium is the massage" so that's to be expected.

I've been throwing around quotes from this piece -http://www.thewire.co.uk/articles/6445/ a lot of late and might as well throw two quotes out there:

"To me, if music can’t be shared, I’m not interested in it. However, once I digitize these objects and they enter into the file sharing ecosystem, they become alive for me again."

"As a matter of fact, records that I’ve been craving for years (such as the complete recordings of Jean Cocteau, which we just posted on Ubu) are languishing unlistened-to. I’ll never get to them either, because I’m more interested in the hunt than I am in the prey. The minute I get something, I just crave more. And so something has really changed – and I think this is the real epiphany: the ways in which culture is distributed have become profoundly more intriguing than the cultural artifact itself. What we’ve experienced is an inversion of consumption, one in which we’ve come to prefer the acts of acquisition over that which we are acquiring, the bottles over the wine."

This is from the founder of the Ubu web a site that's supposed to be all about the music.

IMO we've outgrown the 'industry'. Artists, listeners and fans. All have out grown them. BUt the industry itself will not let go. It's fighting for its relevance. It comes down on the actual music in order to validate the importance of its role in bringing said music to you. It hypes up its achievements, teaches us its buzz words, and keeps us discussing its problems as if they are our own. THIS keeps the industry alive, and it has taught us that it being alive is synonymous with music being alive. That is categorically false. Music can live without the industry, but the industry without the music is just pr and advertising. Oh wait that's what it is now.

So the question is, what do you want to discuss, pr and advertising, or music.

#musiccivilwar

________
Big PEMFin H & z's
█▆▇▅▇█▇▆▄▁▃
http://concretesoundsystem.com
The Underbelly - http://bit.ly/f5BmBR
RIPL - http://bit.ly/e5wzxn
Read me write - http://themoshi.tumblr.com/

  

Printer-friendly copy


Am I the only one bored with ''industry''-related discussions? [View all] , Jakob Hellberg, Sat Apr-30-11 06:38 PM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
I find those discussions kind of disheartening myself
Apr 30th 2011
1
they're fun until they go off the rails.
Apr 30th 2011
3
only when people are misinformed...
Apr 30th 2011
2
RE: No you're not. And I'm calling you out AFKAP.
Apr 30th 2011
4
Why are you calling me out specifically?
May 01st 2011
15
      RE: No, I was being sarcastic.
May 01st 2011
20
           Oh okay.
May 01st 2011
22
They're necessary.
Apr 30th 2011
5
RE: And even more of them are just trying to LOOK smart.
Apr 30th 2011
7
*yawn* That was not very useful and boring.
May 01st 2011
8
      RE: Substance! Alright!
May 01st 2011
9
           I'm interested in media in general and music is a part of that.
May 01st 2011
10
                RE: I guess the distinction then. . .
May 01st 2011
11
                     I don't know that it does. I think that we're both interested
May 01st 2011
12
                          I'm in general agreement with Firebrand I think.
May 01st 2011
18
                               You are totally oversimplifying and misrepresenting the argument here.
May 01st 2011
21
                                    It's like this:
May 01st 2011
25
                                    Again simplifying, though.
May 01st 2011
27
                                    but when we DO have these discussions, they go off the rails...
May 01st 2011
29
                                    Death? This is a REBIRTH!
May 01st 2011
44
No offense but this ''content'' shit...
May 01st 2011
13
      It doesn't really matter that you like it or not.
May 01st 2011
14
      eh... I've already gone back and forth with him on that shit.
May 01st 2011
16
           I think Jay Rosen and his attack on the caveweller idea
May 01st 2011
17
                Well, then I guess the bone of contention
May 01st 2011
23
                     I'm not sure that's what we're saying at all.
May 01st 2011
40
I don't mind when it's about the state of the industry overall
Apr 30th 2011
6
full disclosure I've been bored with this forum for a minute now
May 01st 2011
19
It's boring only when some insist on propping up the old model
May 01st 2011
24
let me ask you THIS:
May 01st 2011
28
Your whole post bored me.
May 01st 2011
30
      Of course it did. Good day to you.
May 01st 2011
31
           Literally NO ONE has posted exactly how to fix the industy.
May 01st 2011
32
                here's the problem.
May 01st 2011
33
                     Your perspective on the fans should encompass more than okp
May 01st 2011
35
                          fair enough.
May 01st 2011
45
and another thing. What's the "New Model"?
May 01st 2011
34
      Uh, the new model is free and a muthaf*ckin' t-shirt
May 01st 2011
37
      LOL
May 01st 2011
38
      hmmmm.
May 01st 2011
39
      Right now the answer is: There is no one model.
May 01st 2011
41
      but to some degree, most artists have the same goals...
May 01st 2011
43
           Those aren't specific goals and it'll be different
May 01st 2011
49
                that's what I said..."it varies by genre"...
May 01st 2011
50
                I think the best way to "save" music is to abandon
May 01st 2011
52
                although your adamant stance about music = free irks me...
May 02nd 2011
65
                     Man I'm just a journalist. I see what cats are doing
May 02nd 2011
74
      *double post*
May 01st 2011
42
      "number of hits on youtube/followers" is part of the new model
May 02nd 2011
62
      That can be part of it. And...
May 02nd 2011
64
      In the "New Model," the artist controls how far they go.
May 02nd 2011
73
ok, I have more time to comment further...
May 01st 2011
26
I completely agree with you
May 01st 2011
36
RE: Am I the only one bored with ''industry''-related discussions?
May 01st 2011
46
yes...and no.
May 01st 2011
48
RE: yes...and no.
May 01st 2011
54
RE: Am I the only one bored with ''industry''-related discussions?
May 01st 2011
53
      RE: Am I the only one bored with ''industry''-related discussions?
May 01st 2011
55
           Trust me...
May 01st 2011
56
           and neither does being a fan.
May 01st 2011
58
                You going after me?
May 02nd 2011
59
                     umm. no I'm not...so don't make shit personal.
May 02nd 2011
60
                          ethugging?
May 02nd 2011
61
           bingo.
May 01st 2011
57
I'm Never Tired Of Those ''Industry Related" Discussions
May 01st 2011
47
man this is on point
May 01st 2011
51
since it is called the music industry, i think industry posts are valid
May 02nd 2011
66
there's like a >10:1 ratio w/ music discussion vs industry posts
May 02nd 2011
67
Yes, but those posts seem to generate MUCH more indepth discussion...
May 02nd 2011
68
      here is where I would like to know OKP's age demographics
May 02nd 2011
71
           This is a great point
May 02nd 2011
72
Here's the thing
May 02nd 2011
69
^^^The new description for The Lesson^^^
May 02nd 2011
70
technology is more interesting than the artefact these days
May 03rd 2011
75

Lobby The Lesson The Lesson Archives topic #161031 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com