Go back to previous topic
Forum nameGeneral Discussion
Topic subjectTrump Admitted On Tape To Intentionally Downplaying Covid Threat
Topic URLhttp://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=4&topic_id=13402919
13402919, Trump Admitted On Tape To Intentionally Downplaying Covid Threat
Posted by Reeq, Wed Sep-09-20 11:35 AM
several audio clips in link:
https://www.cnn.com/2020/09/09/politics/bob-woodward-rage-book-trump-coronavirus/index.html

theres audio back in march where he clearly acknowledges how dangerous the virus is...quotes how much more deadly it is than the flu...quotes how it affects young people and not just old people...and so on...and he was still out in public playing it down.

it also means he *deliberately* took steps to kneecap the federal govt response to the virus and put lives at risk despite being fully knowledgeable about the havoc it could wreak.

and its all on tape. no anonymous sources. the horse is the source.

if anything mattered at all anymore...trump and any republican who still supports him after this would be banished to the phantom zone by the american public.
13402926, Wonder what the MAGA line will be for this one.
Posted by Brew, Wed Sep-09-20 11:58 AM
13402928, that he's 100% right and panic doesn't help anything
Posted by Mynoriti, Wed Sep-09-20 12:07 PM
and that the numbers are drastically inflated and they're blaming every death on covid and its over politicized, etc..

same ol same ol'
13402931, when people say thank God trump is just as incompetent as he is evil
Posted by Reeq, Wed Sep-09-20 12:14 PM
this is a great example.

authoritarians/autocrats around the world played *up* the danger of the virus and used the threat to consolidate power and strategically usurp the authority of parliaments, judiciaries, etc.

trump played down the virus because he most likely thought the 'panic' would have a negative effect on his re-election. and in turn...the failed administrative response still brought on fear and panic...cratered the economy...and became the #1 weapon used against him in his re-election. meanwhile the politicians who publicly treated the virus seriously saw their approval ratings soar and their political standings for re-election greatly increase.
13402935, or even just listening to experts and having a real national response
Posted by Mynoriti, Wed Sep-09-20 12:22 PM
lets say he does and our numbers are relatively low compared to the rest of the world.

he'd be untouchable.

but he can rarely see beyond today's news cycle
13402976, Yea the "panic" line is exactly what I figured they'd key on, too.
Posted by Brew, Wed Sep-09-20 01:04 PM
13402934, Put me in coach, I got this one
Posted by double negative, Wed Sep-09-20 12:20 PM
when it comes to the MAGA reaction...

-IF it's a story that involves sources THEN the tactic is to question the sources, scoff at use of anonymous sources and keep it moving.

-IF it's documented evidence of Trump showing contempt for "them" THEN deny the core statement, lean on Trump's use of ambiguous/open ended statements and say "this is out of context, what he REALLY means is..."

-IF it's documented evidence of Trump showing contempt for something important to MAGA culture (i.e., religion, military, etc), THEN cut off the nose. Lean on ambiguous language and then state "well, this thing was not important to US to begin with"

-IF it's something very clearly bad, with documented evidence and stated extremely clearly with zero ambiguity and there is no way to squirm out of the discussion...

THEN approach the following flow:

1. is the disparaging statement or reprehensible thing on or about shithole countries or "them"? If YES then agree, "Yes, shithole country/people or thing is destroying your hard work and America".
If NO go to 2.

2. is the disparaging statement or reprehensible thing on or about MAGA and "us"? If YES say nothing. Nothing at all. Find a liberal/democrat concept you feel is tearing the country apart. Complain about that. Do not let up.


So - nothing. Not a goddamn thing will be said. They don't self reflect on the shit that you think matters.

13402979, LOL I love this and will use it. To your last point #2 ...
Posted by Brew, Wed Sep-09-20 01:07 PM
>2. is the disparaging statement or reprehensible thing on or
>about MAGA and "us"? If YES say nothing. Nothing at all. Find
>a liberal/democrat concept you feel is tearing the country
>apart. Complain about that. Do not let up.

... my friend's mom posted this article on Facebook and the first response was from some MAGA cunt woman who said "PELOSI TOOK US DOWN TO CHINATOWN" so, yea. You're on point thus far. Haha.
13402996, This how deep the dissonance goes...
Posted by double negative, Wed Sep-09-20 01:28 PM
To them...

Epstein - raped everybody

Clinton - raped everybody

Weinstein - raped everybody

Biden - well, maybe not, but we're still gonna go with, "Raped everybody"

Trump - *sucks teeth* see thats the problem with these females. they see a rich man and they can't help it. it comes with the territory. look, see, he even said "shes not my type". FACTS.



13402983, ALL FAX nm
Posted by vik, Wed Sep-09-20 01:11 PM
13402985, Perfect. Reads like a page from a literal Maganite Playbook
Posted by Cold Truth, Wed Sep-09-20 01:12 PM
13402936, so far im seeing "but fauci lied about masks"
Posted by mista k5, Wed Sep-09-20 12:23 PM
13402967, they really love that one
Posted by Mynoriti, Wed Sep-09-20 12:51 PM
13402943, Rip Torn sums it up rather succintly
Posted by Cold Truth, Wed Sep-09-20 12:32 PM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=plXIfAQ_JWw
13402929, It's Septemeber. Dude had these tapes the whole time
Posted by MEAT, Wed Sep-09-20 12:11 PM
And ... sought profit.
Fuck Bob Woodward too.
13402930, this.
Posted by FLUIDJ, Wed Sep-09-20 12:13 PM
13402933, if this does damage to him right before the election
Posted by Reeq, Wed Sep-09-20 12:18 PM
then i can give him a pass.

im not sure releasing the tapes earlier would have changed much in our collective response to the virus and saved significantly more lives (trump and republicans would just double down on whatever new goalpost they chose).

but if the timing of this (right before early voting starts) helps get him out of office so a competent president can come in and try to right this ship...then thats an overwhelming net positive imo.

i was more annoyed at the michael schmidt (nytimes) shit where he deliberately held on to scoops that would have been major developments up to and through impeachment...but now nobody even cares about.
13402938, Man I've lost family members and the world is forever changed
Posted by MEAT, Wed Sep-09-20 12:25 PM
Anyone that sought to bide time as if we ever had it can kiss my ass.
13402941, are you confident that woodward releasing the info earlier
Posted by Reeq, Wed Sep-09-20 12:29 PM
would have changed any of that?

im not.

spell out a hypothetical chain of events where we get from woodward releasing the audio to a dramatic change of political/public behavior.
13402947, this is offensive
Posted by CherNic, Wed Sep-09-20 12:34 PM
13402950, how so?
Posted by Reeq, Wed Sep-09-20 12:36 PM
13402960, mans said his fam died and you asked for a hypothesis
Posted by CherNic, Wed Sep-09-20 12:47 PM
Do we know for a fact the US wouldn't have lost close to 200k lives nah we don't, but the country deserved to have the truth from it's most powerful office.

If this wasn't downplayed for months we wouldn't have lost as many lives as we did. I'm standing on that.
13402969, The consistent centering of everyday life on what it matters politically is
Posted by MEAT, Wed Sep-09-20 12:54 PM
is such a moral failure of individuals. A complete abdication of the uniqueness, shortness, and frailty of the human experience

It's a bottom five bankrupt character trait. Just completely inhumane.

Niggas aint even paid to not think of themselves, they just depersonalize their own experience willingly.
13402988, why is politics divorced from real life to you?
Posted by Reeq, Wed Sep-09-20 01:13 PM
political decisions/considerations/outcomes affect living/dying.

instead of *just* moralizing woodwards internal decision making process...im saying that i think the way things ultimately played out could help save a lot more lives than the way you wanted things to play out.

thats a moral stance as well. and one that considers the greater social good.

and you dont seem to be disputing any of that.

13402993, That's a horseshit way to put it.
Posted by MEAT, Wed Sep-09-20 01:21 PM
My experience on this planet isn't validated by a fucked up system of laws and rules that overwhelmingly were designed and maintained to benefit and entrench white supremacy.

And the only cure for that is defining reality as it occurs not trying to shape what may be down the road banking on what humans will buy

That's why climate collapse is so important to talk about, rape culture, the 1619 project, gender identity, segregation, redlining, racism ... etc ... it's not enough to treat these studies as academic and how and who they'll play to ... it's a betrayal of a human experience to downplay them because of what someone else may think of them.

My life and the lives of those I love matter more to me than "politics" and elections.
13402997, reality itself is horseshit to you then.
Posted by Reeq, Wed Sep-09-20 01:29 PM
13402998, I think you're hiding behind highbrow meaning
Posted by MEAT, Wed Sep-09-20 01:33 PM
Because it's easy to divorce the emotion of what a betrayal this is if you can ascribe some hope to it.

I think that's horseshit.

There will always be a way to validate something like this, or a war, or someone getting their neck squashed for 8 minutes until they lose their life ... because the idea is that "some good will surely come from this" ... and while that may be true, folks constantly have to ignore and downplay the bad else they evaluate what it means to sacrifice and not demand more from their own lives.

I demand more. This isn't good enough.
13403001, im really not that complicated.
Posted by Reeq, Wed Sep-09-20 01:51 PM
i believe politics has a dramatic effect on lives. especially that shit that takes place in politics that people dont pay attention to or dont think will affect their lives that much. and thats something a lot of people are either unintentionally ignorant to or willfully dismissive of.

i dont know why people treat politics as a separate track inconsequential to their daily lives. thats an almost uniquely american thing (among modernized western societies).

1 political outcome/decision...in the form of a judicial appointment, a law passed, an election altering oppo drop or scandal, etc...can have tangible ramifications for several *generations*.

i dont see how anyone who knows anything about history can disagree with that.

shit you can pretty much directly pin almost everything happening now to a ripple from the election of george w bush in 2000.

if you believe that an audio drop could have lowered deaths back in march or april...i dont understand how you can criticize me for my belief that even more deaths could be prevented by the current timing. its about saving real lives right?

it seems like something we should just be agreeing/disagreeing on the hypothetical results of and not soapboxing about how one is more morally superior (especially if the alternative may actually be better for life/society).
13403003, RE: im really not that complicated.
Posted by MEAT, Wed Sep-09-20 01:58 PM

>if you believe that an audio drop could have lowered deaths
>back in march or april...i dont understand how you can
>criticize me for my belief that even more deaths could be
>prevented by the current timing. its about saving real lives
>right?

I'm saying it's inconsequential on what it means today.

I have documented proof that the president is lying about a pandemic matters more than I have documented proof that the president lied about a pandemic.

It's unknowable how are what would've changed. My position was and continues to be if you can save people you at least try, if you see people hurting you at least try ... that so many people aren’t willing to just try and they we reward that with “what will it change” is a failure.

Maybe one day I look past it, but that day can't be today. I am human. I am disgusted.
13402980, i lost my uncle, one of my nieces fathers, my moms best friend
Posted by Reeq, Wed Sep-09-20 01:07 PM
and one of the kids at the childrens hospital that my girl and i 'adopted' is still dealing with some hellish form of pulmonary fibrosis made worse by covid.

i harbor no resentment toward woodward for any of that.

i do however genuinely believe that the audio dropping right now could potentially help alter the course of history and save more lives by increasing the odds of donald trump being replaced.

that to me overshadows whatever woodwards motivation may or may not have been.




13403004, it's not a competition....but okay
Posted by CherNic, Wed Sep-09-20 01:58 PM
13403048, no dog here, but I read this as him conveying that he relates
Posted by Cold Truth, Wed Sep-09-20 05:43 PM
directly to the issue of experiencing the pain and grief of loss to COVID, and drawing his own, separate conclusion on this issue, despite that shared experience.

I didn't read competition in that, personally.
13402952, I’m confident that he put private greed over public good
Posted by MEAT, Wed Sep-09-20 12:38 PM
Doesn’t matter what it would have or wouldn’t have changed. That’s unknowable.
13402939, RE: It's Septemeber. Dude had these tapes the whole time
Posted by Numba_33, Wed Sep-09-20 12:26 PM
>And ... sought profit.
>Fuck Bob Woodward too.


It's very sad on my part that I had Woodward in somewhat high regard, but hoarding these tapes just to pump him his book sales that probably would have been high anyway is major clownish behavior.

Sad on so many levels.

Truly, truly disturbing.
13402940, Not sure if releasing this in May would have made a difference
Posted by Mynoriti, Wed Sep-09-20 12:28 PM
and i feel your point, but i figure if he puts this out earlier it just gets added to the rest of his early fuck ups and claims that its gonna go away

now it's contrasted with the number of deaths.

that said, i don't think this will move the needle either
13402944, That's around the time when he politicized what should have never been
Posted by FLUIDJ, Wed Sep-09-20 12:32 PM
a political thing....
Not sure if it would have changed anything...but definitely couldn't have hurt.



"Get ready....for your blessing....."
"Bury me by my Grand-Grand and when you can come follow me"
13402948, Wouldn't have hurt, but i think the potential benefit is greater now
Posted by Cold Truth, Wed Sep-09-20 12:35 PM
But I think anyone who would be swayed away from him for this is minimal
13402949, this would have been washed away with everything pre george floyd.
Posted by Reeq, Wed Sep-09-20 12:35 PM
and like you said...now we have a quantifiable measure of the damage of trump playing down the virus and its something he is gonna have to defend right before the election and in debates.

its post labor day too...when most people really start paying attention to the election. so this spells out in clear detail that trumps failure to protect the american people was deliberate and blood is on his hands.

not to mention...it comes right in the midst of trump and his allies making a big deal about reporting based on anonymous sources. and now you have trump saying this shit in his own words on tape so it blows all of that hand wringing up.

if i had to choose between releasing it early or releasing it now...i still think releasing it now presents the best possible chance for a net positive outcome.
13402951, I pretty much disagree with everything you said
Posted by Numba_33, Wed Sep-09-20 12:37 PM
>that said, i don't think this will move the needle either

but if this is true, Trump will probably win in November regardless of what Biden does and America will truly get what it deserves in gifting Trump a second term, for better or for worse.
13402953, whoa, slow ya roll playboy.....
Posted by FLUIDJ, Wed Sep-09-20 12:40 PM

"Get ready....for your blessing....."
"Bury me by my Grand-Grand and when you can come follow me"
13402956, I mean
Posted by Numba_33, Wed Sep-09-20 12:44 PM
if this doesn't convince folks that Trump is completely inept for the role as President given what else has gone down in the past 3 years and change, what will?
13402957, exactly
Posted by liveguy, Wed Sep-09-20 12:45 PM
13402972, How many times have we said this the last 3 years
Posted by legsdiamond, Wed Sep-09-20 12:59 PM
13403047, hundreds, literally
Posted by Mynoriti, Wed Sep-09-20 05:25 PM
he drops that bomb in spring, it probably doesn't even make 45's greatest hits
13403050, As an American, EYE don’t deserve that shit lol...
Posted by FLUIDJ, Wed Sep-09-20 06:07 PM
13402962, I just don't see it as a smoking gun
Posted by Mynoriti, Wed Sep-09-20 12:47 PM
it's a clip in a compilation Lincoln project video.

but if I'm (hopefully) wrong and it is impactful, it's more damaging now than it would have been in spring.
13402971, To be clear
Posted by Numba_33, Wed Sep-09-20 12:57 PM
my main concern is that holding onto those tapes hurt what could have been a better response to COVID-19 at the time Trump made those comments. Trump could have been shamed into making something of a national policy for the pandemic. More importantly, more of the state and local government officials could have taken things more seriously due to how much of an absolute idiot Trump appeared to be in those same tapes. Lives could have been saved and serious quick progress could have been made much earlier on a national level. I'm not too deeply concerned about how this will or won't play in Novemeber's election.
13402978, i understand your point. i just don't agree with it
Posted by Mynoriti, Wed Sep-09-20 01:06 PM
There's not exactly a shortage of things Trump said/did to downplay and deflect this pandemic from the start. i dont see how audio of him saying he's downplaying it to avoid panic changes that. it's just another clip.

so i'm saying it would have had zero impact then but potential impact in November (though not necessarily convinced of that either)

>my main concern is that holding onto those tapes hurt what
>could have been a better response to COVID-19 at the time
>Trump made those comments. Trump could have been shamed into
>making something of a national policy for the pandemic. More
>importantly, more of the state and local government officials
>could have taken things more seriously due to how much of an
>absolute idiot Trump appeared to be in those same tapes. Lives
>could have been saved and serious quick progress could have
>been made much earlier on a national level. I'm not too deeply
>concerned about how this will or won't play in Novemeber's
>election.
13402954, Who cares what it would have changed
Posted by MEAT, Wed Sep-09-20 12:40 PM
The man undeniably withheld privileged access to vital public information for private greed.
It benefits him and his publisher and literally nobody else.
13402955, but what if it changes things *now*?
Posted by Reeq, Wed Sep-09-20 12:44 PM
what if the timing makes it more likely that trump will lose in november...and a president with actual competence and empathy comes in and saves lives that a 2nd term carefree trump never would have?
13402964, I didn’t volunteer to sacrifice two years of my life for private greed
Posted by MEAT, Wed Sep-09-20 12:49 PM
13402984, This was my first thought nm
Posted by vik, Wed Sep-09-20 01:12 PM
13402986, gotta agree with this
Posted by mista k5, Wed Sep-09-20 01:13 PM
as stupid as ive been lately i still agree with your view on this pandemic.

any amount of lives that could had been saved by releasing this back in spring would have been worth it.

the whole narrative of this pandemic could have changed. peoples behaviors could have changed.

even if nothing changed it would have been the right thing to do.
13403070, Get ready. A LOT of stuff will roll out these last few weeks.
Posted by Triptych, Wed Sep-09-20 10:04 PM
.
13403071, .
Posted by Triptych, Wed Sep-09-20 10:04 PM
.
13403072, And I'll continue to be disgusted by the elite and protected
Posted by MEAT, Wed Sep-09-20 10:28 PM
I have nothing but vitrol for people that do what's convenient and easy when the stakes require hardwork and risk
13402946, BRUH....and them dumb ass cultists won't even care (SMFH)
Posted by liveguy, Wed Sep-09-20 12:32 PM
13402959, We’re approaching 200k deaths, innumerable injuries, unable to educate
Posted by MEAT, Wed Sep-09-20 12:47 PM
Our kids safely or spend time with our families
With still no end in sight
No testing
No tracing
ANY framing that came from the highest office setting us on this path was allowed to grow because of the centering of political expediency or maximizing private gain.

Not a single one of you in here are social scientist or political scientists. Get over what you think would’ve maybe been good for November and understand how profoundly you’ve been betrayed.
13402965, had he said wear masks early on, that number would be WAY lower
Posted by liveguy, Wed Sep-09-20 12:50 PM
shit pisses me off....

and people will still try to make excuses for this clown.

Dude is a whole BOZO.

13402970, But he didn't he lied, and Bob Woodward, age 77, networth 16 milllion
Posted by MEAT, Wed Sep-09-20 12:56 PM
Sat on audio tapes for a book deal.
13403018, who's the book about? He get a pass on this?
Posted by liveguy, Wed Sep-09-20 02:59 PM
Obviously it's BIG wack that the book guy didn't say shit until his book is coming out...

BIG WACK!

But the guy who he's talking about is the ACTUAL problem.
13403022, Donald Trump isn't just bad on his own, he's enabled
Posted by MEAT, Wed Sep-09-20 03:09 PM
Bob Woodward is an enabler.
13403035, you damn sure aint wrong...but ULTIMATELY Trump still the problem
Posted by liveguy, Wed Sep-09-20 04:10 PM
13403016, .
Posted by liveguy, Wed Sep-09-20 02:56 PM
.
13402974, Dan Solomon - Writer, Texas Monthly
Posted by MEAT, Wed Sep-09-20 01:02 PM
"i can understand waiting that first month to publish this, until covid started to reshape american life dramatically even as trump continued to downplay it, but the six months after that were an abdication of woodward’s responsibility as a reporter"

https://twitter.com/dansolomon/status/1303747936715780097
13402975, Evan Hill - Visual Investigations, NY Times
Posted by MEAT, Wed Sep-09-20 01:03 PM
"I'm sorry, my mind's a little blown here. How in the world was this not immediately published in February?"

https://twitter.com/evanchill/status/1303735545718345733

13402995, you know a lot of these folks are hypocritical hacks
Posted by Reeq, Wed Sep-09-20 01:28 PM
who instinctively attack other outlets who scoop them right?

like the way they circled the wagons to discredit outlets like buzzfeed multiple times for trump/russia/barr/etc stories but rush to defend haberman, peter baker, etc.

where was this nytimes dude when nytimes reporter michael schmidt held on to several important scoops for his recent book?

like the trump walter reed hospital visit being so serious that pence had to be placed on standby?
https://twitter.com/CNN/status/1300599297721937927

or the mueller investigation being secretly/intentionally curtailed by rosenstein to prevent mueller from exploring trumps financial ties russia?
https://twitter.com/nytmike/status/1300085848596262912

now those stories are now past the point where people even care about them. but they could have done a lot of good if the public was knowledgeable when schmidt actually got hold of the scoop.

this woodward story still has the potential to do more good than any of the schmidt shit he held in the chamber.

they can spare me the selective outrage.
13402999, Send me the Evan Hill link of his personal hypocrisy
Posted by MEAT, Wed Sep-09-20 01:34 PM
Meanwhile I blocked that dude NYTMike long ago

AND

"So you sat on critical information for years, information that you only obtained through access and privilege afforded to you as a journalist, and instead of recognizing the existential threat of what you’re learning you’ve sought profit for salaciousness?"

https://twitter.com/DME123456789/status/1300416678698852359

This is me

Which is posted as soon as the leaks from his book came out too
13403005, how can i send you a link of something he never did?
Posted by Reeq, Wed Sep-09-20 02:01 PM
he never said a peep about his stable mate mike schmidt doing the same thing that has him on his fainting couch when it comes to woodward.

good on *you* for being consistent tho (sincerely). a lot of these journalists and poli commentators arent nearly as principled.
13402977, zeynep tufekci- Writer at @TheAtlantic @NYTimes . Was @SciAm @Wired
Posted by MEAT, Wed Sep-09-20 01:05 PM
Wait, what? Woodward had Trump on tape that the coronavirus was airborne BACK IN FEBRUARY (seems he learned this from Xi) and sat on it, presumably to release his book closer to the election? As we've been saying, the US crisis is elite failure *across* the political spectrum.

https://twitter.com/zeynep/status/1303747775037923331
13402981, Tom Moore - Former Senior Professional Staff Member, US Senate Foreign Relations Committee
Posted by MEAT, Wed Sep-09-20 01:08 PM
How long did Bob Woodward sit on that recording?
And I hope he's asked whether he thought about releasing it, sooner, given that over 190k of us have died, now.

https://twitter.com/PaperMissiles/status/1303741503991353344
13402987, Ryan Goodman - Former Special Counsel @DeptofDefense . Co-editor-in-chief @just_security . Chaired Professor NYU Law. Former Chaired Professor Harvard Law. Co-director @RCLS_NYU
Posted by MEAT, Wed Sep-09-20 01:13 PM
We just added Woodward revelations to Timeline

One item:

Feb. 7: Trump tells Woodward he knows of airborne risks and covid is worse than worst flus

Feb 10-Mar 2, 2020: Trump holds five #MAGA rallies each attracting thousands of people in confined spaces


https://twitter.com/rgoodlaw/status/1303751123661213700
13403008, is it me or does biden seem sharper than usual lately?
Posted by Reeq, Wed Sep-09-20 02:35 PM
https://twitter.com/richardhine/status/1303762581220454403

i gotta give him and his campaign credit. the rapid response has been on point lately with the woodward story, the military losers/suckers story, etc.

it usually takes dems a short while to get their consultant conference calls, non committal non offensive legally strict attack language, etc in order.

but biden has been coming right out with pointed attacks and specific information to effectively support them.

to the point that trump supporters are alleging theres a conspiracy to give biden the news drops beforehand so he can pre-empt his messaging and be ready to go (something that the trump admin and fox news actually do).
13403013, seems like normal biden to me.
Posted by BrooklynWHAT, Wed Sep-09-20 02:52 PM
13403010, leaked email: hhs trying to stop fauci from detailing covid risk to kids.
Posted by Reeq, Wed Sep-09-20 02:44 PM
https://www.politico.com/news/2020/09/09/emails-show-hhs-muzzle-fauci-410861

dudes tryna prevent widespread testing of school kids and university students smh.
13403023, few thoughts...first, I don't ever want to hear run to the middle
Posted by Stadiq, Wed Sep-09-20 03:11 PM
to win the Presidency ever again in my life if Trump wins. If Trump beats Joe fucking Biden, there literally is no middle.

If "the middle" and/or moderate republicans can't be swayed by everything from this to kids in cages, then FUCK them.

This election won't be proof that "run to the middle" is the best strategy in my mind even if Joe wins, but if Trump STILL wins then get that 80's political egg head shit out of here.


#2 Its odd that we are so programmed to view everything through the lens of an election now. There is no question Woodard should have released these back in Feb or whatever. No question he waited for his own gain. That is fucking evil no matter how you slice it. Even if something good comes out of it, its still fucking evil.

"Its good he waited"...oh word? He waited for his paycheck, and people died, got severely ill, kids can't go to school, etc.



#3 Because he waited, the right is going to shift the convo on this to "Why now? Where has this been" etc etc. Its going to be painted as opportunistic, etc.

13403030, Thank you
Posted by MEAT, Wed Sep-09-20 03:32 PM
13403137, Trump has melted brains. Everyone from the FBI to W to authors trying to
Posted by Stadiq, Thu Sep-10-20 12:52 PM
pad their pockets to any Republican who will say anything remotely critical of Trump have become folk heroes to some.

This Woodward is a hero shit is sort of reminding me of the "Its Mueller Time" memes that flooded my timeline from some pretty hardcore lefties.

Hardcore liberals were literally treating the FBI like the Avengers were assembling...how'd that turn out?

The FBI, Woodward, Bush (lol), Scaramucci, Romney, whoever...these dues are not your friends.

I don't know how anyone could tell someone who lost a loved one to COVID - or really anyone for that matter- that sitting on damning information that might have saved lives was the right call because it *might* help sway the mythical moderate. The same moderate who wasn't quite swayed by kids in cages, white supremacy, grabbing pussies, bromance with Putin, etc...

Especially considering he didn't sit on it for the election, he sat on it for his fucking book.

13403138, Yoooo
Posted by mista k5, Thu Sep-10-20 01:03 PM
>This Woodward is a hero shit is sort of reminding me of the
>"Its Mueller Time" memes that flooded my timeline from some
>pretty hardcore lefties.
>

:(

Gotta throw away my button if I ever come across it again lol
13403142, I fundamentally understand the need for hope and optimism
Posted by MEAT, Thu Sep-10-20 01:27 PM
But I admit to getting lost when everything can be ascribed to "the greater good"

Like, good for whom and by what metric?

And then accordingly, we're only scratching the surface of how bad things are. Imagine the things we don't know.

13403024, trump: ted cruz, tom cotton, and josh hawley on my supreme court list
Posted by Reeq, Wed Sep-09-20 03:11 PM
https://twitter.com/dcexaminer/status/1303785976783921152

if any of you are still thinking about sitting out the election.

this is basically what hitler did with the nazi 'peoples court'. install political allies as judges to legislate from the bench and drum up preordained politically beneficial rulings.

it also shows how extreme trump/conservatives are where even the suggestion of this is perfectly fine because they believe that the current slate of right wing activist judges isnt radical enough.

edit: tom cotton deliberately posted this after the announcement.
https://twitter.com/TomCottonAR/status/1303786807692124160
13403027, There should be a fine of $10000000 for sitting this election out
Posted by Bambino Grande, Wed Sep-09-20 03:14 PM
13403040, this is how they change the news...
Posted by Trinity444, Wed Sep-09-20 04:21 PM
I’m only familiar wit cruz
how bad are the other two?


13403041, Great point.
Posted by Brew, Wed Sep-09-20 04:27 PM
RE: this is how they change the news...
13403045, Cotton is just as evil as Trump, and more intelligent
Posted by makaveli, Wed Sep-09-20 05:05 PM
13403042, all Bob Woodward's fault
Posted by Mynoriti, Wed Sep-09-20 04:35 PM
13403056, “Woodward...initially was reluctant to speak on the record until after a “60 Minutes” segment airs on Sunday because he had promised the publisher and CBS not to give any interviews until then.
Posted by MEAT, Wed Sep-09-20 07:31 PM
“Woodward...initially was reluctant to speak on the record until after a “60 Minutes” segment airs on Sunday because he had promised the publisher and CBS not to give any interviews until then.”
https://twitter.com/s_m_i/status/1303845053492850688?s=21
13403061, Damn
Posted by Lurkmode, Wed Sep-09-20 09:03 PM
Woodward is a pos
13403074, never mind liberty etc as a way of life..he had a business pact
Posted by rdhull, Wed Sep-09-20 11:14 PM
>“Woodward...initially was reluctant to speak on the record
>until after a “60 Minutes” segment airs on Sunday because
>he had promised the publisher and CBS not to give any
>interviews until then.”
>https://twitter.com/s_m_i/status/1303845053492850688?s=21
>
13403099, AS LONG AS HE VOTES!!!!!!
Posted by Walleye, Thu Sep-10-20 09:52 AM
Fascinating somebody like Woodward who has done such historical work describing the relationship between the forest and the trees to so utterly miss the point here.

The ethical principal seems pretty simple: if you have evidence that the President is lying in a way that directly leads to people's death, you should share it as soon as possible to prevent future deaths.

Not every fucking thing is about an election.
13403102, ...but WE knew he was lying...right...?
Posted by bentagain, Thu Sep-10-20 09:59 AM
It’s a tough call IRT when to go public

and as hard as it may be for some to admit

IMO, if Woodward releases this info months ago...it wouldn’t have any impact

It’s almost as if the body count is the evidence, proof of his lies.

It’s f’d up, but I think it had to play out this way to even make a dent in the bubble

...and even closing in on 200K deaths, folks are still defending it...

i.e. the information WAS out there

The people that believed his lies wouldn’t have given this interview a second thought if it was released months earlier, IMO

Feels like people are projecting onto Woodward here

He’s not the problem.
13403104, What we knew was that he was contradicting available information and
Posted by MEAT, Thu Sep-10-20 10:05 AM
Seeding doubt. What we didn't know was that he was saying one thing in private audience and then saying the complete opposite to the public, relentlessly.

It's the reason that Burr disappeared from public eye (in addition to the stock trading, actually in align with the stock trading) because he was downplaying the severity in public, while advising private people to bunker down.
13403113, Right...but we knew that too...right...?
Posted by bentagain, Thu Sep-10-20 10:11 AM
The stories about the stock dumps were published around the same time

In February...?

https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2020/4/1/21202900/kelly-loeffler-stock-sales-coronavirus-pandemic

Feinstein was in there too

I’m saying, Woodward releases this info...whenever people think it was appropriate

It doesn’t have the impact.

Attacking the messenger is way down on the bottom of the priority list in light of this revelation
13403115, Stock dumps are not direct and contradictory audio tapes
Posted by MEAT, Thu Sep-10-20 10:15 AM
Your partner goes for an STD test even though it’s only been y’all two for a year, plausible deniability but shaky and suspicious.

Your partner is on tape with a newspaper clipping of the date getting fucked, no plausible deniability.

And again, my point has been that impact is unknowable, sense of duty and scope of responsibility have to form people’s core ... and it doesn’t for the most part.
13403117, The death toll is the STD in your analogy
Posted by bentagain, Thu Sep-10-20 10:22 AM
It is the proof that he lied to the public
13403120, It's not. No.
Posted by MEAT, Thu Sep-10-20 10:26 AM
13403109, "Impact" is providing noise, not context here
Posted by Walleye, Thu Sep-10-20 10:09 AM
Our moral action in the world is often fucked up and messy, owing largely to the chaotically woven relationships of power in the modern world. That makes deciding the right course of action difficult, so I'm open to a reading of this whole thing that sounds like "I believe his intentions were good but Bob Woodward really fucked this up."

But anything short of that means reducing the weight of *any* of our decisions to endlessly speculative conversation about impact when there's a pretty clear, concrete way to evaluate what Woodward's decision meant here. The federal government abdicated their responsibility on COVID, which means that people were left on their own to take care of themselves.

So, if sharing this audio back when it was recorded would have prevented the loss of a single person's life by simply convincing them, as an individual, not to believe the President and to treat COVID as a serious threat to their life, then that's the relevant site to evaluate "impact." He took a pass on that. If it was for profit, he's vile and should repent before God. If it was because he got twisted about what the right way to reveal this was, then he chose wrong - and we should make sure to tell him so.
13403116, RE: if sharing this audio back when it was recorded
Posted by bentagain, Thu Sep-10-20 10:16 AM
That’s the question I’m asking

...and given the defense today by some...

Do you really think it changes anyones mind in Feb?

I think you’re underestimating how dug in these people are

Herman Cain is dead.
13403122, I don't think Trump supporters are the only ones in play
Posted by Walleye, Thu Sep-10-20 10:32 AM
Our psychotic discourse notwithstanding, the American political landscape is wall to wall normal people. We can't give up on normal people, or we'll lose for good. But maybe more importantly: normal people trust the federal government on an instinctual, not an intellectual level. It's the great gift and curse of post-war liberalism - they created institutions that appeared so trustworthy for so long that normal people take their proper function for granted. I think what that means practically speaking is that normal people will understand and accept something as undeniably true as "The President is a giant liar" but not really assimilate that information into a pattern of action because every moment of normal people's lives in contemporary liberalism has been built on believing the government just won't let them die. So put aside Trump supporters for a moment and think of the people who blithely assume that of course the federal government has their interest and safety at heart. Some of those people believed the President because believing the President is what Americans are trained to do.

Some of those people got sick and died. And I think they were very reachable and that knowing this would have helped.

I could be wrong, but we'll never know because the decision was made for us.
13403166, Where’s the outrage?
Posted by bentagain, Thu Sep-10-20 04:20 PM
I’m going to ASSume even people’s political affiliation determined their personal response to COVID

The normal people I know...I haven’t seen in months

i.e. they took it seriously

If the Woodward reveal was a gotcha moment for a bunch of normal people....

...where’s the outrage...

?

I was legit worried leaving the house today

This should trigger a rebellion...bigger than the BLM/Floyd protests...

?

To your point, I am terrified that intelligence was altered

It’s a moment of reckoning...he corrupted the whole damn thing.
13403106, RE: AS LONG AS HE VOTES!!!!!!
Posted by Numba_33, Thu Sep-10-20 10:07 AM
>Fascinating somebody like Woodward who has done such
>historical work describing the relationship between the forest
>and the trees to so utterly miss the point here.
>
>The ethical principal seems pretty simple: if you have
>evidence that the President is lying in a way that directly
>leads to people's death, you should share it as soon as
>possible to prevent future deaths.
>
>Not every fucking thing is about an election.


In addition to that, Woodward already has a proven record in terms of his in-house White House books from his past works. He didn't have to sit on those tapes just for the sake of pumping up his royalty checks.

I wonder how many folks will boycott buying this upcoming book out of principle of being irate with the dude.
13403112, Far fewer than should. America is largely addicted to palace intrigue and
Posted by MEAT, Thu Sep-10-20 10:11 AM
Gossip. I don’t think we’re unique in that aspect, but I know that as a whole we treat the role of government as people we’re accountable to rather than public servants that are beholden to us.
13403059, remember this?
Posted by makaveli, Wed Sep-09-20 08:00 PM
These people are monsters. Please read this if you are one of those people who decided not to vote.

https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2020/07/how-jared-kushners-secret-testing-plan-went-poof-into-thin-air
13403174, wow
Posted by ThaTruth, Thu Sep-10-20 04:37 PM
13403141, LMAO...now Trump saying “Why didn’t Woodward say anything?”
Posted by liveguy, Thu Sep-10-20 01:12 PM
This is all Woodward’s fault. HAHAHAHAHA!

GTFOH
13403146, Why do we keep letting conservative news change the subject
Posted by select_from_where, Thu Sep-10-20 01:54 PM
BOB WOODWARD is not the present of the united states?

Why do we fall for this every single time.
13403147, I KNEW he was gonna use that angle too...talking points for his cult
Posted by liveguy, Thu Sep-10-20 01:58 PM
13403150, All the shit Trump said on tape and still none w/ him using the N-word
Posted by Airbreed, Thu Sep-10-20 02:16 PM
yet there's plenty of hearsay of him using it.

strange.
13403152, Same deal. Wouldnt matter and ppl would be more mad at whoever sat on it
Posted by Mynoriti, Thu Sep-10-20 02:27 PM
13403156, Wouldn't matter to those people.
Posted by Cold Truth, Thu Sep-10-20 03:04 PM
Ideally, it would bring some people out of the woodwork to vote against him, but I don't see any awful- ahem, deplorable- thing that he can say or do that would case any significant portion of his base to turn against him, and THEN vote Biden.

I think he can say that word in camera, and they'd either call it a deep fake, or justify it. They'll say some stupid shit about how god can use even the most deeply flawed people for the greater good of his people and his glory, and the USA itself.

Others would simply say that Black people say it all the time, and the hyper woke lefty liberal commie snowflakes have a double standard.

Others still? They'd be fucking overjoyed at the President saying that shit on camera, because they'd see it as yet another green light to do what they do.... but more, and more overtly.

yes, there's still quite a lot of headroom for people to be more gleefully and overtly racist, and they'd use it as an excuse to eat up more of that space.

He could, on video, call his base as a bunch of illiterate, superstitious. cousin fucking morons who vote for him because they're too stupid to realize he's only using them for political power, and that he wipes his ass from his morning shit with pages from the bible....

.....And they'd say that he's no different from any other politician, they're all manipulative liars, and that he's still better than that ultra liberal socialist Joe Biden.
13403300, Totally agree.
Posted by Airbreed, Fri Sep-11-20 02:18 PM
>Ideally, it would bring some people out of the woodwork to
>vote against him, but I don't see any awful- ahem, deplorable-
>thing that he can say or do that would case any significant
>portion of his base to turn against him, and THEN vote Biden.
>
>I think he can say that word in camera, and they'd either call
>it a deep fake, or justify it. They'll say some stupid shit
>about how god can use even the most deeply flawed people for
>the greater good of his people and his glory, and the USA
>itself.
>
>Others would simply say that Black people say it all the time,
>and the hyper woke lefty liberal commie snowflakes have a
>double standard.
>
>Others still? They'd be fucking overjoyed at the President
>saying that shit on camera, because they'd see it as yet
>another green light to do what they do.... but more, and more
>overtly.
>
>yes, there's still quite a lot of headroom for people to be
>more gleefully and overtly racist, and they'd use it as an
>excuse to eat up more of that space.
>
>He could, on video, call his base as a bunch of illiterate,
>superstitious. cousin fucking morons who vote for him because
>they're too stupid to realize he's only using them for
>political power, and that he wipes his ass from his morning
>shit with pages from the bible....
>
>.....And they'd say that he's no different from any other
>politician, they're all manipulative liars, and that he's
>still better than that ultra liberal socialist Joe Biden.
13403173, I doubt if he used it a lot publicly he had a lot black celeb "friends"...
Posted by ThaTruth, Thu Sep-10-20 04:36 PM
before he got into politics even though he's always said thinly veiled racists things going back to the stuff with the Central Park 5
13403301, RE: I doubt if he used it a lot publicly he had a lot black celeb "friends"...
Posted by Airbreed, Fri Sep-11-20 02:21 PM
>before he got into politics even though he's always said
>thinly veiled racists things going back to the stuff with the
>Central Park 5

true. he's smart at how he uses his words. while it never seems like its thought out and just a scatted mess, he knows how to get his racist pov out without it being in black and white.
13403158, RE: Trump Admitted On Tape To Intentionally Downplaying Covid Threat
Posted by MEAT, Thu Sep-10-20 03:21 PM
"Woodward tells us — but they too remained silent.

And so, for the most part, does Woodward himself. His scoops derive from his ability to convince people who should know better that he’s really on their side; it’s a journalistic technique that requires the reporter to flatter rather than challenge.

At times, he even seems to slip from obsequiousness into the role of mentor: listening to Trump’s justifications for his request that the Ukrainian president launch an investigation of Joe Biden, for instance, Woodward pauses his questions to offer Trump some unsolicited advice. “I’m going to tell you something from my experience,” he says. “I’m telling you, from too many decades of experience in cases like this, if you apologized it would go away.” Trump naturally ignores this guidance, but the reader can’t help but wonder: Why is a journalist giving political counsel to the subject of his reporting?

Later, in another bizarre exchange, Woodward urges Trump to display a tad more empathy toward racial justice protesters. (The president, true to form, has been exulting in his ability “to send in the military” to deal with the protesters, whom he describes, variously, as “these poor radical lefts” and as “arsonists . . . thugs . . . anarchists” and “very bad people.”) Woodward, in response, attempts to explain “White privilege” to an incredulous Trump. “Do you have any sense that that privilege has isolated ?” the reporter asks. “And that we have to work our way out of it to understand the anger and the pain, particularly, Black people feel?”


https://www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/woodwards-rage-is-a-damning-account-of-trumps-cowering-sycophants-and-enablers/2020/09/10/dab8917a-f2d6-11ea-bc45-e5d48ab44b9f_story.html
13403165, Here's our own thread from February to March
Posted by MEAT, Thu Sep-10-20 04:18 PM
https://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=18&topic_id=210457

Search for the words aerosol or droplets
There's a tidbit in there about the CDC not recommending masks too
13403167, how does democracy end?
Posted by Trinity444, Thu Sep-10-20 04:21 PM
we’re living in that moment...

a sister (I forget her name) on msnbc made the point

interesting...

13403170, The more accurate question would be "how will the US end ?"
Posted by Brew, Thu Sep-10-20 04:25 PM
Because we've literally never been even close to a true "democracy" despite what we project out to ourselves and the world.

But either way the point is well taken.
13403168, Here's our own thread from April to May
Posted by MEAT, Thu Sep-10-20 04:23 PM
https://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=18&topic_id=211516

Again, search for aerosol and droplets and even masks

Or this gem

May 9th, Fed government turned down offer to make masks
https://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=18&topic_id=211516#211782

13403169, And this is MONTHS after there were tapes
Posted by MEAT, Thu Sep-10-20 04:24 PM
You don't think you could've helped ONE or your family members, friends or coworkers by having 2-3 months of demanding masks?

Ok
13403171, Here we are on OKP, May 28th when we started talking about aerosols
Posted by MEAT, Thu Sep-10-20 04:27 PM
https://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=4&topic_id=13385552&mesg_id=13385552&listing_type=search

From Backbone

https://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=4&topic_id=13385552&mesg_id=13385552&listing_type=search#13385955

13403181, What are we supposed to do with this information besides get mad?
Posted by legsdiamond, Thu Sep-10-20 07:10 PM
Who is shocked by this info?

Who didn’t know this shit?

What the fuck would have changed?

Trump is a POS. We all knew he knew how serious it was and he was playing politics with it.

We’re 200K in and Americans refuse to mask up.
13403189, Yup
Posted by wiseguy, Thu Sep-10-20 07:31 PM
13403188, Not at all surprised
Posted by wiseguy, Thu Sep-10-20 07:29 PM
.
13403209, Trump: Woodward could've saved lives if he reported my lies sooner (link)
Posted by BrooklynWHAT, Fri Sep-11-20 08:49 AM
https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2020/09/donald-trump-bob-woodward-criticism

Donald J. Trump
@realDonaldTrump
Bob Woodward had my quotes for many months. If he thought they were so bad or dangerous, why didn’t he immediately report them in an effort to save lives? Didn’t he have an obligation to do so? No, because he knew they were good and proper answers. Calm, no panic!
13403262, "the giant caravan of ms13s and rapists are coming to get us!" guy says..
Posted by Mynoriti, Fri Sep-11-20 11:37 AM
he's all about no panic.
13403263, well yeah, that too
Posted by will_5198, Fri Sep-11-20 11:39 AM
fuck Bob Woodward.
13403267, In a just society, they'd both be locked up for this.
Posted by Brotha Sun, Fri Sep-11-20 11:49 AM
13403281, this what I mean by clever...
Posted by Trinity444, Fri Sep-11-20 12:30 PM
like, this fool just created a “reasonable doubt“ type thing.

even some that know the deal are giving a nod

by calling for Woodward’s head...








13403328, - 23% say opinion changed of Trump’s COVID response because of Woodward tape, including 15% of Trump voters - 23% of indys and 6% of Trump voters say troop comments increased support for Biden - B
Posted by MEAT, Fri Sep-11-20 06:43 PM
- 23% say opinion changed of Trump’s COVID response because of Woodward tape, including 15% of Trump voters

- 23% of indys and 6% of Trump voters say troop comments increased support for Biden

- Biden goes from +6 to +10

https://twitter.com/jonfavs/status/1304552152568754177?s=20
13403844, smh.
Posted by Dr Claw, Thu Sep-17-20 06:16 AM
I got nothing. This guy..... there is no end to the depravity.

and as others have said, I wonder why Woodward sat on this until now.
13403851, Ryan Knight Types: But, But, the DNC!
Posted by Amritsar, Thu Sep-17-20 07:30 AM
Blue MAGA is just as bad
13403860, the actual 'Blue MAGA' = Donut Twitter/Blue No Matter Who types
Posted by Dr Claw, Thu Sep-17-20 09:08 AM
the ones who uncritically inhale MSNBC programming and especially the "Russiagate" (as 2016 root cause of failure) bullshit.

and even Ryan would acknowledge Trump being colossal failure here.

NO ONE admits the "white voter" problem we have in this country though. Either party of the duopoly, and much of the left alike.
13403959, join our movement for a peoples party!
Posted by Reeq, Thu Sep-17-20 02:20 PM
have you seen that shit?

its like the lefty grifter avengers.

https://peoplesparty.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/ConventionSquares2020_FB-980x515.jpg

13403935, this + the USPS leak (USPS was going to send masks to people)
Posted by Dr Claw, Thu Sep-17-20 12:40 PM
back in April...

Plus the stuff we know they reported back in the spring/summer about Kushner hoarding supplies and basically being a middle man to the middle men across the country.

.... just get these motherfuckers outta here. However.
13403934, this + the USPS leak (USPS was going to send masks to people)
Posted by Dr Claw, Thu Sep-17-20 12:40 PM
back in April...

Plus the stuff we know they reported back in the spring/summer about Kushner hoarding supplies and basically being a middle man to the middle men across the country.

.... just get these motherfuckers outta here. However.
13403960, this
Posted by Ashy Achilles, Thu Sep-17-20 02:34 PM
>.... just get these motherfuckers outta here. However.
13403961, thx doc. happy to see this.
Posted by Reeq, Thu Sep-17-20 02:36 PM
>.... just get these motherfuckers outta here. However.
13404003, Pences fmr. lead staffer on the COVID taskforce quit, endorsed Biden...
Posted by navajo joe, Fri Sep-18-20 08:44 AM
https://twitter.com/briantylercohen/status/1306689312033890304?s=20

13404011, "Now I don't have to shake hands with these disgusting people" HAHA
Posted by Brew, Fri Sep-18-20 09:51 AM
They are disgusting, he's right. Because they support him.