Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby Okay Sports topic #2711421

Subject: "Is Eli Manning a HOF’er?" Previous topic | Next topic
ThaTruth
Charter member
99998 posts 		Wed Jan-29-20 07:30 PM

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
"Poll question: Is Eli Manning a HOF’er?"


          

I didn’t think he was but I guess they’re running out of things to talk about in Miami...

Poll result (20 votes)
Yes (9 votes)Vote
No (11 votes)Vote

  

  
Printer-friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote


Is Eli Manning a HOF’er? [View all] , ThaTruth, Wed Jan-29-20 07:30 PM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
he will be 100%
Jan 29th 2020
1
RE: Is Eli Manning a HOF’er?
Jan 29th 2020
2
Is he?.. hell no. Will he get in?.. you know he will.
Jan 30th 2020
3
^^^
Jan 30th 2020
8
2 rings + 2 SB MVPs = Yes.
Jan 30th 2020
4
Not to mention the most important factor, his last name
Jan 30th 2020
5
its the only factor. breh was bang average most of his career.
Jan 30th 2020
10
      you can be great with average stats
Jan 30th 2020
16
           but he wasnt great tho.
Jan 30th 2020
19
           He was great. Not statistically or body-language wise
Jan 30th 2020
23
           2 rings, 2 SB MVPs, 210 consecutive starts
Jan 31st 2020
32
was he ever at any point in his career considered a top 5 QB ?
Jan 30th 2020
7
Sorry dude, huge sports market rode with him way longer than
Jan 30th 2020
6
Dude beat the Patriots twice in SB’s
Jan 30th 2020
9
I feel like Frank Gore is similar, when you hear his name you don't...
Jan 30th 2020
11
Frank is way better
Jan 31st 2020
31
      waaaay better
Jan 31st 2020
33
A 'Manning' with 2 SB wins against the NFL pyrite standard
Jan 30th 2020
12
I'd love to see honest and open Giants fans
Jan 30th 2020
13
Giants ruined the last 6-7 years of Eli’s career with TRASH OLines
Jan 30th 2020
14
^^^^
Jan 30th 2020
17
Also the giants defense is the reason why those SB teams were so great.
Jan 30th 2020
21
      Giants defense stunk most of the season in 2011
Jan 30th 2020
28
maybe if he retired after the 2nd SB win or shortly thereafter
Jan 30th 2020
15
He is, but as others have alluded to, he shouldn't be
Jan 30th 2020
18
2nd SB had the pass to Manningham
Jan 30th 2020
20
      RE: 2nd SB had the pass to Manningham
Jan 30th 2020
22
      Decent catch too
Jan 30th 2020
25
           No question
Jan 30th 2020
30
No
Jan 30th 2020
24
Being the 1 in 18-1 kinda made it possible
Jan 30th 2020
26
Without the SBs, he's probably less likely than Matt Ryan.
Jan 30th 2020
27
Dome numbers vs. Meadowlands numbers is a factor
Jan 30th 2020
29
the irony of two awards that were won by default
Jan 31st 2020
34
      30-40 for 296, 0 turnovers - thats MVP worthy numbers
Jan 31st 2020
35
           RE: 30-40 for 296, 0 turnovers - thats MVP worthy numbers
Jan 31st 2020
36
           Those are some of the worst numbers for a SB MVP in the modern era
Jan 31st 2020
37
                I was about to say lol...
Jan 31st 2020
38

Lobby Okay Sports topic #2711421 Previous topic | Next topic
   

Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com