Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby Okay Sports topic #2193369

Subject: "does Andy Pettitte get in the Hall of fame?" Previous topic | Next topic
mistermaxxx08
Member since Dec 31st 2010
16076 posts 		Sat Jun-08-13 07:54 PM

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
"Poll question: does Andy Pettitte get in the Hall of fame?"


          

he got 250 wins,

got Jewelry

been clutch all of his career

and a proven winner.

plays for the best team in Baseball period.

no bias here just asking a question

Poll result (17 votes)
yes (5 votes)Vote
no (12 votes)Vote
yankee Hof and only a Yankee fan would ask this question (0 votes)Vote

  

  
Printer-friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote


does Andy Pettitte get in the Hall of fame? [View all] , mistermaxxx08, Sat Jun-08-13 07:54 PM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
if we're keeping known drug users out of the HOF
Jun 08th 2013
1
you know nothing ever been proven
Jun 08th 2013
2
      didnt he admit to it?
Jun 08th 2013
3
           he did and yet he got back in the game
Jun 08th 2013
4
                its been forgotten cause he fessed up and came up w/a BS excuse
Jun 08th 2013
5
                RE: its been forgotten cause he fessed up and came up w/a BS excuse
Jun 08th 2013
7
                RE: he did and yet he got back in the game
Jun 08th 2013
6
most playoff wins too
Jun 08th 2013
8
^^^^^^
Jun 09th 2013
10
Not a good enough peak for me
Jun 08th 2013
9
Brad Radke had more 5+ bWAR seasons
Jun 09th 2013
12
      You Blyleveners Really Need To Shed That Seamhead Morris Hate Already
Jun 13th 2013
21
           What about when he beat Jack Morris in the '87 ALCS?
Jun 13th 2013
22
           http://splicd.com/csDM1MQ7Wt8/07/20
Jun 15th 2013
30
           Blyleven went 5-1 with a 2.43 ERA in the postseason and won 2 rings
Jun 13th 2013
27
                Your fine post was improved with the avy/sig combination
Jun 13th 2013
28
He is borderline to me, workhorse that pitched forever, won playoffs
Jun 09th 2013
11
Yeah, he's a prototypical "Hall of Very Good" dude.
Jun 13th 2013
24
      i actually dont think he will make it
Jun 13th 2013
25
No, not a high enough peak to go with the longevity
Jun 09th 2013
13
Plus how many No. 3 starters are in Cooperstown?
Jun 13th 2013
20
w/a ticket....
Jun 09th 2013
14
Posnanski: Andy Pettitte and the Van Doren gene
Jun 13th 2013
15
RE: Posnanski: Andy Pettitte and the Van Doren gene
Jun 13th 2013
16
      Also, something should be said about AL East pitching in roid era too
Jun 13th 2013
17
      Kevin Brown's ERA went up when he was 39-40?
Jun 13th 2013
18
           he was a high 3 low 4 era pitcher, went to the NL and shaved a run
Jun 14th 2013
29
      That perception is pretty common
Jun 13th 2013
19
           I never thought twice about it, Kevin Brown was a better pitcher
Jun 13th 2013
26
He gets in
Jun 13th 2013
23

Lobby Okay Sports topic #2193369 Previous topic | Next topic
   

Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com