Didn't really know what to expect from this but really enjoying the concept. The show also gets high marks for casting Rawls as McNulty's father-in-law.
It feels like the kind of show that is going to be worth a rewatch when it is over so you can pick up on little things. For instance, I noticed that in the girl's retelling in epsiode 2, she might have dropped a fact that means the guy's retelling in episode 1 has some truth to it. I'm assuming the truth is somewhere in between the two versions but it's been a intriguing ride so far.