Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby Pass The Popcorn topic #744092

Subject: "Because the Infinity Gaunlet and a wish are different things" Previous topic | Next topic
Cold Truth
Member since Jan 28th 2004
45001 posts
Wed Sep-28-22 08:48 PM

Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
34. "Because the Infinity Gaunlet and a wish are different things"
In response to In response to 32
Wed Sep-28-22 08:50 PM by Cold Truth

  

          

>Like they introduce this idea/person "Eternity" and all of a
>sudden, after years of the MCU, we learn about this being who
>can grant any wish?

Not sure I get the issue here. Damn near every discovery can be reduced to "all of a sudden". Because things have to already exist, in order to be discovered. It's just peeling back another curtain, unveiling a bit more of this world, and it's inhabitants.

>Well why didn't Thanos use Eternity to
>wipe out half the universe?

Easy: He didn't know how to reach Eternity, but DID know how to obtain the Infinity gems. He went with the goal that seemed more readily obtainable.

Or he knew of Eternity, but thought it was a myth.

There are any number of plausible explanations.

>Why didn't the Avengers use
>Eternity to fix what Thanos did?

Most problems likely have more than one solution.

Why not ask this question of every solution one doesn't choose?

It's not much of a problem at all. And again, any number of possible reasons exist. But the movie actually answers this: they didn't understand that Thor could use the Bifrost to reach Eternity until Jane noticed some old drawings that showed this happening.

Just because a potential solution exists, does not mean that everyone automatically knows how to reach it.

It's nothing to believe that Thanos knew of Eternity, but simply wasn't entirely sure it existed, or how to get to it- but had much more sure knowledge of the existence of the Infinity stones, and a more realistic plan to obtain them.

Easy.

>>Why hasn't every villain to
>date been trying to track down Eternity?!?!

Why doesn't every thief steal crypto instead of whatever it is they stole?

Why doesn't everyone make the exact right decision at all times?

It stands to reason, exercise and healthy diet yield significant positive results, so why are junk food and streaming media multi-billion dollar industries?

The answer is simple: people, and life in general, are complex.

Do you think Vulture, Killmonger, Whiplash, Hydra, etc, *all* know Eternity exists?

OF those who do, is there any rational reason to assume most of them knew how to get there?

Everyone has their own agenda, and their own reasons. So even those who did know- and we have no reason to assume anyone knew enough to actually make it happen- likely craved something different.

>Like you introduce out of nowhere this MacGuffin problem

It's not out of nowhere though. It's just something we hadn't seen until now. A gazillion things exist in the comics, and it's a matter of time before a lot of them wind up in an MCU movie. They're not coming out of nowhere, just because we're only just now learning of them.

You could argue that Kang "came out of nowhere", because we didn't discover his existence until Loki. It's no different.

>solved by a MacGuffin solution and everything is the same at
>the end. It just seems like lazy story telling.

what's the MacFuffin though? The Necro Sword? Eternity itelf? Neither of these are unimportant. Stakes are definitely high here. Hell, those stakes are why Zeus wanted no part of the mission.

The light, silly nature of the film doesn't really change th weight of those stakes.

>And damn if its not another movie where the Power of Love
>saves the day.

That's what superhero movies are, damn near by definition.

The love one *hero* had for the other, as well as *humanity*, drove said heroes action. But it's not like love itself was some magical spell. It was still driven by actions- but most superhero movies are, to an extent, a series of actions driven by one person's love for someone or something.

  

Printer-friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote


Thor: Love and Thunder (Takia Watiti, 2022) [View all] , bwood, Mon Apr-18-22 09:16 AM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
I dunno…literally everything looks CG except the actors
Apr 18th 2022
1
Did you not watch the last movie?
Apr 19th 2022
2
Looks like another winner
Apr 22nd 2022
3
New trailer
May 24th 2022
4
Christian Bale looks PHENOMENAL
May 24th 2022
5
I'm renting a theatre for this one too!!
May 24th 2022
6
It's great.
Jun 29th 2022
7
Good to hear. How do you think it fares for the summer movie season?
Jun 30th 2022
8
Fuck no it's not better than TG: M.
Jun 30th 2022
9
Maverick is on another planet from this.
Jul 09th 2022
15
Glad to hear they handled Gorr well
Jun 30th 2022
10
Lol I just came out of OKretirement to check for your review
Jun 30th 2022
11
it was ok, I wasn't aware that this one was geared more towards kids...
Jul 08th 2022
12
Thought it was great. Bale was brilliant in it
Jul 08th 2022
13
It’s fine. Wish these movies had any weight whatsoever.
Jul 09th 2022
14
RE: It’s fine. Wish these movies had any weight whatsoever.
Jul 17th 2022
19
      I think Gunn does a good job at striking a balance.
Jul 17th 2022
20
           I know I'm on an island alone here...
Jul 17th 2022
22
Praise the almighty Bao.
Jul 09th 2022
16
It’s lesser Ragnarok, and that’s fine
Jul 10th 2022
17
Bale was amazing. Marvel's formula is getting boring and stale.
Jul 11th 2022
18
Too much Taika, but this is the best Thor story yet.
Jul 17th 2022
21
it was fun and enjoyable ***spoilers***
Jul 18th 2022
23
The necro sword was gone and he was dying
Jul 18th 2022
24
      you got a couple points
Jul 18th 2022
25
           I think it's fairly strong, and consistent with his motives
Sep 28th 2022
36
This movie is for first graders , what the hell?
Sep 08th 2022
26
Same thing happened with Wonder Woman 1984
Sep 08th 2022
27
Here's hoping Wakanda Forever can salvage Phase 4
Sep 08th 2022
28
Not for me.
Sep 12th 2022
29
kind of a Marvel B movie. I enjoyed it
Sep 12th 2022
30
Just watched this weekend and.....*sigh*
Sep 12th 2022
31
i think fans limit themselves by needing "forward"
Oct 13th 2022
37
Like She-Hulk, if you give up on seriousness, it's more enjoyable.
Sep 28th 2022
32
This feels like the weight of having SO much content that's part of
Sep 28th 2022
33
Did other problems cease to exist because WWII did?
Sep 28th 2022
35
this is a serious question...
Oct 13th 2022
38

Lobby Pass The Popcorn topic #744092 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com