| Subject |
Author |
Message Date |
ID |
 TV Spot #26 - Hints to possible cameos? |
|
Dec 07th 2016 | 1
|
 I think we'll see a brief Leia cameo, right at the end of the film. |
|
Dec 07th 2016 | 2
|
  Well, my prediction was pretty accurate... |
|
Dec 17th 2016 | 114
|
| Rebels is so damn dope.. |
|
Dec 07th 2016 | 3
|
| TV Spot #27: K-2SO is gonna be the scene stealer. |
|
Dec 07th 2016 | 4
|
| The soundtrack track listing is out. Time to get nerdy. |
|
Dec 08th 2016 | 5
|
| Im excited to hear this |
|
Dec 09th 2016 | 6
|
| The first reactions to the premiere have been crazy |
|
Dec 12th 2016 | 7
|
| Has anyone seen the New Yorker review? lol |
|
Dec 14th 2016 | 8
|
| They're either parodying their own pretense or just trolling |
|
Dec 14th 2016 | 9
|
| "enticingly florid dialogue" in the trilogy prequels, huh |
|
Dec 14th 2016 | 10
|
| What in the blue fuck? Was this a satirical piece? |
|
Dec 14th 2016 | 11
|
| Richard Brody is one of my favorite film writers |
|
Dec 14th 2016 | 12
|
| it was an experiential thrill simply surviving most of 1-3's dialogue |
|
Dec 14th 2016 | 13
|
| Brody's taste in mainstream flicks has always been strange. |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 35
|
| Front half is bad...Back half is spectacular |
|
Dec 15th 2016 | 14
|
| But "The Bad" seems to have answers |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 16
|
| It's funny - when they announced that there wouldn't be a crawl |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 22
|
| this WHOLE movie was BASED on the 2nd paragraph |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 77
|
| yeah replacing a crawl with planet hops defeats the purpose. |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 86
|
| Yeah, but it doesn't serve the movie is the problem, lol |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 25
|
| Nah Tarkin had to have a lot of time |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 59
|
| You know why it wasn't in a crawl? |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 74
|
| i wonder when the cgi will be good enough |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 87
|
| Vader voice was the problem for me too |
|
Dec 19th 2016 | 149
|
| This right here: |
|
Dec 22nd 2016 | 180
|
| Tarkin is SecState, Vader's VP/SecDef, if the Emperor had a cabinet as s... |
|
Dec 27th 2016 | 194
|
| Agree. Wouldn't have minded losing it and focusing on heist. |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 19
|
| There's a fine line between rebellion and terrorism. |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 21
|
| At the same time... |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 32
|
| Crystal / Lightsaber Explanation |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 50
|
| Hmm interesting... |
|
Dec 22nd 2016 | 178
|
| I only have one question...is my nugga Snoke in the house? |
|
Dec 15th 2016 | 15
|
| SPOILER aka THEORY? |
|
Dec 18th 2016 | 125
|
| Soooo re: Vader..... |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 17
|
| It's minutes before A New Hope. |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 20
|
| RE: It's minutes before A New Hope. |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 54
|
| Vader in the bacta tank says a LOT about his state of health. |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 52
|
| That scene got spoiled for me kind of |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 56
|
| interesting |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 79
|
| The money shot |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 18
|
| I can't believe how many fucking.... |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 23
|
| Oh, and Donnie Yen is the fucking man. |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 24
|
| they tied everything together so well, without it fucking up the film |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 89
|
| It's good, but it couldda been great. I give the edge to Awakens |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 26
|
| I absolutely loved it |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 27
|
| Episode 3.95: Katniss in Space |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 28
|
| Can they fix the 2nd trilogy with a 1.3, 2.5, and 3.2??? |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 29
|
| the whole Clone Wars cartoon |
|
Dec 21st 2016 | 164
|
| once i finish rebels, im doin clone wars |
|
Dec 21st 2016 | 165
|
| Just started clone wars. Pretty good! n/m |
|
Dec 21st 2016 | 173
|
| Mostly good, but (unpopular opinion) the nostalgia stuff is awful. |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 30
|
| This |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 31
|
| Only two of the nostalgia moments were bad to me |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 33
|
| Eh. |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 34
|
| Tarkin looked like a polar express character.. |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 37
|
| Like I said, I enjoyed the movie too. |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 38
|
| But they HAD to be there cause Bail Organa LOL |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 63
|
| For casual fans, literally none of this matters, though. |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 65
|
| Lmao that's Leia's pops / one of the architects of the Rebellion |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 66
|
| The larger story. Not this story. |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 68
|
| Jimmy Smits/Bail Organa actually served a purpose in the story though |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 69
|
| 1. Nobody's complaining. 2. His appearance doesn't matter. |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 72
|
| For me, his presence didn't take away from the film at all |
|
Dec 17th 2016 | 105
|
| Me neither. |
|
Dec 17th 2016 | 110
|
| I think Reply 71 covered my feelings on this. |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 73
|
| i think it's a finer line than that though |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 90
|
| The issue is the main characters |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 94
|
| i think part of the story is that the arc of the universe subsumes the c... |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 95
|
| We'll have to agree to disagree |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 96
|
| Saw's back story was more important to tell because it was another grey ... |
|
Dec 17th 2016 | 104
|
| Grey area is not a theme. In general, I don't care about canon. |
|
Dec 17th 2016 | 111
|
| I laughed at the music swell on Jimmy Smits |
|
Dec 21st 2016 | 174
|
| "Oh shit, son! It's Matt Santos!" |
|
Dec 27th 2016 | 195
|
| You've got Mendelsohn/Mads and you rely on CGI Tarkin |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 39
|
| RE: Eh. |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 58
|
| Ahh. This works for me |
|
Dec 19th 2016 | 147
|
| Dude, it's a movie that directly relates/leads up to Ep. IV |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 41
|
| He's not complaining about cameos |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 43
|
| 100% this. |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 45
|
| Yup. |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 53
|
| RE: He's not complaining about cameos |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 60
|
| The movie doesn't change without Smits' appearance. |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 71
|
| "Because her dad built it" was unnecessary to the heist, too. |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 97
|
| Thank you. |
|
Dec 17th 2016 | 102
|
| I've never rooted so hard for two people NOT to kiss |
|
Dec 17th 2016 | 109
|
| I understand all of that. |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 44
|
| SON A YODA MOVIE THANK YOU BABY JESUS?!?! |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 48
|
| man you nailed it |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 46
|
| Tarkin was completely unnecessary fan service and I loved it |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 47
|
| I can dig that. |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 51
|
| You realize those people HAD to be there |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 57
|
| SMH... |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 75
|
| If the Tarkin CGI was better, or Peter Cushing wasn't, you know, dead... |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 78
|
| I didn;t think the CGI was a BAD |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 80
|
| I agree that it'd have been much better with a human actor. |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 83
|
| Post 43 |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 84
|
| I'd never heard of a Saw Gerrera in my entire life before this film |
|
Dec 17th 2016 | 106
|
| I was with you up until the Vader part |
|
Dec 19th 2016 | 146
|
| Yeah, and I've honestly come around on that scene. |
|
Dec 19th 2016 | 151
|
| I loved this film, but glad it's a 1-off. I prefer fairytale fantasy Sta... |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 36
|
| So what were the reshoots? |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 40
|
| There are a couple scenes from the trailers |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 81
|
| Worth it just to see the redemption of Vader's badassedness. |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 42
|
| who was the old man that went to the bacta tank to get Vader? |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 49
|
| just a Vader servant I gathered. |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 61
|
| Galen Erso must be inspirational as HECK. |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 55
|
| I would've *loved* to get to know him more. |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 62
|
| this is either the second or third best SW flick |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 64
|
| Agree 100% nm |
|
Jan 17th 2017 | 230
|
| So, yeah, thoroughly enjoyed it. |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 67
|
| I really don't see any of the cameos as fan service. |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 70
|
| %100 base |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 76
|
| Agree! |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 82
|
| ... but isn't this the definition of fan service? |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 85
|
| When I said I think decisions were made I was thinking the opposite. |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 91
|
| No it's not the definition! |
|
Dec 17th 2016 | 99
|
| One last breakdown on this: |
|
Dec 17th 2016 | 101
|
| You nailed it |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 88
|
| The deaths here had more heft than... |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 92
|
| Nah, Han hit waaaay harder... |
|
Dec 20th 2016 | 158
|
| Agreed...all of em combined in Rogue One don't match Solo's |
|
Dec 20th 2016 | 159
|
| |
| Donnie Yen spin-off prequel directed by Gareth Evans please |
|
Dec 16th 2016 | 93
|
| motherfuckin Vader got that screen presence |
|
Dec 17th 2016 | 98
|
| I didn't have a problem with the pacing at all |
|
Dec 17th 2016 | 100
|
| Great review at AV Club, worth sharing: |
|
Dec 17th 2016 | 103
|
| Did anyone notice Chopper on Yavin hanger bay? |
|
Dec 17th 2016 | 107
|
| yes, that was dope |
|
Dec 21st 2016 | 166
|
| shit was good AF. shut the fuck up with the wack ass critiques |
|
Dec 17th 2016 | 108
|
| fartsies gonna fartsy. nm |
|
Dec 17th 2016 | 116
|
| basically. great flick. these dweebs bitch about everything tho. |
|
Dec 18th 2016 | 128
|
| lol. |
|
Dec 28th 2016 | 208
|
| ^this |
|
Dec 20th 2016 | 162
|
| ^^^ |
|
Dec 22nd 2016 | 179
|
| I got the spectacle I was missing from The Force Awakens |
|
Dec 17th 2016 | 112
|
| same here |
|
Dec 17th 2016 | 115
|
| first scene with Tarkin |
|
Dec 17th 2016 | 117
|
| Yep to all things here. |
|
Dec 18th 2016 | 129
|
| Those weren't AT-ATs in this movie. |
|
Dec 19th 2016 | 140
|
| RE: Those weren't AT-ATs in this movie. |
|
Dec 19th 2016 | 152
|
| RE: Those weren't AT-ATs in this movie. |
|
Jan 05th 2017 | 229
|
| Forest was amazing to me, and I wish Saw was used better. |
|
Dec 17th 2016 | 113
|
| I really liked his seasoning on that ham as well. |
|
Dec 17th 2016 | 118
|
| Thank you. So far in my convos, u and I are the only ones. |
|
Dec 18th 2016 | 121
|
| Yep. That scene when he asked Jyn if she was there to kill him... |
|
Dec 18th 2016 | 122
|
| Looks like Saw is showing up in Rebels when it restarts |
|
Dec 18th 2016 | 119
|
| Diego Luna doesn't work for me, ever. He's a distraction to me. |
|
Dec 18th 2016 | 120
|
| Might be better suited for comedy...killed it in Casa de mi Padre |
|
Dec 19th 2016 | 154
|
| Forest was over acting like he was in a totally different movie |
|
Dec 18th 2016 | 123
|
| He was supposed to be acting crazy |
|
Dec 18th 2016 | 126
|
| Yeah man, I knew who his character was. And he was over acting. |
|
Dec 18th 2016 | 130
|
| Yeah man...he wasnt. |
|
Dec 18th 2016 | 131
|
| He was though. |
|
Dec 19th 2016 | 134
|
| Upcoming Rebels season will determine that |
|
Dec 19th 2016 | 141
|
| Forest said, 'fuck it...this gon be my Battlefield Earth prequel too' |
|
Dec 19th 2016 | 155
|
| Lol |
|
Dec 20th 2016 | 161
|
| LOFL |
|
Dec 28th 2016 | 209
|
| A thought. A theory. A grade. |
|
Dec 18th 2016 | 124
|
| I don't think so |
|
Dec 18th 2016 | 127
|
| But... |
|
Dec 18th 2016 | 132
|
| The puppet that tall is being used to interact with actors |
|
Dec 19th 2016 | 135
|
| Fuck these names. PLAGEUS??? |
|
Dec 18th 2016 | 133
|
| I think it's even more simple than that. Snoke is Snoke. |
|
Dec 19th 2016 | 139
|
| Wasn't Plagues a Muun? |
|
Dec 19th 2016 | 142
|
| Before TFA I was hoping Snoke was Plagueis, but Snoke has a nose. |
|
Dec 19th 2016 | 145
|
| It ain't Plageus. They already came out and said that |
|
Dec 19th 2016 | 148
|
| oddly, I think Tarkin is bothering people because they know it's CGI |
|
Dec 19th 2016 | 136
|
| yup. |
|
Dec 19th 2016 | 137
|
| He looked really good to me. On Youtube someone posted all |
|
Dec 19th 2016 | 138
|
| i caught the IMAX 3D, and also thought the tarkin CG looked fantastic. |
|
Dec 19th 2016 | 150
|
| same |
|
Dec 19th 2016 | 156
|
| in this line. |
|
Dec 28th 2016 | 210
|
| it didn't bother casual and new Star Wars goers at all... |
|
Dec 19th 2016 | 143
|
| I'd actually say the opposite. |
|
Dec 19th 2016 | 144
|
| I barely know who tarkin is much less who is in episode iii |
|
Dec 19th 2016 | 157
|
| That's my point. |
|
Dec 21st 2016 | 169
|
| I didnt think twice about it until after the movie |
|
Dec 21st 2016 | 163
|
| Same here. I was hyped that he was in it. |
|
Dec 21st 2016 | 167
|
| the patient, dialed-down dialogue was also refreshing versus TFA |
|
Dec 19th 2016 | 153
|
| Whittakers reprising the role in the Rebel cartoons |
|
Dec 21st 2016 | 168
|
| Looks like we'll get to see why he went crazy. |
|
Dec 21st 2016 | 170
|
| ya'll ain't no real Star Wars fans ... LOL |
|
Dec 21st 2016 | 171
|
| I'm surprised people disliked the CGI |
|
Dec 21st 2016 | 172
|
| I gotta see it in IMAX or just Ultra AVX no 3D |
|
Dec 22nd 2016 | 175
|
| I saw it in IMAX 3D and then on a regular screen |
|
Dec 22nd 2016 | 184
|
| After rewatching, the only CGI moment I didn't like was Leia's smile. |
|
Dec 22nd 2016 | 176
|
| Yeah i agree she shouldve looked scared or worried |
|
Dec 22nd 2016 | 181
|
| lol |
|
Dec 22nd 2016 | 183
|
| I saw it. I really liked it. My complaints are minimal. |
|
Dec 22nd 2016 | 177
|
| My only problem with the movie are the motivations |
|
Dec 22nd 2016 | 182
|
| This is actually the crux of the "fan service" debate |
|
Dec 22nd 2016 | 185
|
| RE: This is actually the crux of the "fan service" debate |
|
Dec 22nd 2016 | 186
|
| Again, we'll agree to disagree. And I'll tap out of this post. |
|
Dec 22nd 2016 | 187
|
| I liked it :) |
|
Dec 24th 2016 | 188
|
| This joint was great! |
|
Dec 25th 2016 | 189
|
| Which death? K2SO? |
|
Dec 26th 2016 | 191
|
| Yeah man |
|
Dec 27th 2016 | 198
|
| Yeah plus his was very hard to watch it was sad |
|
Dec 27th 2016 | 200
|
| Loved it |
|
Dec 26th 2016 | 190
|
| I want to hear a good case for why Saw Gerrera is a thing |
|
Dec 27th 2016 | 192
|
| There really isn't a case for him. |
|
Dec 27th 2016 | 196
|
| Rebels: al Qaeda/ISIS. Empire: USA |
|
Dec 27th 2016 | 193
|
| Resistance: ?? / First Order: ?? |
|
Dec 27th 2016 | 197
|
| Yea that all missed me too. "When trying to be deep goes nowhere" |
|
Dec 27th 2016 | 199
|
| NO. you are confusing tactics with goals |
|
Dec 27th 2016 | 202
|
| Saw it again - still good - but a few niggles... |
|
Dec 27th 2016 | 201
|
| RE: Saw it again - still good - but a few niggles... |
|
Dec 27th 2016 | 203
|
| Lightsaber wounds are bloodless because they instantly |
|
Dec 28th 2016 | 204
|
| Think it has to do with species, cuz there was blood in the cantina |
|
Dec 28th 2016 | 205
|
| Maybe? |
|
Dec 28th 2016 | 206
|
| Yeah that stuff is pretty much par for the course in Star Wars. |
|
Dec 28th 2016 | 207
|
| i appreciate the story even more after the second viewing. |
|
Dec 30th 2016 | 213
|
| So Cass shot Jyns pops right? |
|
Dec 30th 2016 | 211
|
| ?? I thought that was a strike from the airraid |
|
Dec 30th 2016 | 212
|
| They all went down in an explosion |
|
Dec 30th 2016 | 214
|
| Saw it again yesterday; he was def. taken out by the explosion... |
|
Dec 31st 2016 | 216
|
| I know he went down from the air raid |
|
Jan 01st 2017 | 219
|
| explosion + steel platform = bad things. |
|
Jan 03rd 2017 | 221
|
| Oh and this bothered me |
|
Dec 30th 2016 | 215
|
| Data storage isn't standardized now! |
|
Dec 31st 2016 | 217
|
| Storagetek's contract with the Empire had a |
|
Dec 31st 2016 | 218
|
| Cool movie, not as good as TFA though... |
|
Jan 03rd 2017 | 220
|
| i don't think its better than TFA either |
|
Jan 03rd 2017 | 222
|
| Saw looked great but he was completed wasted, story wise, imo |
|
Jan 03rd 2017 | 223
|
| I agree with the Darth Maul comparison |
|
Jan 04th 2017 | 224
|
| Flesh out his story in the tv show and books |
|
Jan 04th 2017 | 225
|
| This is a good point... |
|
Jan 04th 2017 | 226
|
| Yeah having Forrest play him made us expect a lot |
|
Jan 04th 2017 | 227
|
| Yeah - DOPE. But check the other thread for my other thoughts |
|
Jan 04th 2017 | 228
|
| "I'm going in!" |
|
Jan 24th 2017 | 231
|
| br leaked. |
|
Mar 18th 2017 | 232
|
| was my dumbass talking shit about this movie? |
|
Dec 11th 2019 | 233
|
| This was and still is my favorite of the reboots |
|
Dec 12th 2019 | 234
|
Printer-friendly copy 
Email this topic to a friend
Pass The Popcorn
