Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby Pass The Popcorn topic #392277

Subject: "yES" Previous topic | Next topic
Big Chief Rumbletummy
Member since Jan 31st 2006
2005 posts
Wed Aug-06-08 02:41 PM

Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
21. "yES"
In response to In response to 18


  

          


*

I felt vindicated in my abject dismissal of Season 6A when I read that David Chase interview that posted here in which he touched on the ending of the season and addressed crictisms of the whole last season. I felt vinbdicated in that he basically admitted that extending the season over that many episodes was an error, or at least they erred by not having enough story to cover that many episodes. That's why you had the whole Johnny Cakes storyline lasting as long as it did and why THE FUCK was Hal Holbrook anywhere near the set? But what I don't get is why focus so much time on Vito's story which was played as a (wink, wink) nod during the Kevin Finnerty stuff and then seemingly dominated the show for a few episodes, when you had great stuff to deal with in Pontecorvo, Ray Curto, and Carlo all being snitches but all that was delat with in one episode, maybe two. (one for EP & RC, and perHAPS 2 for CG). There was great set-up, and one episode of fantastic exploration, of the Soprano kids growing up and joining in the self-delusion but before that you had episode after episode of AJ being unwatchable.

My biggest problem with Season 6, on the whole, is just how much David Chase & CO. turned on the fans, and the characters, and just made everyone unfathomably loathesome. They wrote like they now detested the idea of the show being popular. It left the realm of probability. The storylines got dark for no other reason than being dark. I said, dark...not deep. I absolutely HATED what they did with Vito Jr. There was nothing interesting or relevant at all. Silvio's run at the #1 spot made ZERO sense both in the real mafia world and in the Soprano's world where Sil was T's ace numero uno. And Bobby Bacala cried and pled for his life from kids!! This is a couple episodes after he willfully and eagerly beats up his boss, a man he knows would murder him with a smile onhis face.

  

Printer-friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote


In retrospect, Season 5 of The Sopranos was not bad at all. [View all] , Ryan M, Mon Aug-04-08 11:49 PM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
who really thought it was bad?
Aug 05th 2008
1
Hmmm....possibly.
Aug 05th 2008
2
I did
Aug 05th 2008
3
      Ditto
Aug 05th 2008
4
      BAD, bad?
Aug 05th 2008
5
           Bad for The Sopranos, which is pretty good for regular TV
Aug 06th 2008
19
i didnt think it was the worse one... but not near my fav.
Aug 05th 2008
6
see, i thought "irregular around the margins" was one of the best
Aug 05th 2008
12
      really, i just felt the 2nd half of that episode just seemed off
Aug 05th 2008
13
           i love the ending of that one
Aug 06th 2008
30
                this is true
Aug 06th 2008
32
Season 5 was great. Season 4 & 6 (1st half) sucked.
Aug 05th 2008
7
RE: In retrospect, Season 5 of The Sopranos was not bad at all.
Aug 05th 2008
8
Season 5 was great
Aug 05th 2008
9
None of them were bad.
Aug 05th 2008
10
True, disappointing might be a better term
Aug 06th 2008
16
season 5 is on demand right now.
Aug 05th 2008
11
you're out your damn mind
Aug 06th 2008
14
      yeah, i watched it last night and i'm definately wrong
Aug 06th 2008
29
Test Dream was terrible. Season Five was great.
Aug 06th 2008
15
Sums it up....
Aug 06th 2008
17
I'll speak on the behalf of the first half of the first half of #6
Aug 06th 2008
18
Luxury Lounge is one of my top five Sopranos episodes ever
Aug 06th 2008
20
in retrospect, i think the whole Cleaver storyline was a bad idea
Aug 06th 2008
23
Chris punching Lauren Bacall is the face is a top 5 favorite
Aug 06th 2008
28
      i liked what that said about the mob's current influence in hollywood
Aug 06th 2008
31
      do you have a low sodium menu?
Aug 06th 2008
33
I feel the same way
Aug 06th 2008
24
i forgot all about this
Aug 06th 2008
26
Everybody Hurts
Aug 06th 2008
22
Agreed. Eexcept for the Chirstopher episode
Aug 06th 2008
25
      i enjoy it but it feels like a holiday special
Aug 06th 2008
27
           RE: i enjoy it but it feels like a holiday special
Aug 06th 2008
34
                yeah he should've jumped there
Aug 07th 2008
35
                     I shook my head at that
Aug 07th 2008
37
Wiki just confirmed what I thought....
Aug 07th 2008
36
Watched Unidentified Black Males last night
Jun 08th 2009
38

Lobby Pass The Popcorn topic #392277 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com