Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby The Lesson topic #2684927

Subject: "as a HUGE Roots fan...the album just has no legs" Previous topic | Next topic
Stadiq
Member since Dec 21st 2005
4886 posts
Thu Apr-12-12 12:01 PM

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
22. "as a HUGE Roots fan...the album just has no legs"
In response to In response to 0


          


First of all, like others have said its a "concept" album by the Roots...

it was never going to be HUGE.

others have covered that 100%


But, lets be honest...

#1 there is NOTHING seperating this album from being a regular Roots album.

The concept just isn't there...you can take the idea of it being a concept away from it and it literally does nothing to the album

They really, really screwed up by having all these rappers be the same, generic voice of the same character...

it really prevents it from being as interesting as it could have been...plus it really does become completely impersonal.

Like a lot of reviews said, it makes it...boring

They should have had each rapper be a different character...would have been far more interesting and a true concept

or something else...

but as it stands once you have spun it a couple times, there is no reason to go back

Its just the 3rd straight Roots album with a ton of guests...


#2 Some of these hooks suck, man. I'm sorry. I love the firs track, Cool On, Stomp, Tip The Scale...

but Make My is boring as sh*t, I can't even remember the Phonte track, and

Lighthouse??

That hook is almost parody bad

So, there are very few **songs** that stand out. Not in the way that past Roots songs like Star, etc have stood out.


The Roots are my favorite rap group of all time. I actually loved Undun at first, then I realized it left rotation quicker than any Roots album before.

Im not saying this is a bad album

But its far from perfect.

It has really low replay value IMO which is probably why no one is talking about it even in the rap nerd world



  

Printer-friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote


the response to UNDUN has really made me jaded [View all] , howardlloyd, Thu Apr-12-12 07:31 AM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
has the album been out for a year yet?
Apr 12th 2012
1
even more of a reason
Apr 12th 2012
2
      I gives not a fuck about a grammy, dude
Apr 12th 2012
4
           brother man
Apr 12th 2012
5
its kinda sad.
Apr 12th 2012
3
re: critical darling treatment
Apr 12th 2012
6
i was just listening today and yesterday
Apr 12th 2012
7
what did you expect?
Apr 12th 2012
8
i wasn't expecting
Apr 12th 2012
10
Not worth your time being discouraged...
Apr 12th 2012
14
good point - THEY DIDN'T PROMOTE IT! how many videos? how much talk?
Apr 12th 2012
12
      Yea true - didn't ?uest...
Apr 12th 2012
15
still a great album imo
Apr 12th 2012
9
I don't get the Undun hype.
Apr 12th 2012
11
what would 'success' have looked like for you?
Apr 12th 2012
13
RE: what would 'success' have looked like for you?
Apr 12th 2012
19
Remember A Prince Among Thieves?
Apr 12th 2012
16
Literally nothing about the album warranted high levels of attention
Apr 12th 2012
17
LMAO? Fuck you expect, 5X platinum?
Apr 12th 2012
18
Well...
Apr 12th 2012
20
All very well said. I agree.
Apr 12th 2012
23
unlike a LOT of folks in here *points fingers* i agree.
Apr 12th 2012
21
For some viewers it would be like if Paul Scheiffer
Apr 12th 2012
28
my thoughts precisely
Apr 16th 2012
47
make my/one time/lighthouse
Apr 12th 2012
24
I WAS a huge Roots fan...
Apr 12th 2012
25
      I think your on to something ...
Apr 12th 2012
32
           RE: I think your on to something ...
Apr 16th 2012
45
wtf?
Apr 14th 2012
43
it's a very, very, very good album but you went overboard that last poin...
Apr 12th 2012
26
yep
Apr 12th 2012
27
RE: it's a very, very, very good album but you went overboard that last ...
Apr 17th 2012
55
      so you should have said in a CRITICAL way
Apr 17th 2012
56
           nope...
Apr 18th 2012
59
Maybe I'm jaded already but I never expect a "response"
Apr 12th 2012
29
.
Apr 12th 2012
30
There are a few things that prevented it from being embracing it fully
Apr 12th 2012
31
I take it you don't read many books.
Apr 12th 2012
34
      I read plenty
Apr 12th 2012
39
Don't agree...
Apr 12th 2012
33
I dunno about THAT...
Apr 12th 2012
36
      RE: I dunno about THAT...
Apr 16th 2012
48
           Can you cite examples?
Apr 17th 2012
50
                RE: Can you cite examples?
Apr 17th 2012
51
their best album since Phrenology but I dont kno what you were expecting
Apr 12th 2012
35
Doesnt HIGO touch on the same issues/topics?
Apr 12th 2012
37
RE: Doesnt HIGO touch on the same issues/topics?
Apr 17th 2012
52
your expectations are unrealistic.
Apr 12th 2012
38
The lack of vinyl has me jaded.
Apr 12th 2012
40
^^^^
Apr 14th 2012
42
I'm glad/It's perfect as a "sleeper' album
Apr 14th 2012
41
i really dig the album
Apr 14th 2012
44
its a flawed album. too slight, and great concept, but lacks feeling.
Apr 16th 2012
46
RE: its a flawed album. too slight, and great concept, but lacks feeling...
Apr 17th 2012
49
sticky fingaz/black trash/kirk jones did it better
Apr 17th 2012
53
prince paul did it best
Apr 18th 2012
57
I Do Not Like Undun
Apr 17th 2012
54
RE: I Do Not Like Undun
Apr 18th 2012
58

Lobby The Lesson topic #2684927 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com