NES: (tie) Double Dribble/Tecmo Bowl/Blades of Steel SNES: NBA Live 95 PS1: Gamebreaker (college football- terrible yet awesome at the same time) N64: FIFA(whatever year it came out) * PS2: Madden 02 XBOX: College Basketball 2K3 PS3: NCAA Football 09
*The real answer for N64 is Goldeneye, but I said all sports.