Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby Pass The Popcorn Pass The Popcorn Archives topic #61688

Subject: "PTP's New Classics: NO REVISIONS ALLOWED, NEW LISTS DUE 10 PM" This topic is locked.
Previous topic | Next topic
Frank Longo
Member since Nov 18th 2003
86672 posts
Mon Jun-23-08 09:52 AM

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
"PTP's New Classics: NO REVISIONS ALLOWED, NEW LISTS DUE 10 PM"
Tue Jul-29-08 04:05 PM by Frank Longo

  

          

I've already begun to tally, so no one is allowed to revise their own list. Jigga, Wordman, anyone else... you've got 5 hours. Otherwise, wallow in your own disgrace and wretched shame.

By now, you've probably seen Entertainment Weekly's List: http://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=6&topic_id=380736&mesg_id=380736&page=

And you've probably disagreed with it.

Well, we at PTP will form our own list. And it will be awesome.

RULES:

1. You must rank the films. With a list of this length, we can't simply count how many times a film is included, there would be too many ties. All lists MUST be ranked.

2. You must list as full a list as possible. Any list with less effort than 50 films will not be counted.

3. What qualifications should you use to vote? Simple-- which films do you think will be classics to you years and years down the line? So, if you think House of Sand and Fog is a "better" film than Borat, but you will remember Borat long after House of Sand and Fog has faded from your memory, put Borat higher. Make sense? It's your personal classics-- not critical favorites, but the films you believe you'll argue are classics until the end of your life.

4. Scoring: I was going to do the film listed first gets 100 points, second gets 99, etc. But since I doubt we get 100 people to vote in this poll, I might just go with #1 gets 11 points, other top 10 films gets 10 points, films 11 through 20 get 9 points, etc. That way, films included on more lists, even if they aren't as high, will have a better shot. If anyone thinks that's a poor way to compile this list, feel free to comment on it. But if only 20 or 30 people vote, giving any film 100 points would more or less guarantee its inclusion fairly high on the final list, so one joker who loves Police Academy 3 more than life could skew our list considerably, lol. So yeah, lemme know if you have a better way to score this shit, nerds.

5. If you want to revise your list, just reply to your original list with a subject line "UPDATED LIST." That'll make it so I accidentally don't count your list twice.

If there are any questions, lemme know either via inbox or in the post. Feel free to comment on other people's individual lists if you'd like-- in fact, reading others' lists might help you remember a film you forgot that you wanted to include.

Here are some fairly comprehensive lists of films if you wanna do some research:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1980s_in_film
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1990s_in_film
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2000s_in_film

Let's try to have our lists done by July... but I might let it run longer than that so more people can vote. But EVERYONE VOTE!

Thanks,
Frank

My movies: http://russellhainline.com
My movie reviews: https://letterboxd.com/RussellHFilm/
My beer TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@thebeertravelguide

  

Printer-friendly copy


PTP's New Classics: NO REVISIONS ALLOWED, NEW LISTS DUE 10 PM [View all] , Frank Longo, Mon Jun-23-08 09:52 AM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
this will be a fun summer homework assignment
Jun 23rd 2008
1
dam this is gonna be hard
Jun 23rd 2008
2
You've got time. :)
Jun 23rd 2008
3
RE: PTP's New Classics: Voting For Our 100 Best Films Since 1983
Jun 23rd 2008
4
dog, double check the release dates of some of those
Jun 23rd 2008
5
      RE: dog, double check the release dates of some of those
Jun 23rd 2008
6
           No it's not, lol.
Jun 23rd 2008
9
                He clearly meant Taxi starring Queen Latifah & Superman Returns
Jun 23rd 2008
17
                     RE: He clearly meant Taxi starring Queen Latifah & Superman Returns
Jun 24th 2008
36
moth-->flame
Jun 23rd 2008
7
I give you 48 hours of resisting the urge to post a full list of 100.
Jun 23rd 2008
8
haha when i saw this post i was only certian of my top two
Jun 23rd 2008
10
Great list just b/c of these 2 flicks:
Jun 25th 2008
42
      re: Housekeeping
Jul 01st 2008
76
           Edit
Jul 01st 2008
78
What say you on documentaries?
Jun 23rd 2008
11
they better count the same
Jun 23rd 2008
12
If it's feature-length, it's fair game.
Jun 23rd 2008
13
      Damn, no short films?
Jun 23rd 2008
14
           If you'd like shorts listed, then it shall be so.
Jun 24th 2008
25
                ^^Good man n/m
Jun 25th 2008
43
I may add on, but here's my 66
Jun 23rd 2008
15
This took hours, Frank
Jun 23rd 2008
16
*screams at you for not having seen do the right thing*
Jun 24th 2008
27
      GEEEEEEEEE SEVAWWWWWWNN
Jun 24th 2008
28
           So on a road trip with fellow OKP DubSpt, we went to Cedar Point.
Jun 24th 2008
29
                LOL
Jun 24th 2008
30
                     Fuck it, spinoff time.
Jun 24th 2008
32
Oh my god did that say fucking Moulin Rouge at #10?
Jun 23rd 2008
18
IT DID
Jul 01st 2008
72
I'm gonna do it.
Jun 23rd 2008
19
This will be your biggest head ache of the summer
Jun 23rd 2008
20
Are you gonna post yours? n/m
Jul 29th 2008
177
I only did 50, but I made sure they were 50 good ones
Jun 23rd 2008
21
is :The Thin Blue Line: a documentary on the Thrashers defense?
Jun 24th 2008
37
I don't think I can manage it
Jun 23rd 2008
22
THE HOT 100 is READY **(LAST SECOND EDIT, sorry, Longo)**
Jun 23rd 2008
23
Placeholder
Jun 24th 2008
24
my list...FINALLY!
Jun 24th 2008
38
      UPDATED LIST
Jun 30th 2008
67
placeholder
Jun 24th 2008
26
First of all, fuck you Longo for making me do this
Jun 27th 2008
57
      RE:
Jun 30th 2008
68
      RE:
Jul 01st 2008
82
           RE:
Jul 02nd 2008
84
           Before Sunset
Jul 02nd 2008
86
      This should be my one and only revision
Jul 14th 2008
126
I got to 75 and I'm drained
Jun 24th 2008
31
Is the deadline July 1st or 31st?
Jun 24th 2008
33
July ASAP.
Jun 24th 2008
35
push the deadline back frank, I can't handle the pressure
Jun 24th 2008
34
http://www.planearium2.de/bilder/wallpaper-char-tweek-800.jpg<-pressure!
Jun 27th 2008
52
      "No! Don't sell me into the slavery!!!"
Jun 27th 2008
59
this is going to be very hard
Jun 25th 2008
39
Anthols List
Jun 25th 2008
40
this was fun... here goes:
Jun 25th 2008
41
Great list just on these choices:
Jun 25th 2008
44
oh shit... dope avy
Jun 25th 2008
45
Edit
Jun 25th 2008
46
      yeah...
Jun 25th 2008
47
           RE: yeah...
Jun 27th 2008
56
                RE: yeah...
Jun 28th 2008
61
                     RE: yeah...
Jun 29th 2008
65
Jun 27th 2008
54
      lol i don't even need to click the link
Jun 27th 2008
55
      "Bad luck just seeing a thing like that."
Jun 27th 2008
58
      Wow. I forgot all about that scene.
Jun 29th 2008
64
comments
Jun 26th 2008
48
RE:
Jun 26th 2008
49
      RE:
Jun 26th 2008
50
Good list. Ya picked a lot of the same ones I picked.
Jun 28th 2008
62
      ^^^unpopular with the chicago police department
Jun 28th 2008
63
*placeholder* but i have an important question
Jun 27th 2008
51
EDIT: JUST REALISED WE CAN LIST MORE THAN 50 DOH! i shall add more tomor...
Jun 27th 2008
53
if jurassic park isn't on your list, you lose.
Jun 27th 2008
60
So, is that including 1983 or starting with 1984?
Jun 29th 2008
66
1-50
Jul 01st 2008
69
51-100
Jul 03rd 2008
88
      one flip flop please
Jul 03rd 2008
89
List
Jul 01st 2008
70
Not a fan of Ran, Paris Texas, or Short Cuts?
Jul 01st 2008
71
I am
Jul 01st 2008
74
      is a decent amount of your list netflixable?
Jul 01st 2008
75
           76 of them are. These:
Jul 01st 2008
77
           Forgot to say
Jul 01st 2008
80
           this is how everyone sees el norte
Jul 01st 2008
79
damn i've got work to do
Jul 01st 2008
81
      RE: damn i've got work to do
Jul 01st 2008
83
           awesome. thanks for all that man
Jul 02nd 2008
85
           *nods*
Jul 02nd 2008
87
           Come and See is incredible
Jul 07th 2008
96
                RE: Come and See is incredible
Jul 07th 2008
98
                     gahhhhhhhhhh
Jul 08th 2008
99
                          Edit
Jul 08th 2008
109
                               RE: Edit
Jul 08th 2008
111
ok
Jul 01st 2008
73
Here...
Jul 04th 2008
90
our #1s are the same! YAY!
Jul 06th 2008
93
      I saw that and thought, this dame is ALL right.
Jul 07th 2008
94
           i didn't think anyone else would have it as their #1
Jul 07th 2008
97
           just saw it for the first time damn good
Jul 08th 2008
100
                i can excuse the kids a little bit
Jul 08th 2008
103
goodfellas? really?
Jul 06th 2008
91
RE: PTP's New Classics: Voting For Our 100 Best Films Since 1983
Jul 06th 2008
92
do you
Jul 07th 2008
95
SHIT.....I forgot Robocop.
Jul 26th 2008
155
I just cntrl-f' for "ferris" in this post and found nothing
Jul 08th 2008
101
You'll see it in my list nm
Jul 08th 2008
102
i coulda sworn...
Jul 08th 2008
104
51
Jul 08th 2008
105
      I blame FF3's cntrl-f for being wonky, my fatwa is rescinded
Jul 08th 2008
106
           ^ an idiot
Jul 08th 2008
107
here's a list
Jul 08th 2008
108
RE: here's a list
Jul 08th 2008
110
RE: here's a list
Jul 08th 2008
113
      RE: here's a list
Jul 09th 2008
116
y'know i can't think of "y tu mama tambien" now...
Jul 08th 2008
112
      hah, i need to listent to that
Jul 08th 2008
114
           oh shit!
Jul 09th 2008
120
I sorta dozed off after 50
Jul 08th 2008
115
I think this is the first ever list I've seen you post
Jul 09th 2008
117
I like lists...usually get frustrated making them halfway through
Jul 09th 2008
118
i'll just pretend your list starts at 2
Jul 09th 2008
119
      I had to do it for PTP!
Jul 09th 2008
121
           Much obliged
Jul 09th 2008
122
So I'm working on mine, lol. I'm seeing a few films to catch up.
Jul 11th 2008
123
Ditto. And waiting on The Dark Knight.
Jul 11th 2008
124
list
Jul 13th 2008
125
the lost boys...
Jul 15th 2008
127
I wanna play too
Jul 22nd 2008
128
Welcome to PTP! Please feel free to post more often.
Jul 22nd 2008
129
      RE: Welcome to PTP! Please feel free to post more often.
Jul 22nd 2008
130
           Or better yet, don't go to the Lesson. Just stay here. :)
Jul 22nd 2008
131
                haha yeah maybe you're right
Jul 22nd 2008
132
                     The King of Comedy played in Iceland in Dec 1982.
Jul 24th 2008
146
                          ok thanks. i might have to make a change now
Jul 25th 2008
147
My Top 100 (in order)
Jul 24th 2008
133
Frank, please let me get a late edit.
Jul 26th 2008
156
This was damned hard
Jul 24th 2008
134
Network?
Jul 24th 2008
139
      you no likey NETWORK?
Jul 24th 2008
142
           You can change it still if you want.
Jul 24th 2008
143
                Thanks...my revised list
Jul 25th 2008
152
                     they used to call him Spit Shine Rumbletummy
Jul 30th 2008
181
I would ask for an extension through the weekend, BUT
Jul 24th 2008
135
Hey, wait a minute.
Jul 24th 2008
137
      *Signs the "List in by the END of July" petition*
Jul 24th 2008
138
      I'm posting the list on August 1st, since my vacation begins the 2nd...
Jul 24th 2008
141
Re: scoring
Jul 24th 2008
136
Not bad points at all. Anyone else care to chime in?
Jul 24th 2008
140
where's YOUR list tough guy?
Jul 24th 2008
144
Working on it... :(
Jul 25th 2008
149
      Is there no limit to your Norm Mac man-love? n/m
Jul 25th 2008
150
UPDATED LIST
Jul 24th 2008
145
I've narrowed it down to 211 movies.
Jul 25th 2008
148
I'd be interested in knowing these
Jul 25th 2008
151
most of them probably won't make the final cut, since
Jul 25th 2008
153
      In case you're also interested:
Jul 25th 2008
154
           a view into the process (not that anyone cares)
Jul 28th 2008
165
                another view into the process (not that anyone cares)
Jul 28th 2008
166
                     How did I forget Goodfellas?
Jul 28th 2008
167
Without further ado, here's my list!
Jul 28th 2008
168
      I left these three out, but I'm not changing my list
Jul 28th 2008
169
I forgot The Five Heartbeats too?!
Jul 26th 2008
157
I've said it before, I'll say it again...
Jul 26th 2008
158
MY LIST:
Jul 27th 2008
159
I thought you said you hated King Kong
Jul 27th 2008
160
No... Nettrice does w/o having seen it, so I harass her about it.
Jul 28th 2008
161
yes, I have a fellow Ran brother!
Jul 28th 2008
162
My updated list
Jul 28th 2008
163
IMPORTANT QUESTION regarding trilogies:
Jul 28th 2008
164
Looks like most people are lumping LOTR and Kill Bill
Jul 28th 2008
171
      Because the majority lumped LOTR and KB, I'm rollin with that.
Jul 28th 2008
174
So is the deadline tonight or tomorrow night?
Jul 28th 2008
170
My guess is until 11:59 PM on July 29...
Jul 28th 2008
172
Soon as possible, please.
Jul 28th 2008
173
      I'll have it in by tomorrow night for sure if that's cool
Jul 28th 2008
175
I feel like my list looks too...commercial, but eff it:
Jul 29th 2008
176
An American Tail!!
Jul 29th 2008
178
Jigga's Jewels
Jul 29th 2008
179
hope i ain't too late (my list):
Jul 29th 2008
180

Lobby Pass The Popcorn Pass The Popcorn Archives topic #61688 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com