| Subject |
Author |
Message Date |
ID |
 seeing this after work tonight |
|
Feb 19th 2010 | 1
|
| Hope it doesn't suffer from 'the book was better than the movie' |
|
Feb 19th 2010 | 2
|
| RE: Shutter Island (Scorsese, 2010) |
|
Feb 19th 2010 | 3
|
 if this is the case |
|
Feb 19th 2010 | 4
|
| I have no clue but is performance is damn good |
|
Feb 19th 2010 | 6
|
| hopfully seeing it tonight *spoiler* k not really just my thoughts pre..... |
|
Feb 19th 2010 | 5
|
| You think you know... but you have no idea... |
|
Feb 19th 2010 | 7
|
| LOL |
|
Feb 20th 2010 | 10
|
| oop |
|
Feb 20th 2010 | 13
|
| no no no not a good or bad thing |
|
Feb 20th 2010 | 16
|
| Got damn. |
|
Feb 19th 2010 | 8
|
| love the avatar. |
|
Jan 10th 2011 | 138
|
| Gahbage |
|
Feb 19th 2010 | 9
|
| This movie wasnt good |
|
Feb 20th 2010 | 11
|
| Crazy ass movie |
|
Feb 20th 2010 | 12
|
| i loved the way it was shot |
|
Feb 20th 2010 | 14
|
| Needed to cut a half an hour out of it. |
|
Feb 20th 2010 | 15
|
 *I liked all that stuff* |
|
Feb 20th 2010 | 18
|
 Quantity doesn't = quality |
|
Feb 20th 2010 | 19
|
| RE: Quantity doesn't = quality |
|
Feb 20th 2010 | 24
|
| Zee Germans |
|
Feb 20th 2010 | 30
|
| RE: Zee Germans |
|
Feb 21st 2010 | 47
|
| Eh, most of that stuff worked for me |
|
Feb 21st 2010 | 39
|
| I liked it |
|
Feb 20th 2010 | 17
|
| RE: I liked it |
|
Feb 23rd 2010 | 85
|
| Good ass flick. Go see it. |
|
Feb 20th 2010 | 20
|
| I went in thinking it was going to be shit |
|
Feb 20th 2010 | 21
|
| RE: I went in thinking it was going to be shit |
|
Feb 20th 2010 | 22
|
| Yeah the look of the film was probably the best part of it |
|
Feb 20th 2010 | 36
|
| agreed |
|
Feb 21st 2010 | 45
|
| RE: Shutter Island (Scorsese, 2010) |
|
Feb 20th 2010 | 23
|
| Spoiler discussion: |
|
Feb 20th 2010 | 25
|
| RE: Spoiler discussion: |
|
Feb 20th 2010 | 27
|
| RE: Spoiler discussion: |
|
Feb 20th 2010 | 29
|
| RE: Spoiler discussion: |
|
Feb 20th 2010 | 31
|
| RE: Spoiler discussion: |
|
Feb 20th 2010 | 32
|
| That's pretty much what I thought |
|
Feb 21st 2010 | 38
|
| Yeah, this is what I was asking about. |
|
Feb 21st 2010 | 40
|
| RE: Yeah, this is what I was asking about. |
|
Feb 21st 2010 | 41
|
| Yeah, that's what I got out of it too. |
|
Feb 21st 2010 | 42
|
| The one thing that doesn't fit for me... |
|
Feb 21st 2010 | 43
|
| The best I can do is... |
|
Feb 21st 2010 | 44
|
| The Noyce conversation is an interesting chapter in the book (swipes) |
|
Feb 21st 2010 | 55
|
| That's damn near identical to the scene in the film, to my memory. |
|
Feb 21st 2010 | 57
|
| I thought the shaking of the head meant |
|
Mar 16th 2010 | 118
|
| I thought the same thing. **SPOILER**** |
|
Feb 20th 2010 | 34
|
| Exactly. |
|
Feb 20th 2010 | 35
|
| I defiantly got that |
|
Feb 21st 2010 | 56
|
| RE: Spoiler discussion: |
|
Feb 22nd 2010 | 58
|
| RE: Spoiler discussion: |
|
Mar 02nd 2010 | 108
|
| Why would Ruffalo having a problem with his hoslter be |
|
Mar 16th 2010 | 119
|
| LOL....WHAT the FUCK! |
|
Feb 21st 2010 | 46
|
| Very well done |
|
Feb 20th 2010 | 28
|
| Excellent film!!!! |
|
Feb 20th 2010 | 33
|
| just got back... dope! Leo killed in this role (Spoilers) |
|
Feb 21st 2010 | 37
|
| The Band-Aid (Spoilers) |
|
Feb 21st 2010 | 48
|
| ah yes i meant to ask this as well |
|
Feb 21st 2010 | 49
|
| Neither makes perfect sense but... |
|
Feb 21st 2010 | 50
|
| There are terrible problems with either solution. |
|
Feb 21st 2010 | 52
|
| But in one instance there are explanations. |
|
Feb 21st 2010 | 53
|
| I agree. |
|
Feb 22nd 2010 | 60
|
| So your issue is more with the story than the filmmaking itself? |
|
Feb 22nd 2010 | 63
|
| both. |
|
Feb 22nd 2010 | 68
|
| The coaching of the crazy people was obvious. |
|
Feb 21st 2010 | 51
|
| to add to your comments |
|
Feb 23rd 2010 | 78
|
| For a few minutes I thought I was watchin Cliffhanger 2 |
|
Feb 21st 2010 | 54
|
| RE: For a few minutes I thought I was watchin Cliffhanger 2 |
|
Mar 20th 2010 | 123
|
| what was the rule of four? |
|
Feb 22nd 2010 | 59
|
| What I got from the film was... |
|
Feb 22nd 2010 | 62
|
| Good movie. Nuff said |
|
Feb 22nd 2010 | 61
|
| BTW, I couldn't watch this film without thinking of Vertigo. |
|
Feb 22nd 2010 | 64
|
| I was reminded more of Spellbound |
|
Feb 22nd 2010 | 72
|
| I saw a mixture of Caligari, Vertigo, and The Shining |
|
Feb 23rd 2010 | 76
|
| The only lingering question I had was... (spoilers) |
|
Feb 22nd 2010 | 65
|
| wondering the same thing |
|
Feb 22nd 2010 | 66
|
| Everyone else was acting, why couldn't the nurse? |
|
Feb 23rd 2010 | 82
|
| that'd be soem damn good acting |
|
Mar 02nd 2010 | 107
|
| The way I understood it... |
|
Feb 22nd 2010 | 67
|
| RE: The only lingering question I had was... (spoilers) |
|
Feb 23rd 2010 | 77
|
| my only beef with that is |
|
Feb 23rd 2010 | 81
|
| Am I the only one who thought.... (SPOILERS) |
|
Feb 22nd 2010 | 69
|
| I can see that |
|
Feb 22nd 2010 | 70
|
| I always get those two mixed up.... |
|
Feb 23rd 2010 | 75
|
| elias koteas looks like deniro in a whole lotta things he's been in. |
|
Feb 22nd 2010 | 71
|
| I know - it's like haven't they seen him before? |
|
Mar 05th 2010 | 111
|
| Casey Jones for the win! |
|
Feb 22nd 2010 | 73
|
| I thought so at first as well. Dead ringer for DeNiro. |
|
Feb 22nd 2010 | 74
|
| i was almost certain it was De Niro from the trailer |
|
Feb 25th 2010 | 89
|
| saw this TWICE today |
|
Feb 23rd 2010 | 79
|
| A little long, but overall enjoyable. |
|
Feb 23rd 2010 | 80
|
| Teddy faked the relapse? |
|
Feb 23rd 2010 | 83
|
| he didn't fake being cured |
|
Feb 24th 2010 | 88
|
| I interpreted that line a bit differently actually... |
|
Feb 26th 2010 | 97
|
| God made me slow... |
|
Feb 27th 2010 | 101
|
| RE: Shutter Island (Scorsese, 2010) |
|
Feb 23rd 2010 | 84
|
| Any significance to the rats? |
|
Feb 24th 2010 | 86
|
| The rats were in reference to Matt Damon I believe |
|
Feb 24th 2010 | 87
|
| LOL |
|
Mar 13th 2010 | 117
|
| I dug it |
|
Feb 25th 2010 | 90
|
| The Nazi parts were extremely important... |
|
Mar 01st 2010 | 104
|
| i don't agree |
|
Mar 02nd 2010 | 105
|
| Apparently |
|
Mar 02nd 2010 | 106
|
| Scorcesi's Hitchcock movie |
|
Feb 25th 2010 | 91
|
| what flaws? |
|
Feb 26th 2010 | 92
|
| RE: what flaws? |
|
Feb 26th 2010 | 93
|
| RE: what flaws? |
|
Feb 26th 2010 | 94
|
| That's what I gathered as well. |
|
Feb 26th 2010 | 99
|
| RE: what flaws? |
|
Feb 26th 2010 | 95
|
| Flaws: |
|
Feb 27th 2010 | 100
|
| RE: Flaws: |
|
Feb 27th 2010 | 102
|
| "Too vague?" |
|
Mar 08th 2010 | 112
|
| Disappointing for a Scorcese flick (spoiler) |
|
Mar 08th 2010 | 113
|
| agreed (spoiler) |
|
Mar 08th 2010 | 114
|
| I'm glad I saw it before these new commercials. |
|
Feb 26th 2010 | 96
|
| Yeah, that's annoying... |
|
Feb 26th 2010 | 98
|
| my fb is full of "i saw it comin within 5 minutes" |
|
Feb 28th 2010 | 103
|
| Guess I'm just not a fan of these types of movies. |
|
Mar 04th 2010 | 109
|
| Scorcese for this generation |
|
Mar 04th 2010 | 110
|
| RE: Leo gives a captivating performance in a solid film |
|
Mar 09th 2010 | 115
|
| Anybody else notice crazy lady's imaginary drink of water? |
|
Mar 13th 2010 | 116
|
| I noticed the fake water too but then when I saw the |
|
Mar 16th 2010 | 120
|
| yeah |
|
Mar 16th 2010 | 121
|
| Leo glass of water disappeared too. |
|
Jun 17th 2010 | 128
|
| Remener when Leo walked in & everyone was getting |
|
Mar 16th 2010 | 122
|
| see post 78 |
|
Apr 04th 2010 | 126
|
| Let me start by saying I didn't think it was a BAD film (contains spoile... |
|
Mar 24th 2010 | 124
|
| Just got back from seeing it.....excellent film |
|
Apr 04th 2010 | 125
|
| RE: Just got back from seeing it.....excellent film |
|
Apr 04th 2010 | 127
|
| Which would be worse, to live as a monster... |
|
Jun 17th 2010 | 129
|
| you figured out the final twist from the trailer? |
|
Jun 17th 2010 | 130
|
| Not that twist. |
|
Jun 17th 2010 | 131
|
| Fantastic Second Viewing |
|
Jun 18th 2010 | 132
|
| 1/3 in and Marty Mar had to get that n-bomb in there |
|
Jun 19th 2010 | 133
|
| shhh. |
|
Jun 20th 2010 | 135
|
| a very mediocre movie. |
|
Jun 20th 2010 | 134
|
| Now THIS is a "psychological thriller"... |
|
Jun 20th 2010 | 136
|
| ehh ... Session 9 with a budget |
|
Jan 10th 2011 | 137
|
Printer-friendly copy 
Email this topic to a friend
Pass The Popcorn 
