Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby Pass The Popcorn Pass The Popcorn Archives topic #20760

Subject: "I'm only trying to help." This topic is locked.
Previous topic | Next topic
REDeye
Charter member
6598 posts
Wed Sep-13-00 06:09 AM

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
56. "I'm only trying to help."
In response to In response to 55


          

My bad. I just think people who are looking for hidden meanings are missing the point. But you have questions, and deserve answers. So I'll try this one more time.

First, a few excerpts from www.ptanderson.com:

---------

Q: The film has obvious biblical overtones, and I noticed in at least a few scenes signs embossed with "Exodus 8:2."

A: Yeah, there's more than that. There's many, many more. I bet you could probably spot a hundred. Exodus 8:2 (describes) the plague of frogs in the Bible. The funny thing is, my reasons for using the plague of frogs aren't exactly biblical. I didn't even know it was in the Bible until after I wrote the script. The rain of frogs is something that really happens. Did you know that? It's a true thing.

Q: So did you go back and include the beacons of Exodus 8:2?

A: No. Right after I got done writing the script I found out it was in the Bible. So then I became very interested in looking at the Bible and figuring out what it meant there. I JUST THOUGHT IT WAS A FUN DIRECTORIAL, BORED-ON-THE-SET THING TO DO, TO PLANT 8:2s ALL OVER THE PLACE. (emphasis mine)

(answering a question about the Worm)
A: Yeah, the worm stuff. There’s sort of, a little bit more of a follow through on the mystery character, who’s in it now.  It’s better to remain sort of a mystery character.  The brown jacket and the little kid (Dixon).  And that stuff is sort of better served as something to truly think about as opposed to something to answer and in an effort to make it more mysterious and make it shorter…I just took it out.

-----------

In light of that, let's recap...

>i am not attempting to like
>the movie. what i am
>trying to do is figure
>out what the sum of
>all the sybolism/metaphor/innuendo was.

There is no sum.

>what was the purpose of the
>movie? who was the worm?
>what was the significance of
>the number 82? why not
>73 or 44 or something?

Once again, the only significance of the 82 is that in Exodus 8:2 says "And if you refuse to let them go, behold, I will smite thy borders with frogs."

The Worm was an actual character, played by Orlando Jones from Mad TV. He was the rapping kids father, and Marcie's son. He killed the guy in the closet, who used to molest him. Most of that was cut out to make it "more mysterious and make it shorter." He wouldn't have cut it out if it was integral to the story.

>what, besides 82, ties these
>people in these stories together?

Once again, IMO, they are connected only by circumstance and coincidence. Some of the characters are really related, like Claudia is the game show host's daughter, but they are not connected in hidden way.

>were these things put in
>the movie simply to distract
>the viewer from the actual
>story?

I'm sure it wasn't done intentionally to distract, but it is distracting and that's why I encourage people to look beyond that stuff. It is all engrossing and very cool, but it potentially robs attention from a very deep and powerful story.

>what did the opening
>scene and closing scene, other
>than highlighting the possibility that
>there are some things in
>life that are more than
>mere coincidence, have to do
>with the rest of the
>film? is that it?

IMO, those scenes say that some things are not more than coincidence, but are ONLY coincidence. Strange things are a part of life. Shit happens. Once again, from PTA:

Q: Of all things, why frogs?

A: It truly came from a slightly gimmicky and exciting place.  I'd read about rains of frogs in the works of Charles Fort (...) So I just started writing it in to the script. It wasn't until after I got through with the writing that I began to discover what it might mean, which is this: you get to a point in your life, and shit is happening, and everything's out of your control, and suddenly, a rain of frogs just makes sense. You're staring at a doctor who is telling you something is wrong, and while we know what it is, we have no way of fixing it.  And you just go: "So what you're telling me, basically, is that it's raining frogs from the sky."

Shit happens, some of it very strange, and there's nothing you can do about it. That is all, and that is a lot, IMO.

>whether i like the answer to
>these questions and other questions
>is irrelevant. i wanna know
>what the answer is period.

I get that. I thought I and others on here had answered the questions, though. I get the impression that you are saying that you don't think these answers are adequate and there must be more. But there isn't.

>now i ain't saying that i
>would not be a little
>pissed if 3hrs of sitting
>and thinking about this movie
>only added up to this:
>the common thread in each
>of these people's lives is
>the number 82, but at
>least the book would be
>closed on the subject.
>
>i am the kind of person
>who does not simply absorb
>something at face value and
>leave it at that.

You cannot absorb something at face value. To absorb it, you must go deeper. All 82s and the frogs -- even the Worm being the killer -- that's all surface stuff.

>lemme ask you this. did you
>understand everything in the movie?
>can you (as they say
>in grade schools all over
>the USA) give me your
>take on the main idea
>of it?

From post #37:
"...the alienation and lack of connection which we all experience, and which carries through each storyline in the movie, is really what connects us. We are connected by circumstance."

From post #47:
"...a richly layered commentary on what it means to be human and need connection when connection is so very difficult."

It's just my opinion, but I got all of that long before I knew 82 referred to Exodus or knew the kid's father was Big Worm, who killed the "long time oppresor" who used to molest him.

If this still isn't enough, check out http://members.tripod.com/magnoliathemovie/main.htm. Go to the discussion section and, under search, put in "worm" or whatever else you're interested in. You'll get a whole lot of posts on various thoughts and theories, including the whole "black kid was an angel" theory which, I think is a stretch in a movie so firmly based in reality.

RED
(really, I'm trying to help)

RED
http://arrena.blogspot.com

  

Printer-friendly copy


?uest Speaks About Magnolia [View all] , crgclark, Sat Sep-02-00 04:20 PM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
Another of ?uest's favorites...
Sep 02nd 2000
1
RE: Another of ?uest's favorites...
Sep 02nd 2000
2
RE: Another of ?uest's favorites...
Sep 02nd 2000
3
RE: Another of ?uest's favorites...
Sep 02nd 2000
5
      RE: Another of ?uest's favorites...
Sep 02nd 2000
6
           Didnt do anything for you?
Sep 04th 2000
16
           RE: Didnt do anything for you?
Sep 04th 2000
18
           Third Time's a Charm
Oct 02nd 2000
67
Rushmore
Wrongthink
Sep 18th 2000
64
RE: ?uest Speaks About Magnolia
Sep 02nd 2000
4
RE: ?uest Speaks About Magnolia
Sep 03rd 2000
7
      Answer to Magnolia is 82...??
Sep 04th 2000
8
      RE: Answer to Magnolia is 82...??
Sep 04th 2000
9
           ohh...
Sep 04th 2000
10
                RE: ohh...
Sep 04th 2000
11
                     RE: ohh...
Sep 04th 2000
12
                          Was watchin the DVD...
Sep 04th 2000
13
                          RE: ohh...
Sep 04th 2000
14
      WHY 82!?! ARGH!
Sep 12th 2000
36
           RE: WHY 82!?! ARGH!
Sep 12th 2000
37
           Sould have read this first!!
Sep 12th 2000
39
           yeah but
Sep 12th 2000
40
                RE: yeah but
Sep 12th 2000
42
                RE: yeah but
Sep 12th 2000
43
                must...kill...
Sep 12th 2000
44
                     LOL........n/m
Sep 12th 2000
45
                RE: yeah but
Sep 12th 2000
47
                     ??????!
Sep 13th 2000
55
                         
                               yeaaaup..
Sep 13th 2000
57
           Grannie I'm lost than a.....
Sep 12th 2000
38
                uu are not alooooooone..
Sep 12th 2000
41
RE: ?uest Speaks About Magnolia
vuduchild
Sep 04th 2000
15
Man...
Sep 04th 2000
17
RE: Man...
Sep 07th 2000
22
damn!!
Sep 04th 2000
19
the Mosaic Magnolia Review *spoilers*
Sep 05th 2000
20
RE: the Mosaic Magnolia Review *spoilers*
Sep 11th 2000
33
What about the music?
vuduchild
Sep 05th 2000
21
Aimee Mann
Sep 11th 2000
29
      RE: Aimee Mann
Sep 11th 2000
32
who was the murderer
Sep 07th 2000
23
RE: who was the murderer
Sep 07th 2000
24
i'll check that out again..
Sep 11th 2000
30
right..
Sep 11th 2000
31
the worm?
Sep 12th 2000
35
Just another case of that ol' PTA (c) LONS
Sep 07th 2000
25
REDeye expressed...
Sep 07th 2000
26
      RE: REDeye expressed...
Sep 07th 2000
27
saw it this weekend...
Sep 11th 2000
28
Magnolia is in good company
Sep 11th 2000
34
What IIII got from the movie
BTMBQHKDR
Sep 12th 2000
46
Whoa!!!
vuduchild
Sep 12th 2000
48
      RE: Whoa!!!
Sep 12th 2000
49
           RE: Whoa!!!
Sep 12th 2000
50
                RE: Whoa!!!
Sep 12th 2000
52
                     RE: Whoa!!!
vuduchild
Sep 12th 2000
53
                     RE: Whoa!!!
Sep 14th 2000
58
                          RE: Whoa!!!
vuduchild
Sep 14th 2000
59
                               RE: Whoa!!!
Sep 14th 2000
60
                                    RE: Whoa!!!
vuduchild
Sep 14th 2000
61
                                         RE: Whoa!!!
Sep 15th 2000
63
                     damn man..
Sep 12th 2000
54
don't beat me......
Sep 12th 2000
51
noooooooooo!!!
Sep 15th 2000
62
i didn't get this movie
Oct 02nd 2000
65
another gem
Oct 02nd 2000
66
RE: ?uest Speaks About Magnolia
Oct 05th 2000
68
RE: ?uest Speaks About Magnolia
Oct 05th 2000
69
RE: the title Magnolia
Oct 05th 2000
70
      RE: the title Magnolia
Oct 08th 2000
71
           PTA likes Adam Sandler
Oct 09th 2000
72
upupup for fire
BTMBQHKDR
Oct 24th 2000
73

Lobby Pass The Popcorn Pass The Popcorn Archives topic #20760 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com