Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby Okay Activist Archives topic #9229

Subject: "RE: Given the fact" This topic is locked.
Previous topic | Next topic
M2
Charter member
10072 posts
Thu Jan-31-02 08:11 PM

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
28. "RE: Given the fact"
In response to In response to 20


          

>>
>>Or even disrespect these people's traditions...
>>
>>
>>But considering none of us live
>>in Ghana and we have
>>an AIDS problem right here
>>in America.....
>>
>>.....and with respect to developing a
>>solution that is adaptable to
>>multiple cultures and people.......
>>
>that u haven't been thru the
>inititation how do u know
>that it DOESN'T do the
>following?

How do you know it does?

Besides, I'm talking about simply equiping children to make intelligent choices as opposed to conditioning them to live a specific lifestyle.


>there are no potential "sexual partners"
>b/c in non-western cultures, that's
>not the way ppl operate.
>not in terms of "sexual
>partners" but in terms of
>life partners.

To my knowledge, that's false.

Furthermore, this is NOT Ghana, it's the US.

It's possile to have positive and healthy relationships with sexual partners and to me, "life partners" sounds cold and functional. But like I said, people should be able to make choices as to how they want to live with respect to "partners" and not be taught to live in only one way.

Married people get STDs all the time.


>please expound on this for me:
>tell me how i would
>recognize a "sexually repressed adult?"

Someone who isn't comfortable with their own sexuality or has yet to really explore/disover it.



>remember traditional rites of passage
>are a little more than
>your sex education class. AND
>if this works for Muslims
>and Hindus (the ones that
>i know) this idea of
>no "partners" but a spouse,
>y can't this work for
>the average joe who wants
>it to work? don't we
>have rites of passage programs?
>couldn't these be used to
>do something similar?

I'm not talking about sex education.

I'm talking about educating people so they can make the right decision, rather then saying "here is a path, follow this path and you'll be alright" the person is being taught to imitate a behavior, not evaluate a decision and make an intelligent choice.

>>
>>When you've known women who've gotten
>>HIV and other SDS from
>>their Husbands, women who "waited"
>>for marriage, but weren't equipped
>>with the information to make
>>intelligent choices about sex....you get
>>jaded.
>
>ok, tell me what "intelligent choice"
>u should make about sex
>when it comes to your
>spouse?

Just because someone got married, doesn't mean they won't cheat and bring something nasty back home. 9 times out of 10, the man/woman whose spouse infects them with something should've suspected something all along.....but refused to believe it because they "were married" "he's a good man" "He/she will be faithful once we're married"

People put too much faith in marriage to protect them from things like STDs an getting hurt.



>>I like the sound Dipo, but
>>it seems to leave out
>>key information (to me) that
>>could bit the child in
>>the ass later on in
>>life...
>
>
>again u can't really know what
>info is being left out
>or included, unless u go
>thru the initiation yourself.

By that logic you can't be a proponent of it, until YOU'VE gone through the initiation yourself and/or have had detailed discussions with someone who has....since you're posting articles....

Why are having this discussion?

In any event, I'm making inferences based on what I do know if they are incorrect, let me know.

In any event, perhaps I should put forth the modifier that my criticism are going to be more applicable to a similar rite initiated in this country.

After all, I have very similar criticisms of right wing christian ideas towards sexual education....where children are taught abstinance and nothing else. The idea is that if the kids are taught abstinance, they will obey and there is nothing to worry about.

The problems start when they do have sex, whether they are married or not......they don't always have problems and I don't think it's wrong for people to wait...but people should have all the neccessary information and be able to make intelligent choices on their own


>>Waiting until you're ready to have
>>sex with the right person,
>>is 10000x more important (IMHO),
>>then merely waiting for marriage
>>to protect the dignity of
>>the family.
>
>who is the "right" person? what
>does that mean exactly? i'm
>sure ppl who have several
>"partners" are ready to have
>sex w/ each "right" person.

The right person simply means someone who can have a positive and healthy sexual experience with, whether it's your fiance, a long time girlfriend or someone who met recently.

As for multiple partners, relationships don't always work out, it's hard to find the right person...regardless of whether or not you wait for sex or thing in terms of life-partners.


Anyway, my basic issue is that I'm not uncomfortable with people teaching children to follow a certain path and a certain path only.......rather then teaching them to make intelligent decisions on their own and advising them when they fail to do so.

Actions with respect to Sex & Marriage are personal choices that people should make for themselves, not be taught to make a specific ones.

I was taught that I should get married once I got my career going/late 20s and be fruitful and multiply. Well I don't like the former, and I'm confounded by the human desire to procreate...

In other words, neither is for me.....and I'm glad that even though my parents "taught" me to make that decision and live that way because they feel it's the best...that they also taught me to make my own decisions regarding how I live..and respect my decisions regardless.



Peace,






M2

The Blog: http://www.analyticalwealth.com/

An assassin’s life is never easy. Still, it beats being an assassin’s target.

Enjoy your money, but live below your means, lest you become a 70-yr old Wal-Mart Greeter.

  

Printer-friendly copy


African AIDS Prevention [View all] , kemetian, Tue Jan-22-02 10:31 AM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
Good article
Jan 22nd 2002
1
interesting.
Jan 22nd 2002
2
oh u shd know me better than that
Jan 22nd 2002
3
      true. i was on some click
Jan 22nd 2002
4
           My uncle's a psychiatrist
Jan 22nd 2002
5
^
Jan 23rd 2002
6
swaziland
Jan 23rd 2002
7
two links about it
Jan 23rd 2002
8
      good looking out!
Jan 23rd 2002
9
           RE:Good looking out
Jan 24th 2002
10
           its a good post
Jan 24th 2002
11
                RE: its a good post???
Jan 28th 2002
13
                     Why not?
Jan 30th 2002
14
                          RE: Why not?
Jan 30th 2002
16
                               RE: Why not?
Jan 30th 2002
18
^
Jan 28th 2002
12
Not to sound Daft......
Jan 30th 2002
15
RE: Not to sound Daft......
Jan 30th 2002
17
i want to play the devils advocate...:
Jan 30th 2002
19
      RE: i want to play the devils advocate...:
Jan 31st 2002
21
           devils advocate:
Jan 31st 2002
22
                we r looking at it differently
Feb 01st 2002
30
                     RE: we r looking at it differently
Feb 02nd 2002
36
Given the fact
Jan 31st 2002
20
prostitutes
Jan 31st 2002
23
RE: prostitutes
Jan 31st 2002
24
      tell me your stories
Jan 31st 2002
25
           i've completely gone off of the topic
Jan 31st 2002
26
                RE: i've completely gone off of the topic
Jan 31st 2002
27
                     well let's see
Feb 01st 2002
31
      i'm really interested in this idea
Feb 01st 2002
29
      i'm not convinced
RevUrb
Feb 01st 2002
32
      RE: i'm not convinced
Feb 01st 2002
33
      RE: i'm not convinced
Feb 02nd 2002
38
           RE: i'm not convinced
Feb 03rd 2002
39
                RE: i'm not convinced
Feb 03rd 2002
42
                     RE: i'm not convinced
Feb 04th 2002
46
                          RE: i'm not convinced
Feb 04th 2002
47
                               ain't no need to get to raising caps
Feb 04th 2002
54
      RE: i'm really interested in this idea
Feb 02nd 2002
37
      RE:EXACTLY
Feb 01st 2002
35
so in your experience
Feb 03rd 2002
41
      RE: so in your experience
Feb 03rd 2002
43
           do you think...
RevUrb
Feb 04th 2002
44
           RE: do you think...
Feb 04th 2002
48
           i c
Feb 04th 2002
45
           RE: i c
Feb 04th 2002
51
                i'm just asking questions
Feb 04th 2002
53
           RE: so in your experience
Feb 04th 2002
49
                RE: so in your experience
Feb 04th 2002
50
                     RE: so in your experience
Feb 04th 2002
52
That's Peace.
Feb 01st 2002
34
Because a.l.l.a.h. and g.o.d.
Feb 03rd 2002
40
      RE: Because a.l.l.a.h. and g.o.d.
Feb 06th 2002
55
^ (from p.7)
Feb 18th 2002
56
RE: ^ (from p.7)
Feb 18th 2002
57
      ^
Feb 26th 2002
58

Lobby Okay Activist Archives topic #9229 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com