Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby Okay Activist Archives topic #26262

Subject: "RE: let me clarify myself" This topic is locked.
Previous topic | Next topic
explizit
Charter member
9990 posts
Mon Mar-07-05 10:29 AM

Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
44. "RE: let me clarify myself"
In response to In response to 34


  

          

>first of all, i really could care less whether oriental
>stays or goes. if people are offended, even if i don't see
>the logic, i don't feel i HAVE to see the logic to stop
>saying it...but...that's why i brought this topic up: i
>don't want to say oriental, but i REALLY don't want to say
>asian because:
>
>>When I talk to other Asian
>>people, we tell each other what we are...Korean, Chinese,
>>whatever cause WE know we are different but no one else
>>cares so you just sum it up with Asian to keep it simple for
>>the simpletons.
>
>notice how you didn't say "Iraqi, Russian, Indian" in the
>list. and i'd be willing to bet, if you kept going, you
>would have said thing mmore along the lines of "Vietnamese,
>Cambodian, Japanese, etc". it is a simpleton thing to act
>like there isn't something linking all these people that is
>distinguishable from the rest of the world (including other
>parts of the continent of asia). it is also a simpleton
>thing to never want to know more about an individual's
>particular heritage beyond that, i'd agree. however, in
>discussion (as you've exhibited), sometimes the word to
>describe all of these linked peoples has to exist to
>complete a sentence. the word Asian does a piss poor job of
>that, because Asia is a place with many people who DON'T
>share the qualities of so-called "Asians".

Who are so-called "Asians." Turkey is asia? your coming up with some very un-defined definitions. who says turkey is part of asian? who are so-called asia? you seem to be very vague with every question and answer you give on here. you're like a lot of people when they start talking about race they have in the inability to be specific. you never say anything remotely specific or sociologically backed-up? Come on now,.... "so-called Asians." I dont know who these people are. you cant explain yourself, what you are talking about. just accept that some people liked to be called asian americans. no one word ever accurately describes someone. the only way you learn about a culture or people is to meet them. Asian is a million times more accurate and non-offensive than oriental. just accept that. you are looking for specificity but you are never specific with your arguments. ???? Look at this---Asian > Oriental. get it? way better than oriental, way better. no one word is going to specifically describe someone, and no one is understandable from a term. Nor are people completely culturally monolithic.the world is complex, theres hella chinese living in mexico. Im half japanese and half white. most of this planet is going to be racially and ethnically mixed really soon.
>
>>
>>Does the "Orient" exist? And it's East of what? East of
>>the West?

http://myspace.com/bambumusic

www.individualsole.com

http://www.individualsole.com/?p=5256

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WGH3OuP9Sek

  

Printer-friendly copy


some honest questions about the words "oriental" and "asian" [View all] , Jon, Fri Mar-04-05 04:46 AM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
oriental literally means 'eastern'
Mar 04th 2005
1
up! cause this is a good conversation
Mar 04th 2005
16
"oriental" means eastern
Mar 04th 2005
2
lol.
Mar 04th 2005
3
RE:
Mar 04th 2005
4
but
Mar 04th 2005
8
      Colonization in Asia
Mar 14th 2005
70
sure thing, gringo
Mar 04th 2005
7
cosign
Mar 04th 2005
10
I say Asian
Mar 04th 2005
5
my question to you is
Mar 04th 2005
9
      i use asian because
Mar 04th 2005
15
           lol i was looking for more creativity
Mar 05th 2005
30
                another word/ i wasn't singling you out
Mar 05th 2005
40
RE: some honest questions about the words "oriental" and "asian"
Mar 04th 2005
6
RE: some honest questions about the words "oriental" and "asian"
Mar 04th 2005
11
RE: some honest questions about the words "oriental" and "asian"
Mar 04th 2005
12
      RE: some honest questions about the words "oriental" and "asian"
Mar 05th 2005
31
that's not where the word comes from
Mar 05th 2005
41
"asian" is inadequate... and isn't it even MORE of an invention?
Mar 04th 2005
13
RE: "asian" is inadequate... and isn't it even MORE of an invention?
Mar 04th 2005
14
      well "asian" is plainly less accurate
Mar 04th 2005
17
           in your example some more enlightened news orgs
Mar 04th 2005
18
           I forgot about them
Mar 04th 2005
21
                "asian" is virtually void of national/political connotations
Mar 04th 2005
22
                     RE:
Mar 05th 2005
26
           RE: well "asian" is plainly less accurate
Mar 04th 2005
19
                RE: well "asian" is plainly less accurate
Mar 04th 2005
20
                     RE: well "asian" is plainly less accurate
Mar 04th 2005
24
                          calm down
Mar 05th 2005
25
                          RE: calm down
Mar 05th 2005
32
                               RE: calm down
Mar 07th 2005
43
                                    RE: calm down
Mar 08th 2005
45
                          that's a mad doggie
Mar 05th 2005
27
Read "Orientalism" by Edward Said
Mar 04th 2005
23
RE: Read "Orientalism" by Edward Said
Mar 09th 2005
54
RE: some honest questions about the words "oriental" and "asian"
Mar 05th 2005
28
however
Mar 05th 2005
33
the people who use the word asian for themselves are usually Americans o
Mar 05th 2005
29
let me clarify myself
Mar 05th 2005
34
     
           RE: let me clarify myself
Mar 08th 2005
46
i found a difference between NZ and the UK with this word
Mar 05th 2005
35
how in the world is
Mar 05th 2005
36
if they're from India, call them Indian
Mar 05th 2005
37
      ummm....asia
Mar 05th 2005
39
RE: i found a difference between NZ and the UK with this word
Mar 05th 2005
38
that's sort of similar to the US actually
Mar 05th 2005
42
RE: some honest questions about the words
Mar 08th 2005
47
oh my goodness
Mar 08th 2005
48
hey, that's pretty much exactly what i was saying.
Mar 11th 2005
60
oh and btw, could you tell me what these mean:
Mar 08th 2005
49
      RE: oh and btw, could you tell me what these mean:
Mar 08th 2005
50
           thanks, i'm going to
Mar 08th 2005
51
                RE: thanks, i'm going to
Mar 08th 2005
52
                     well
Mar 08th 2005
53
and the politics of the minority name game...
Mar 09th 2005
55
u in here dropping dimes....up dammit.
Mar 09th 2005
56
she didn't explain anything
Mar 10th 2005
57
      read it again
Mar 10th 2005
58
RE: and the politics of the minority name game...
Mar 11th 2005
62
      thank you
Mar 11th 2005
65
According to an Asian
Mar 11th 2005
59
they're south east asian
Mar 11th 2005
61
      RE: they're south east asian
Mar 11th 2005
66
           because your boy's right
Mar 12th 2005
67
                RE: because your boy's right
Mar 15th 2005
72
RE: some honest questions about the words "oriental" and "asian"
Mar 11th 2005
63
RE: some honest questions about the words "oriental" and "asian"
Mar 11th 2005
64
RE: Amerie (who's part korean), says it best....
Mar 13th 2005
68
      Chicago has a freakin puerto rican radio dj as well?
Mar 14th 2005
69
Wow another Thai American on the boards
Mar 15th 2005
71
I just say Asian
Mar 16th 2005
73

Lobby Okay Activist Archives topic #26262 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com