Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby General Discussion General Discussion Archives topic #184154

Subject: "Vatican: Pope's encounter with Kentuky clerk Kim Davis not a form of sup..." This topic is locked.
Previous topic | Next topic
j0510
Member since Feb 02nd 2012
2315 posts
Fri Oct-02-15 07:00 AM

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
175. "Vatican: Pope's encounter with Kentuky clerk Kim Davis not a form of sup..."
In response to In response to 0


  

          

http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/nationworld/ct-pope-kentuky-clerk-kim-davis-20151002-story.html

Vatican: Pope's encounter with Kentuky clerk Kim Davis not a form of support
Tribune wire reports
October 2, 2015, 5:57 AM Vatican City

The Vatican on Friday distanced Pope Francis from Kim Davis, the focal point in the gay marriage debate in the U.S., saying she was one of dozens of people the pope greeted in the U.S. and that their encounter "should not be considered a form of support of her position."

After days of confusion, the Vatican issued a statement Friday clarifying the circumstances of Francis' Sept. 24 encounter with Davis, a Kentuky county clerk who went to jail for refusing to issue same-sex marriage licenses.

In a statement, the Vatican spokesman, the Rev. Federico Lombardi, said Francis met with "several dozen" people at the Vatican's embassy in Washington just before leaving for New York.

Lombardi said such meetings are par for the course of any Vatican trip and are due to the pope's "kindness and availability." He said the pope only really had one "audience" in Washington: with former students and his family members.

"The pope did not enter into the details of the situation of Mrs. Davis and his meeting with her should not be considered a form of support of her position in all of its particular and complex aspects," Lombardi said.

Davis, an Apostolic Christian, spent five days in jail for defying a series of federal court orders to issue same-sex marriage licenses after the Supreme Court legalized gay marriage across the country.

A judge ultimately freed Davis on the condition she not interfere with her deputies issuing the licenses. When Davis returned to work, she confiscated the marriage licenses and replaced them with new ones saying they were issued not under the authority of the county clerk, but "pursuant to federal court order."

Davis said earlier this week that she and her husband met briefly with the pope at the Vatican's nunciature in Washington and that he encouraged her to "stay strong."

"Just knowing that the pope is on track with what we're doing and agreeing, you know, it kind of validates everything," she told ABC.

The Vatican statement made clear the pope intended no such validation.

News of the audience sent shockwaves through the U.S. church, with Davis' supporters saying it showed the pope backed her cause and opponents questioning whether the pope had been duped into meeting with her.

Initially the Vatican only reluctantly confirmed the meeting but offered no comment.

On Friday, Lombardi met with Francis and issued a fuller statement to "contribute to an objective understanding of what transpired."

He declined to say who invited Davis into the nunciature or what the pope knew of the case ahead of time. Such encounters are arranged by the Vatican ambassador and his staff, not the pope's delegation or the U.S. bishops' conference.

An assistant to Lombardi, the Rev. Thomas Rosica, said he believed the pope was unaware of Davis or the implications of the meeting.

"I don't think it's a matter of being tricked as of being fully aware of the situation and its complexities," he said. "I don't think anyone was willfully trying to trick the pope, and at the same time nor was the pope briefed properly on who was he meeting. He wasn't properly briefed on the person or the impact of such a visit."

From the start of his six-day tour, Francis encouraged Americans to preserve religious freedom, which he called "one of America's most precious possessions." But he listed it among many other issues, including immigration, climate change and the death penalty.

Francis firmly upholds church teaching that marriage is between a man and woman, but he did not focus on the debate over same-sex marriage during his visit, at one point telling the U.S. bishops to avoid "harsh and divisive" language despite the challenges they face in society.

As he left the country, Francis told reporters who inquired that he did not know Davis' case in detail, but he defended conscientious objection as a human right.

"It is a right. And if a person does not allow others to be a conscientious objector, he denies a right," Francis said.

  

Printer-friendly copy


Looks like the Pope is riding with Kim Davis. Feelings anyone? [View all] , BlackSun, Wed Sep-30-15 08:00 PM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
Lol @ that snake shit.
Sep 30th 2015
1
been saying he's a fraud...nm
Sep 30th 2015
2
folk flocked to him like he was Jesus
Sep 30th 2015
3
i think this ruins his anti christ chances no?
Sep 30th 2015
4
      bible says folks will love him (the anti christ)
Sep 30th 2015
5
      right he'll say all the right things!
Sep 30th 2015
8
      not at all -- his existence is anti Christ
Oct 01st 2015
24
           right my response was tongue in cheek
Oct 01st 2015
100
                my bad
Oct 01st 2015
146
lol, but he was so cool...
Sep 30th 2015
6
I like how people are immediately turning on the Pope....
Sep 30th 2015
7
So the Pope stood by his faith and folks are magically mad. SMH
Oct 01st 2015
9
So who is on the wrong side with this one?
Oct 01st 2015
10
      KD for trying to use Christianity to persecute others
Oct 01st 2015
28
      Well the Bible says that We Win, it's just a matter of time.
Oct 01st 2015
124
I hate this country and our need for political binaries.
Oct 01st 2015
11
^^^This.
Oct 01st 2015
12
^ 'It's not my issue so I dont care'.
Oct 01st 2015
18
if IF was a spliff we'd all be high!!!
Oct 01st 2015
20
If Zimmerman was a devout catholic and said he did what he was
Oct 01st 2015
42
RE: If Zimmerman was a devout catholic and said he did what he was
Oct 01st 2015
46
Lol
Oct 01st 2015
50
Edit: I'm not getting sucked into this.
Oct 01st 2015
164
      ^ 'it's not my issue, so I don't care'
Oct 01st 2015
165
      I didn't defend him. I said that his actions are consistent with being
Oct 01st 2015
167
           fine if that's what you meant.
Oct 01st 2015
171
      Harry Har @ the edit.
Oct 01st 2015
166
           He can curry all the good favor he wants...the gay thing was
Oct 01st 2015
169
                word.
Oct 01st 2015
172
might have been fine
Oct 01st 2015
30
How y'all going to be mad if yall don't know the conversation?
Oct 01st 2015
13
ikr...he is the Pope after all...
Oct 01st 2015
14
do you have kids? I imagine this is the Kim Davis equivalent of DisneyLa...
Oct 01st 2015
16
Pope told her to 'stay strong' and referred to the importance of
Oct 01st 2015
17
Who said the Pope told her to stay strong? Her?
Oct 01st 2015
22
      *pats head*
Oct 01st 2015
23
           Please read the OP and Reply 19....
Oct 01st 2015
                *pats head*
Oct 01st 2015
81
                     smh....smug over nothing.
Oct 01st 2015
86
                          no, 'smh' stands for 'shaking my head'.
Oct 01st 2015
106
Its what they do.
Oct 01st 2015
41
What do you think he meant when he told her to stay strong?...
Oct 01st 2015
74
lol @ anyone caring what the pope thinks
Oct 01st 2015
15
So just screw 1.2 billion Roman Catholics in the world, huh?
Oct 01st 2015
131
      the ones in the church who see it's fallacy will depart
Oct 01st 2015
144
           Ok Prophet.
Oct 01st 2015
159
                I didn't write those words -- I'm just re-typing them,
Oct 02nd 2015
180
                     you added your own words to them
Oct 02nd 2015
210
                          I paraphrased which should be pretty obvious
Oct 05th 2015
234
confirmation of the meeting & a report on the conversation (link/swipe):
Oct 01st 2015
19
i cant wait for her 15 minutes to be up
Oct 01st 2015
21
The joke is he'll meet with Kim Davis, but Trayvon's or Mike's folks??
Oct 01st 2015
25
Trayvon and Mike were Catholics?
Oct 01st 2015
43
Kim Davis ain't Catholic either
Oct 01st 2015
47
      Oh, I thought she was catholic. I stand corrected. I don't get it then...
Oct 01st 2015
59
           why?
Oct 01st 2015
64
                Because I am pretty sure I read somewhere she is catholic. but she isn'...
Oct 01st 2015
68
                     oh okay.
Oct 01st 2015
70
                     she was raised Catholic.
Oct 01st 2015
79
the joke is you agree w/ Davis that same-sex marriage is an abomination
Oct 01st 2015
78
I never placed him on a pedestal...
Oct 01st 2015
26
^^^^^
Oct 01st 2015
104
He was never a more liberal pope. Just a smarter one.
Oct 01st 2015
27
Yeah, screw you Leo XIII and Paul VI
Oct 01st 2015
34
I felt the "some" was implied. Apologies.
Oct 01st 2015
36
he is a *more* liberal pope, doesn't make him across the board liberal
Oct 01st 2015
89
^^^^people made him into what they wanted him to be
Oct 01st 2015
105
he's the pope.
Oct 01st 2015
29
yup
Oct 01st 2015
40
i don't like how it was a secret
Oct 01st 2015
31
Yup. Its like the Vatican PR firm was in full swing
Oct 01st 2015
32
lol if we only knew the other secrets within the organization
Oct 01st 2015
33
you really need to stop reading Dan Brown novels.
Oct 01st 2015
91
      Never heard of the Medici's I take it? Or Hittler?
Oct 01st 2015
140
           if they are secrets then how do you know so much about them?
Oct 02nd 2015
207
                this is a fun one
Oct 05th 2015
238
                     super happy fun time!
Oct 06th 2015
250
                          You're confused sir and have started with a huge 'L' to boot
Oct 06th 2015
252
There are many things that're shameful...
Oct 01st 2015
37
stands in this line, we got 24/7 media coverage of the pope in a fiat
Oct 01st 2015
38
Why does it even matter? Why did the Pope need to tell anyone?
Oct 01st 2015
129
lol, this pope has been all marketing hype from the beginning and people...
Oct 01st 2015
35
and red shoes... he has red shoes!!!
Oct 01st 2015
122
The Pope is the most conservative person on the planet - its his job
Oct 01st 2015
39
It's not the job of religious leaders to be conservative. To say that
Oct 01st 2015
44
it's the pope's job to be conservative.
Oct 01st 2015
55
My point is that it's possible to be conservative on Gay Issues and
Oct 01st 2015
82
      but the pope is not, nor has he given any hint that he was.
Oct 01st 2015
111
????????????????????????????
Oct 01st 2015
57
      he just makes stuff up.
Oct 01st 2015
60
      You didn't repeat what I said. You said something different.
Oct 01st 2015
76
           this post is about the pope.
Oct 01st 2015
80
                It's not the pope's job to be conservative.
Oct 01st 2015
109
                     his job is to repeat catholic doctrine, which is all he has ever done.
Oct 01st 2015
115
RE: The Pope is the most conservative person on the planet - its his job
Oct 01st 2015
45
It's like folks expect the pope to come out and say "eff the bible", lol
Oct 01st 2015
49
      who expected the pope to support gay civil rights?
Oct 01st 2015
62
           I think it's the impression that this Pope specifically was signaling a
Oct 01st 2015
66
                i've never heard of him contradicting catholic doctrine.
Oct 01st 2015
69
                     He is very vocal about things most Popes were pretty quiet about
Oct 01st 2015
73
                          he has never contradicted catholic doctrine.
Oct 01st 2015
77
The political climate nowadays is insane...
Oct 01st 2015
48
who is doing this?
Oct 01st 2015
51
I'm going off of comments I've seen here as well as other "liberal" sour...
Oct 01st 2015
56
      when has this pope ever contradicted the Catholic position on gays?
Oct 01st 2015
58
Yup. It was always 'everybody'.
Oct 01st 2015
52
Thank you for your contribution
Oct 01st 2015
53
thanks for YOURS.
Oct 01st 2015
88
"some people" are saying this is a "controversial" position.
Oct 01st 2015
54
      Everybody thinks this is a fair point.
Oct 01st 2015
84
it's only going get worst i think
Oct 01st 2015
61
      who expected the pope to be in favor civil rights for gay ppl?
Oct 01st 2015
63
           No one intelligent expects the pope to be pro gay agenda...
Oct 01st 2015
65
                so ppl like it when the pope does stuff they agree with...
Oct 01st 2015
67
                     It's not simply dislike of 1 statement, it's total revocation of support
Oct 01st 2015
71
                          the pope was always 100 percent against me on gay rights.
Oct 01st 2015
75
                               Then I'm not talking about you specifically then, am I?
Oct 01st 2015
83
                                    yet you said "everybody."
Oct 01st 2015
85
                                         Ok
Oct 01st 2015
87
                                              so, not everybody.
Oct 01st 2015
90
                                                   You shouldn't turn their pedantic tactics back on them
Oct 01st 2015
114
                                                        My god you guys are the most miserable people to debate with lol
Oct 01st 2015
116
                                                             everybody agrees.
Oct 01st 2015
118
                                                             we sure are.
Oct 01st 2015
120
                                                             to be fair, they have a right to be miserable right now...
Oct 01st 2015
128
                                                             the ppl that thought the Catholic Pope was pro-gay got played.
Oct 01st 2015
130
                                                             Perhaps they are projecting their own misery elsewhere
Oct 01st 2015
147
                                                             he gobbled a L even engaging with them
Oct 01st 2015
133
                                                             It's not you it's the Pope... LOL
Oct 01st 2015
132
                                                             There's misery all up and down your reply
Oct 01st 2015
145
                                                                  It is miserable to discuss with someone who focuses on semantics
Oct 01st 2015
151
                                                                       it can be miserable to discuss stuff w/someone who is sloppy
Oct 01st 2015
152
                                                                       << Lawyered
Oct 01st 2015
153
                                                                            LOL!
Oct 01st 2015
154
                                                                       Common language used to inflate the idea of proportion, yes
Oct 01st 2015
155
                                                                            Thank you. I will do better next time
Oct 01st 2015
156
So whats the issue, that he met with her at all?
Oct 01st 2015
72
Stay strong kinda sounds like he's riding wit her
Oct 01st 2015
92
we know he didn't do that.
Oct 01st 2015
93
      Yeah. Telling her to chill doesn't warrant an in-person clandestine meet...
Oct 01st 2015
94
      No. We don't know. We weren't there..
Oct 01st 2015
95
           yes, we know.
Oct 01st 2015
97
                To be fair, It's the pope. Head of a global church with 2.2B followers
Oct 01st 2015
139
                     i'm sure the world is filled w/things that are strange to YOU.
Oct 01st 2015
143
                          I'll wait for that apology.........
Oct 02nd 2015
178
                               you won't get one.
Oct 02nd 2015
179
                                    Homey you were a condescending prick who got the facts wrong. That
Oct 02nd 2015
188
                                         could you get to talk to the pope?
Oct 02nd 2015
197
                                         nope.
Oct 02nd 2015
201
                                              Oh then you are a poor sport with too much riding on being right
Oct 03rd 2015
222
                                                   'If I knew then what I know now I wouldn't have made some of those state...
Oct 05th 2015
229
                                                        Then why are you so bad at this? I mean why bother to type "If I known t...
Oct 05th 2015
236
                                                             lol
Oct 05th 2015
239
pope cant help her keep her job for breaking federal law
Oct 01st 2015
96
she's an elected official.
Oct 01st 2015
98
      she can be impeached tho
Oct 01st 2015
121
           agreed. they won't.
Oct 01st 2015
126
RE: Its hilarious...
Oct 01st 2015
99
the meeting contradicts the Ill Puta's 'let's not be dicks about it'
Oct 01st 2015
101
RE: the meeting contradicts the Ill Puta's 'let's not be dicks about it'
Oct 01st 2015
123
RE: the meeting contradicts the Ill Puta's 'let's not be dicks about it'
Oct 01st 2015
134
yes. it does.
Oct 01st 2015
136
Gay mafia be on some Dick Cheney don't you dare talk to my enemies shit
Oct 02nd 2015
185
^ Stands in this line.
Oct 01st 2015
103
I get that, what I disagree with is the notion that this make everything
Oct 01st 2015
110
      who has expressed that notion?
Oct 01st 2015
112
      It's literally starts with the second post here.
Oct 01st 2015
117
           that looks like someone that ALWAYS thought the pope is a fraud.
Oct 01st 2015
119
           no, that guy says he's 'been saying' the pope is a fraud.
Oct 01st 2015
125
                Yeah and he is using this as proof that everything he has done is
Oct 01st 2015
135
                     no, he's not.
Oct 01st 2015
137
                          The phrase you are thinking of is Distinction without a Difference
Oct 01st 2015
138
                               LOL
Oct 01st 2015
142
      everything he has ever said and did is in line with cathlolic doctrine.
Oct 01st 2015
113
like most Christians he always had a hate the sin love the sinner
Oct 01st 2015
102
popes gon' pope and all, but i won't lie, i hate that it was her
Oct 01st 2015
107
Ditto all of that.
Oct 01st 2015
108
How you gonna hate on her and the Pope would do the same thing.
Oct 01st 2015
127
      pope is doing his job. she's not doing hers
Oct 01st 2015
141
           Yep. This basic understanding is beyond some people though.
Oct 01st 2015
148
           she's also not a conscientious objector.
Oct 01st 2015
149
           Exactly
Oct 01st 2015
150
           A conscientious objector? Where is that in Christianity?
Oct 01st 2015
158
                Ask Pope Francis, sport.
Oct 01st 2015
161
                     I'm talking about in context to her faith stance on Same Sex Marriage
Oct 01st 2015
162
                          What?
Oct 01st 2015
163
                               You'll catch it tomorrow.
Oct 01st 2015
168
                               His retort failed after your reply, so he's trying to change tacks
Oct 01st 2015
170
                                    you know?
Oct 01st 2015
173
                                         Check this out
Oct 01st 2015
174
           All Christians have the SAME JOB - POPE included
Oct 01st 2015
157
                https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1qEsTXVj57M
Oct 01st 2015
160
Cool.
Oct 02nd 2015
176
apologize ..silly niggers
Oct 02nd 2015
177
for what?
Oct 02nd 2015
195
Another article; US Church beef with the pope and he got set up!
Oct 02nd 2015
181
this doesnt surprise me at all.
Oct 02nd 2015
204
I want the coworker who's been relentlessly calling Pope a dbag all week...
Oct 02nd 2015
182
your coworker is still correct.
Oct 02nd 2015
196
The Vatican is now an honest and trustworthy entity
Oct 02nd 2015
183
so the vatican embassy made sure the pope had political cover?
Oct 02nd 2015
189
      How does this confirm the Pope doesn't care about you?
Oct 02nd 2015
198
           the Catholic Church, as an institution, opppses gay rights.
Oct 02nd 2015
199
                But you don't know that
Oct 02nd 2015
211
Hope its not a postjack, but why isn't Kim Davis' job automated by now?
Oct 02nd 2015
184
Real Talk: Why were some of y'all so quick to believe Kim D.?
Oct 02nd 2015
186
The vatican gave a very 'we cannot confirm or deny' response
Oct 02nd 2015
187
Fair enough but alot of people bought in without knowledge of the first
Oct 02nd 2015
190
      because it was clear the pope was on some slick shit.
Oct 02nd 2015
193
      i knew that the Vatican had not denied the meeting.
Oct 02nd 2015
203
how many ppl got to visit the pope?
Oct 02nd 2015
191
We get it you don't like Catholicism. But Catholicism aside, that
Oct 02nd 2015
192
      the fact that she saw him was enough.
Oct 02nd 2015
194
           Well you are pretty alone in making no distinction between the
Oct 03rd 2015
223
the Vatican hasn't denied the meeting or the language used.
Oct 02nd 2015
202
      And your fool ass still believing her and lying about it.
Oct 03rd 2015
224
           My goodness you are pretty deeply invested here.
Oct 05th 2015
230
                Kids were asleep and wife was out on girls night. I got the time.
Oct 05th 2015
237
                     girls night. at 3:30 PM on a Saturday.
Oct 05th 2015
240
                          Weird. My time stamp says 9:30pm. If that's the case kids were
Oct 05th 2015
243
Now the Vatican is like......
Oct 02nd 2015
200
of course he isnt. anyone who thought otherwise was being foolish.
Oct 02nd 2015
205
      Huh? Why would they go to see someone like Kim Davis if thats the case?
Oct 03rd 2015
218
Perhaps we (including me) were too quick to judge. (SWIPE)
Oct 02nd 2015
206
It depends if people were waiting on facts to form an opinion on this is...
Oct 02nd 2015
208
It's turning into #popegate. Only in America.
Oct 02nd 2015
209
Yeah.
Oct 03rd 2015
220
Some people outta pocket with their expectations
Oct 02nd 2015
212
Some people will be, I don't know how big a problem that is
Oct 02nd 2015
213
So basically.....
Oct 02nd 2015
214
That's the cleanup story, so that everyone can feel better
Oct 02nd 2015
215
lol just say you wish he was more like you and be done with it
Oct 03rd 2015
216
Dude supporting K Davis goes against everything this Pope
Oct 03rd 2015
219
and not only that -
Oct 03rd 2015
217
Didn't he also meet with a same sex couple?
Oct 03rd 2015
221
Yes
Oct 03rd 2015
225
No he didn't (c) people in this post with agendas.
Oct 04th 2015
226
      Right LOL
Oct 06th 2015
253
Gotta hear both sides
Oct 04th 2015
227
Pope expected to fire Archbishop who set up the meet (swipe)
Oct 04th 2015
228
read that this morning
Oct 05th 2015
231
thats as far as i could get
Oct 06th 2015
251
*Files nails*
Oct 05th 2015
232
Vi-Gone-O
Oct 05th 2015
233
Pope cool again
Oct 05th 2015
235
but if you molest a child you keep your position?
Oct 05th 2015
241
Hold-up, I thought she "ambushed" the pope?
Oct 05th 2015
242
      RE: Hold-up, I thought she &quot;ambushed&quot; the pope?
Oct 05th 2015
244
      I'm just LOL'in at the comment above about her ambushing the Pope
Oct 05th 2015
245
      RE: I'm just LOL'in at the comment above about her ambushing the Pope
Oct 05th 2015
247
      Yeah, people will read into this what they will
Oct 05th 2015
248
      Yes, people hold different perspectives on a controversial event
Oct 05th 2015
249
in an ideal world this old, crusty, white catholic would have no
Oct 05th 2015
246
Nice article on the Liberty Counsel
Oct 06th 2015
254
Great article
Oct 06th 2015
255
This whole thing is like a "Where's Waldo" picture
Oct 06th 2015
256
that's a great analogy, case
Oct 06th 2015
257

Lobby General Discussion General Discussion Archives topic #184154 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com