| Subject |
Author |
Message Date |
ID |
 Jeter |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 1
|
 no. |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 25
|
| AIDS on your family nm. |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 57
|
  RE: AIDS on your family nm. |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 74
|
| Bobby Gritch is 2.0 WAR ahead of Tony Gwynn's career total |
|
Jan 13th 2013 | 156
|
| I might submit Tony Gwynn is overrated though |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 180
|
| somewhat , sure. but he was a great player regardless |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 233
|
| Bobby Grich is one of the best offensive 2B ever |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 194
|
| And Lou Whitaker is one of the best all-around 2B ever |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 220
|
| non yanks fans know he's just a solid player... |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 235
|
| have you ever actually taken a good look at his stats? |
|
Jan 15th 2013 | 237
|
| Of these three i'd say Kobe. In 10-15 years it will be Wade though. |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 2
|
| Wade had a playoff series that Kobe could only dream of. |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 24
|
| Kobe > Wade. Not even going to debate this. |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 35
|
| Wade 2006 playoffs >> Kobe at any point, ever |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 47
|
| ^^^Raw uncut truth nm. |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 58
|
| Kobe's 01 destruction of the Kings and Spurs says different |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 110
|
| If you wanna compress entire careers into one years playoffs, do you |
|
Jan 12th 2013 | 140
|
| I mean you kinda have to with Wade. |
|
Jan 13th 2013 | 153
|
| exactly. |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 178
|
| we agree for once |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 181
|
| You're right - Kobe never enabled the ref cheat code. |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 63
|
| oh gawd, kobe fans talking about not getting calls *faints* |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 85
|
| I'm crying...dude is serious too...haha n/m |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 86
|
| I didn't say Kobe didn't get calls. |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 87
|
| kings lakers 2002 playoff series elbows you in the face |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 91
|
| ^^^Yes, LA was done...i'm still angry about that series. |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 98
|
| LOL. Not even in the same discussion as Wade 2006 |
|
Jan 12th 2013 | 129
|
| LMAO. Hope you realize how dumb this reply is. |
|
Jan 12th 2013 | 145
|
| Let's try it again: Wade Playoffs 2006 >>> Kobe ever |
|
Jan 12th 2013 | 149
|
| LOL. Deflection! |
|
Jan 12th 2013 | 151
|
| Wade 2006 playoffs >> Kobe at any point, ever |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 163
|
| Cut the disingenuous act, you know exactly what he's talking about |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 88
|
| LOL WTF? Jesus Christ dude, log the fuck off |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 3
|
| Scottie Pippen, cry! |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 4
|
| RE: Scottie Pippen, cry! |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 5
|
| you know i dont mean it, why you making me clarify now? |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 16
|
| http://bossip.files.wordpress.com/2011/12/scottie.jpg?w=500&h=320 |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 7
|
| At least he has his striking good looks to fall back on |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 19
|
| It is Scottie easily. |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 32
|
| Scottie >>>> Ewing |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 38
|
| Sad thing is people believe that...DEFINITION OF OVERRATED |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 56
|
| Its true. get over it |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 83
|
| Has Pippen ever led a team to one game from a chip? |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 166
|
| 1994. |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 191
|
| How u one game from a chip...in the ecf? 1994 = WRONG |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 217
|
| RE: Has Pippen ever led a team to one game from a chip? |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 192
|
| Wrong-o my friend |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 218
|
| 2nd best perimeter player in the league? WTF? In what year? |
|
Jan 15th 2013 | 245
|
| No one's out there saying Scottie's the 2nd best SF ever |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 51
|
| who the FUCK would have him ahead of bird/erving/lebron? |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 65
|
| That's my point |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 72
|
| nah i am not making that leap, kobe ahead of pippen all time |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 75
|
| I'm not either. |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 77
|
| Nothing...really. Though Kobe is a great scorer |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 100
|
| So let me get the right Pip> both Kobe & Ewing? |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 179
|
| I'm saying, if I had to build a team with just one |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 183
|
| LOL. This is absurd. |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 185
|
| I think this is crazy talk, but hey.....strokes/folks |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 186
|
| RE: I think this is crazy talk, but hey.....strokes/folks |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 195
|
| RE: I think this is crazy talk, but hey.....strokes/folks |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 219
|
| I agree |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 81
|
| I swear YOU have made this same post at least 2 other times. |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 6
|
| RE: I swear YOU have made this same post at least 2 other times. |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 8
|
| How bout them MAVS! |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 13
|
| lol |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 20
|
| haha. you mad Kobe "winning" |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 9
|
| Five! |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 12
|
| RE: Five! |
|
Jan 29th 2013 | 255
|
| Jordan. Russell is a close second |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 10
|
| just no |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 14
|
| If you are the GOAT you can't really be overrated, dude |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 17
|
| You have to be young to say Jordan was overrated |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 34
|
| I absolutely remember, and UI remember that he was human |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 44
|
| yup. Jordan is a monolith at this point |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 92
|
| lol |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 42
|
| there are dozens as athletic |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 54
|
| Jump off a bridge nm. |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 60
|
| FOH |
|
Jan 13th 2013 | 161
|
| Bill Russell is the most overrated player in the history of pro sports. |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 11
|
| At least people are willing to discuss that possibility |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 15
|
| LOL that's because the people who saw him own the league will be dead |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 18
|
| 6'9, zero offensive skills |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 37
|
| Uh, Rodman is in the hall, dude, Russell was better at everything |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 66
|
| Russell sucked, dude. |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 71
|
| "Russell sucked" <------ only on OKS |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 73
|
| you are a fool and dont know wtf you are talking about |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 78
|
| oh his scoring is respectable? |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 97
|
| 68 and 69 teams were comically stacked? FOH |
|
Jan 12th 2013 | 119
|
| You're right. He only had two Hall of Fame teammates in 68-69 |
|
Jan 12th 2013 | 127
|
| they were the fourth of four seeds, OLD AS FUCK and on the road |
|
Jan 12th 2013 | 134
|
| oh, by the way. |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 104
|
| daaaaaaaaamn |
|
Jan 12th 2013 | 122
|
| so he would lead the league in blocks and probably rebounds |
|
Jan 13th 2013 | 159
|
| yes, he would be a fine player. |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 164
|
| he is still not the most overrated player or even close |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 173
|
| yes he is, by far |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 177
|
| k |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 205
|
| ummm, today's league isn't filled with lead-footed white dudes |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 165
|
| Todd Day |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 21
|
| Wo Jo |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 22
|
| no Duncan? |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 23
|
| HELL...no Duncan. The fucks wrong with you |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 26
|
| he's just mad |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 27
|
| Shoulda known...silly Laker fans. |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 30
|
| lol. distractdistract! |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 55
|
| ^Pavlov's mutt^ |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 162
|
| bill russell = reggie evans minus the stunning good looks |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 28
|
| hells naw |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 29
|
| Rodman without the calm demeanor |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 31
|
| Renaldo Balkman without the Humpty nose |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 33
|
| Did you already plug his numbers into Johnny 5 to get his PER? |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 36
|
| is PER supposed to be hard to find? |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 48
|
| cmon guinness...blocks, orebs, steals, turnovers, then 3 pointers |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 61
|
| russell - stromile swift minus athleticism |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 93
|
| but you cited BS made-up PERs |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 107
|
| oh no doubt. |
|
Jan 12th 2013 | 141
|
| in his era he was top 10 and did you look at DWS by any chance? |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 67
|
| Yeah, however how did they make that up? |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 108
|
| LMAO |
|
Jan 12th 2013 | 118
|
| lmao @ Pippen being better than Ewing |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 39
|
| http://gifsoup.com/view1/1165656/pippen-dunks-on-ewing-o.gif |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 62
|
| Starks dunking on Jordan, Pippen and Grant >>>>>>>> That mess |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 80
|
| still my favorite dunk all time because of the step over |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 82
|
| he basically begged for that GIF n/m |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 225
|
| how is the GOAT talent overrated? |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 40
|
| A lot of players could score like that, but they're not sociptaths |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 41
|
| Man, fuckin STOP with this T-Mac talk. He peaked and was as good |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 64
|
| The T-Mac pile on is unfair. He legitimatley got hurt. |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 70
|
| T-Mac at the peak of his powers >>>> Kobe |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 76
|
| A LOT of players have been this n that pre-injury or even death |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 95
|
| Staying healthy is part of it, sorry. |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 172
|
| it was a good era of shooting guards, really |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 234
|
| Agreed with all of that. |
|
Jan 15th 2013 | 239
|
| quit that "GOAT talent" horseshit |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 46
|
| Seriously though. Stop making the same post over and over. |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 49
|
| Yet, your in these same posts over and over |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 50
|
| Phil's words, so i'll take it as gospel |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 105
|
| because you always take Phil's words on everything as gospel. |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 175
|
| You should have just made one poll option |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 43
|
| ^ |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 45
|
| Randy Moss |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 52
|
| never heard that. Just heard he was the most talented ever |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 53
|
| Definitely more explosive than Rice |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 69
|
| Calvin Johnson is already the best receiver in NFL history |
|
Jan 12th 2013 | 123
|
| no |
|
Jan 12th 2013 | 132
|
| Welp Randy said it today at SB media day... |
|
Jan 29th 2013 | 253
|
| George Miken is the correct answer btw |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 59
|
| who really rates mikan *that* high? he is just a symbol of preintegratio... |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 84
|
| Jerry West: The (O)riginal (G)unner but perennial loser |
|
Jan 10th 2013 | 68
|
| He went to what, nine NBA Finals? Yeah, huge ass loser. STFU |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 79
|
| white folks started that shyt.....so, two can play that game (ask Bron) |
|
Jan 12th 2013 | 117
|
| except west is regarded as one of the best clutch players ever |
|
Jan 12th 2013 | 120
|
| These posts always turn into "Name every great player" |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 89
|
| Larry Bird |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 96
|
| Grrrrrr |
|
Jan 12th 2013 | 115
|
| Bird has actually become underrated over the years |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 167
|
| agreed completely, he is every bit magic's equal |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 206
|
| name me another SF w/ no athleticism who can ave 10 rbs/career |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 228
|
| Namath |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 90
|
| AI |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 94
|
| i vote jordan...i flat out don't respect his peers, except hakeem |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 99
|
| glad you can finally admit Zeke wasn't his peer |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 101
|
| when he beats zeke more than zeke beat him, you let me know |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 102
|
| when Zeke comes anywhere close to this, come get me |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 168
|
| Jordan shitted on Magic, Zeke, Bird, Mchale, Parish, Kareem too |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 103
|
| them niggas was all done. bye. |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 106
|
| There is a valid argument for that. |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 111
|
| The 49 & 63 against the C's in 86 wasn't against a washed up team |
|
Jan 12th 2013 | 112
|
| Of course he did. He did his winning AFTER though. |
|
Jan 12th 2013 | 113
|
| RE: Of course he did. He did his winning AFTER though. |
|
Jan 12th 2013 | 130
|
| So numbers>>>>>>.winning to you. Got it. |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 171
|
| >JUST like a Kobe stan lmao. You don't want to talk individual anything. |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 200
|
| ok so why dont kobestanis recognize russell as the GOAT? |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 207
|
| MPLS titles count if 9 straight counts. |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 216
|
| That's like expecting Kyrie to beat the Heat and OKC in the playoffs |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 236
|
| I never called Mike over rated. |
|
Jan 15th 2013 | 238
|
| "God in disguise as MJ" - Birdman |
|
Jan 12th 2013 | 126
|
| RE: "God in disguise as MJ" - the guy who won that series |
|
Jan 12th 2013 | 144
|
| The correct answer is Wilt. |
|
Jan 11th 2013 | 109
|
| ^^^REAL SPIT!!!!!!! |
|
Jan 12th 2013 | 114
|
| yup |
|
Jan 12th 2013 | 116
|
| except wilt led the league in assists and kept his teams competitive |
|
Jan 12th 2013 |
|
| except wilt led the league in assists and kept his teams competitive |
|
Jan 12th 2013 | 121
|
| lol so that he could SAY that led the league in assists |
|
Jan 12th 2013 | 124
|
| Eh, he took it as a personal challenge and did it |
|
Jan 12th 2013 | 135
|
| LOL don't be so defensive, sweet cheeks. |
|
Jan 12th 2013 | 125
|
| Kobe's individual accolades don't fuck with that list at ALL. |
|
Jan 12th 2013 | 128
|
| i thought i left my wok on, but it was just this post sizzling. |
|
Jan 12th 2013 | 136
|
| LOL@some perspective. Bird's list don't even fuck with Kobe's |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 169
|
| In 17 years tho right? |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 182
|
| So, I mean, Bird couldn't last 17 years, right? |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 184
|
| Kobe didn't go to college, which is an extra 4 NBA seasons right there |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 188
|
| Which is still comparable, plus his career stats go up. |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 190
|
| oh Kobe definitely belongs on the list |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 199
|
| Kobe has 1 MVP to Bird's 3 and they both have 2 Finals MVPs. |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 201
|
| LOL I already broke it down. Kobe has more of everything BUT MVP's |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 203
|
| I know rings are the only stats Kobestanis like, but uhhh |
|
Jan 12th 2013 | 131
|
| Wow |
|
Jan 12th 2013 | 133
|
| Surprised at the lack of Jabbar on that list |
|
Jan 12th 2013 | 137
|
| 4 |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 189
|
| sorry, got confused because i jammed a finger, two are taped together |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 208
|
| the poll is the most overrated player EVER |
|
Jan 12th 2013 | 138
|
| NO YOU STOP RIGHT NOW |
|
Jan 12th 2013 | 139
|
| Tell em! |
|
Jan 12th 2013 | 143
|
| ....you know they're talking about 2 guards right? |
|
Jan 12th 2013 | 146
|
| An injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere (c) |
|
Jan 12th 2013 | 148
|
| I'd deflect if I were you too. n/m |
|
Jan 13th 2013 | 154
|
| RE: NO YOU STOP RIGHT NOW |
|
Jan 29th 2013 | 254
|
| No Olajuwon? Wow. |
|
Jan 12th 2013 | 142
|
| Olajuwon is overrated as fuck. 2 phenomenal post seasons |
|
Jan 12th 2013 | 147
|
| On that note, the playoff list: |
|
Jan 12th 2013 | 150
|
| Command/Control F : Enters Kobe |
|
Jan 13th 2013 | 157
|
| 2 phenomenal post seasons>>infinity regular season MVPs |
|
Jan 13th 2013 | 152
|
| ^^^Thinks Robert Horry is an all-time great |
|
Jan 13th 2013 | 155
|
| There's a context you're ignoring there, Hoss |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 170
|
| No, dude, just no. Watch him in the Finals against Boston, get back w me |
|
Jan 13th 2013 | 160
|
| you can argue Robinson was otherwise on par w/ Hakeem, not Ewing though |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 187
|
| Hakeem was the greatest of what was a great... |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 196
|
| I will entertaiin the possibility that he was clearly better than those ... |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 197
|
| I don't know, man... |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 198
|
| if you compare Dream's 86-91 seasons to his 92-96 |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 215
|
| Fine, but he was still a hall-of-famer... |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 223
|
| agreed |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 227
|
| and also playing without a second option throughout |
|
Jan 15th 2013 | 246
|
| I see no merit in that argument. |
|
Jan 15th 2013 | 249
|
| LMAO! I called Ewing the Dirk Nowitzki of centers a few years ago |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 221
|
| ewing's problem was injury basically |
|
Jan 15th 2013 | 247
|
| he was already relying too heavy on those fallaway jumpers before that |
|
Jan 16th 2013 | 250
|
| Timmy don't even show up on this list.... |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 212
|
| shows up five different times on the playoff one before you get to Kobe |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 226
|
| higher career PER and he chilling in the 80s. |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 232
|
| Big O is so fucking lucky his career didn't occur in the |
|
Jan 13th 2013 | 158
|
| LOL how so? By any account he was LeBron before LeBron, dude |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 174
|
| honestly, how would O do in today's league? |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 176
|
| Why not? He could dribble, pass, and shoot really well. |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 193
|
| his adjusted numbers are still great. |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 202
|
| I'm not a fan of the advanced stats to tell the tale. |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 204
|
| not necessarily advanced stats but adjusted ones |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 210
|
| True, adjusted was the term I was looking for but eluded me. |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 214
|
| a quad-double wouldnt be far fetched for Bron |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 213
|
| i would think he'd get 15 boards barely trying |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 224
|
| 40/15/10 |
|
Jan 15th 2013 | 240
|
| LOL @ adjusting for pace being advanced. |
|
Jan 15th 2013 | 241
|
| he was also a rebounder and a guy who was advanced physically |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 211
|
| he would be hands down the best guard in the league in any era w/ |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 209
|
| Cal Ripken Jr. |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 222
|
| some WNBA players today could've played NBA in the 70s |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 229
|
| naw, they ain't got the ball to bang with the big boys |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 230
|
| wouldn't dominate, but they have size/skill to play in 70s NBA |
|
Jan 14th 2013 | 231
|
| I love him but ...Michael vick |
|
Jan 15th 2013 | 242
|
| So Kobe's NOT the 2nd best two guard of all time? |
|
Jan 15th 2013 | 243
|
| *Won't say Whaq* |
|
Jan 15th 2013 | 244
|
| Surprised no one's brought up Reggie Miller yet |
|
Jan 15th 2013 | 248
|
| Hmmm...Good one. |
|
Jan 16th 2013 | 251
|
| i think reggie is rated pretty fairly |
|
Jan 16th 2013 | 252
|
| Let's see... |
|
Jan 29th 2013 | 256
|
| so pretty much on par for a melmag post |
|
Jan 29th 2013 | 257
|
Printer-friendly copy 
Email this topic to a friend
Okay Sports
(2 votes)
(9 votes)
(24 votes)
(1 votes)
