I chose these 3 specifically because they rank high on all time lists but they seem to have the most holes in they legacy. the criticisms that often haunt them are in quotes.
Obviously all great players, but perhaps, shouldn't be ranked as high as they routinely are.

If you chose "Other", the player must be a sure shot HOF'er and a regular on all time listings. (lets say top 20)

Poll question: So.. who's the most overrated player ever?

Poll result (36 votes) Big O: "inflated stats"/ "only one ring"/ "needed Kareem" (2 votes) Vote Bill Russell: "glorified role player"/ "always on stacked teams"/ "would be outplayed today"" (9 votes) Vote Kobe:"self centered"/ "no defining playoff performance"/ "Shaq sidekick" (24 votes) Vote Other (1 votes) Vote