| Subject |
Author |
Message Date |
ID |
 I dunno what he's suing them for. They can't sue him. |
|
Aug 15th 2013 | 1
|
| Nothing wrong here. |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 2
|
 it's enough of a rip-off to claim (and win) a suit. |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 3
|
 It's really not. |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 4
|
 ...oh, hi denny. |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 6
|
| What's happening? |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 9
|
| Hi doggy! |
|
Aug 25th 2013 | 203
|
| it's not. Hum both basslines. They're different. |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 5
|
| what's a bassline? |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 8
|
| RE: what's a bassline? |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 10
|
| Vanilla Ice's legal advisor^ |
|
Aug 17th 2013 | 50
|
| that's an entirely different situation that involves |
|
Aug 17th 2013 | 70
|
| do those bass lines sound the same to you? |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 7
|
| The tone of the bass is very clearly copying the Gaye song. |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 12
|
| agreed. |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 13
|
| RE: it's enough of a rip-off to claim (and win) a suit. |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 23
|
| RE: it's enough of a rip-off to claim (and win) a suit. |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 24
|
| RE: it's enough of a rip-off to claim (and win) a suit. |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 37
|
| then MJ owes royalties to stevie wonder for his "hee hee" sound. |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 41
|
| and Stevie owes royalties to Richard Street from the Temptations |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 43
|
| RE: And STEVIE owes SLY STONE for "Don't call me Nigger, Whitey" |
|
Sep 02nd 2013 | 235
|
| RE: then MJ owes royalties to stevie wonder for his "hee hee" ... |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 44
|
| you're the one that brought up the vocal tic. |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 46
|
| Did you seriously take that reply seriously? |
|
Aug 17th 2013 | 71
|
| *wave hand around the rest of the post* he's not alone |
|
Aug 17th 2013 | 74
|
| SEE: reply #26 |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 27
|
| what now the Culture Bandit scurred now? |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 11
|
| You're ridiculous. |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 14
|
| LOL! |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 15
|
| look turkey pharell sucks and is a overrated hack |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 16
|
| RE: look turkey pharell sucks and is a overrated hack |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 17
|
| yes he is. |
|
Aug 17th 2013 | 51
|
| i think i know where this one is going. |
|
Aug 17th 2013 | 53
|
| Pharell is about as Legit as a Songwriter as Tim Tebow |
|
Aug 17th 2013 | 55
|
| Yep |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 83
|
| i actually have no issues with your train of thought. |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 102
|
| agreed. |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 103
|
| RE: i think i know where this one is going. |
|
Aug 22nd 2013 | 162
|
| Those are cool grooves.... |
|
Aug 22nd 2013 | 164
|
| RE: You're ridiculous. |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 18
|
| right? |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 19
|
| another lame no nothing turkey who always follows and repeats |
|
Aug 17th 2013 | 57
|
| awww, thats cute |
|
Aug 17th 2013 | 68
|
| Murph the Lesson TOM |
|
Aug 17th 2013 | 56
|
| LOL |
|
Aug 19th 2013 | 78
|
| no, it's right in line with who he is |
|
Aug 19th 2013 | 79
|
| it's not an interpolation, it's not a sample, and it's not a cover. |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 26
|
| agreed. |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 34
|
| RE: it's not an interpolation, it's not a sample, and it's not a cover. |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 45
|
| right. . . |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 48
|
| Did R pay Barry White's fam for Share My Love? |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 30
|
| . |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 32
|
| Was it? |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 35
|
| i went to "who sampled" and it popped up. |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 36
|
| Bottom line it's a box you can't open |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 38
|
| So did R break Ted's people off too? |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 39
|
| i think it's a beautiful thing. |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 40
|
| well look who has come out of the Grave? THicke ain't on R's Level |
|
Aug 17th 2013 | 54
|
| go to a piano. |
|
Aug 17th 2013 | 63
|
| FYI R.Kelly did acknowledge bill withers in the credits |
|
Aug 17th 2013 | 65
|
| alright Genius on Love Letter and Write me back |
|
Aug 17th 2013 | 61
|
| Well.... |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 20
|
| Armen Boladian is just a pig in a suit trying to feed at the trough |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 31
|
| here for the irony of the song being called 'blurred lines' |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 21
|
| it's a given |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 22
|
| I hope Robin Thicke loses |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 25
|
| RE: I hope Robin Thicke loses |
|
Aug 17th 2013 | 60
|
| ?uestlove and George Clinton support Thicke. |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 28
|
| if Thicke was Black I doubt he gets half this support? |
|
Aug 17th 2013 | 59
|
| obviously, but it's not plagarism. |
|
Aug 17th 2013 | 64
|
| you hate Marvin Gaye period |
|
Aug 17th 2013 | 66
|
| If Thicke were Black and Marvin were white, you'd be ok with this |
|
Aug 23rd 2013 | 186
|
| no i wouldn't turkey because that no talent planters peanut head |
|
Aug 24th 2013 | 187
|
| Somewhere Bobby Nunn is hiding his last 80 bucks |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 29
|
| RE: Somewhere Bobby Nunn is hiding his last 80 bucks |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 33
|
| Sly Stone, Jimi Hendrix,,Little Richard would have Prince's Afro |
|
Aug 17th 2013 | 58
|
| You're making the same point |
|
Aug 19th 2013 | 77
|
| thing is Man THicke and Pharell jacked the Beard off Marvin |
|
Aug 19th 2013 | 80
|
| the basslines on smokey's "quiet storm" and marvin's "what's going on" |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 42
|
| Armen Boladian makes me ashamed to be Armenian, man |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 47
|
| RE: Armen Boladian makes me ashamed to be Armenian, man |
|
Aug 16th 2013 | 49
|
| Marvin Gaye outta be paid period |
|
Aug 17th 2013 | 62
|
| songwriting credit for what? he ain't write none of it |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 82
|
| never let one person make you ashamed of your heritage. |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 89
|
| lemme rephrase...i'm not ACTUALLY ashamed of my heritage.. |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 130
|
| i hope it gets pulled off the air |
|
Aug 17th 2013 | 52
|
| Ok can someone please explain the Funkadelic thing? |
|
Aug 17th 2013 | 67
|
| see #31. |
|
Aug 17th 2013 | 73
|
| Anyone heard about the bruno/breakbot thing? |
|
Aug 17th 2013 | 69
|
| P shoulda known better, but when he got away with it before |
|
Aug 17th 2013 | 72
|
| Brand New Heavy's Saturday Night (Jay Dee Remix) ft Mos Def |
|
Aug 17th 2013 | 75
|
| I like the song and all but damn Thicke, smh. |
|
Aug 18th 2013 | 76
|
| There Is Nothing New Under the Sun |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 81
|
| good analysis.... |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 84
|
| Thank you for your comments... |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 95
|
| long story short Thicke is a Culture Bandit and outta pay up. |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 97
|
| Yay! My first reply from Maxx! |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 98
|
| RE: Yay! My first reply from Maxx! |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 99
|
| I think we all agree... |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 104
|
| To be clear.... |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 105
|
| Okay, I see... |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 118
|
| RE: Okay, I see... |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 124
|
| I'm not completely new around here |
|
Aug 21st 2013 | 133
|
| RE: Robin Thicke VS. Marvin Gayes Family |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 85
|
| meanwhile i know a guy who swears 'BL' uses 'Don't Stop Til You Get Enou... |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 86
|
| Dont make it right, but thats been Pharrell's style tho |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 87
|
| kellz does *exactly* the same thing. |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 92
|
| increasingly so does Saadiq. |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 93
|
| To be fair.... |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 111
|
| Yeah true..thats kinda of what I mean..who HASN'T done |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 96
|
| No one claims this was the first time... |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 106
|
| Chuck Brown was credited as a writer on Hot in Herre... |
|
Aug 21st 2013 | 146
|
| i love reading the legal opinions of people who know zero about |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 88
|
| the willful ignorance + 'righteous indignation' = awesome. |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 90
|
| thats the straw the stirs the drink of every poAst in every subboard |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 91
|
| ain't it? |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 94
|
| RE: Robin Thicke VS. Marvin Gayes Family |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 100
|
| RE: Robin Thicke VS. Marvin Gayes Family |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 101
|
| Robin Thicke is the George Zimmerman of Music |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 107
|
| You're offsides and outta line. |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 108
|
| THIS is him. |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 109
|
| there is exactly one post I made on OKP that I regret. |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 110
|
| i Stay Black No Matter what |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 115
|
| if only Thicke were a real soul brother like Bruno Mars. |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 116
|
| FYI BRuno Mars>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>THicke |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 117
|
| my favorite bruno mars sounds like a foreigner song. |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 120
|
| lou graham can sing and i want to know what love is |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 121
|
| one hand washes the other. |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 123
|
| Well.... |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 125
|
| blurred lines ain't a great track though |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 127
|
| it's undeniably the song of the summer. |
|
Aug 21st 2013 | 148
|
| summer ain't that memorable then |
|
Aug 21st 2013 | 150
|
| that Kells song u proclaimed sure as hell wasnt it |
|
Aug 23rd 2013 | 173
|
| you ain't never had to thug it out here |
|
Aug 23rd 2013 | 174
|
| I like Bruno.... |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 126
|
| Bruno ain't riding off no Pharell or trying to be down |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 128
|
| did you know that pharell is black? |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 119
|
| i know pharell is black and he is a No talent Hack |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 122
|
| Robin Thicke don't post on here as far as I know |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 114
|
| that's just plain stupid... nobody died behind this.... |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 112
|
| its my Opinion and feelings on the Matter |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 113
|
| You need a racial intervention. |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 129
|
| i mean, it's maxxx. |
|
Aug 21st 2013 | 132
|
| likewise to you as well |
|
Aug 21st 2013 | 135
|
| dude, you just called thicke the zimmerman of music. |
|
Aug 21st 2013 | 137
|
| i never demean Trayvon Martin at all because I march because of him |
|
Aug 21st 2013 | 138
|
| thing is, |
|
Aug 21st 2013 | 140
|
| RE: thing is, |
|
Aug 21st 2013 | 141
|
| since when do you need to announce inspiration? |
|
Aug 21st 2013 | 143
|
| i stand by my support og the Gaye estate getting that credit |
|
Aug 21st 2013 | 144
|
| credit for what, exactly? |
|
Aug 21st 2013 | 145
|
| playing a Master and entering Marvin Gaye's Property |
|
Aug 21st 2013 | 151
|
| the songs aren't even _that_ similar. |
|
Aug 22nd 2013 | 153
|
| the beat alone sells the song,fyi |
|
Aug 22nd 2013 | 154
|
| yes, it's obviously inspired by 'got to give it up. |
|
Aug 22nd 2013 | 155
|
| pay the Marvin Gaye estate |
|
Aug 22nd 2013 | 165
|
| that's ridiculous. |
|
Aug 23rd 2013 | 175
|
| Old School Soul Brother here |
|
Aug 23rd 2013 | 176
|
| ..i give up. |
|
Aug 23rd 2013 | 177
|
| FYI i don't care for Robin THicke and I'm not alone |
|
Aug 21st 2013 | 134
|
| RE: its my Opinion and feelings on the Matter |
|
Aug 21st 2013 | 139
|
| RE: its my Opinion and feelings on the Matter |
|
Aug 21st 2013 | 142
|
| RE: its my Opinion and feelings on the Matter |
|
Aug 21st 2013 | 147
|
| RE: its my Opinion and feelings on the Matter |
|
Aug 21st 2013 | 152
|
| Nah... |
|
Aug 22nd 2013 | 157
|
| RE: Nah... |
|
Aug 22nd 2013 | 166
|
| should have sampled Pack Jam by Jonzun Crew anyways. |
|
Aug 20th 2013 | 131
|
| that's too black for him |
|
Aug 21st 2013 | 136
|
| what rhymes with 'sue me'? |
|
Aug 21st 2013 | 149
|
| 'declaratory judgment' |
|
Aug 22nd 2013 | 156
|
| this dumb shit is still going? |
|
Aug 22nd 2013 | 158
|
| Musician Nicholas Payton's view on this |
|
Aug 22nd 2013 | 159
|
| this reads like somebody defending pharell. |
|
Aug 22nd 2013 | 160
|
| RE: this reads like somebody defending pharell. |
|
Aug 22nd 2013 | 169
|
| Got to give it up means Pay up |
|
Aug 22nd 2013 | 171
|
| *uncle* |
|
Aug 23rd 2013 | 178
|
| You both hear wrong, which means... you're factually wrong. |
|
Aug 23rd 2013 | 184
|
| Hypocrite |
|
Aug 22nd 2013 | 161
|
| RE: Hypocrite |
|
Aug 22nd 2013 | 170
|
| How does a song |
|
Aug 22nd 2013 | 172
|
| i mean, at this point |
|
Aug 22nd 2013 | 163
|
| part two of that he called Thicke the George Zimmerman of Copyright |
|
Aug 22nd 2013 | 168
|
| So Robin won't be singing w/a hologram Marvin at the grammy's n/m |
|
Aug 22nd 2013 | 167
|
| maybe with Marvin Hamlisch Rip another known jacker |
|
Aug 23rd 2013 | 179
|
| Robin Thicke offered settlement to Gaye family, |
|
Aug 23rd 2013 | 180
|
| WHY DO I HAVE TO PAY ATTORNEY FEES? (c) M. Gaye |
|
Aug 23rd 2013 | 181
|
| do people offer six figures where there's no legit claim? |
|
Aug 23rd 2013 | 182
|
| yes. |
|
Aug 23rd 2013 | 183
|
| Why wouldn't they? |
|
Aug 23rd 2013 | 185
|
| the question was about offering six figures for a claim that wasn't |
|
Aug 24th 2013 | 190
|
| RE: the question was about offering six figures for a claim that wasn't |
|
Aug 24th 2013 | 191
|
| RE: the question was about offering six figures for a claim that wasn't |
|
Aug 24th 2013 | 194
|
| RE: the question was about offering six figures for a claim that wasn't |
|
Aug 24th 2013 | 195
|
| RE: the question was about offering six figures for a claim that wasn't |
|
Aug 24th 2013 | 198
|
| civilians tend to see the issue as you do. |
|
Aug 25th 2013 | 200
|
| turkey you done lost your mind, bringing up a fake MJ case |
|
Aug 25th 2013 | 205
|
| *pats head* |
|
Aug 25th 2013 | 217
|
| you should have never brought up that MJ Case,especially |
|
Aug 25th 2013 | 221
|
| k. |
|
Aug 26th 2013 | 231
|
| defending a case isn't free. |
|
Aug 24th 2013 | 192
|
| this is going to be the end of Thicke |
|
Aug 24th 2013 | 188
|
| not at all. |
|
Aug 24th 2013 | 189
|
| The Family rejected the first "peace offering". |
|
Aug 25th 2013 | 216
|
| Robbing Thicke |
|
Aug 24th 2013 | 193
|
| Did Charlie and them every have a lawsuit file against them |
|
Aug 24th 2013 | 196
|
| turkey how dare you pick on the Gap Band? |
|
Aug 24th 2013 | 197
|
| yes, actually. |
|
Aug 25th 2013 | 199
|
| um, charlie wilson is black. |
|
Aug 25th 2013 | 206
|
| read my thread below, Gap Band,George Duke, ROger and Zapp |
|
Aug 25th 2013 | 211
|
| my bad. you're right. |
|
Aug 25th 2013 | 218
|
| It's a valid example to bring forth........ |
|
Aug 25th 2013 | 201
|
| absolutely. |
|
Aug 25th 2013 | 207
|
| that is a weak counter argument and I pointed out why |
|
Aug 25th 2013 | 209
|
| how is it a jack when the melody and the chord progression |
|
Aug 25th 2013 | 212
|
| please explain away why thicke and Pharell went to the Gaye estate |
|
Aug 25th 2013 | 213
|
| it's been explained. more than once. |
|
Aug 25th 2013 | 219
|
| RE: how is it a jack when the melody and the chord progression |
|
Aug 25th 2013 | 220
|
| again when George Duke, Michael Henderson, Ray Parker Jr |
|
Aug 25th 2013 | 226
|
| RE: again when George Duke, Michael Henderson, Ray Parker Jr |
|
Aug 25th 2013 | 229
|
| RE: again when George Duke, Michael Henderson, Ray Parker Jr |
|
Aug 26th 2013 | 230
|
| RE: again when George Duke, Michael Henderson, Ray Parker Jr |
|
Aug 26th 2013 | 232
|
| time to nip this in the bud,right now |
|
Aug 25th 2013 | 208
|
| Or how About this...... |
|
Aug 25th 2013 | 214
|
| them turkeys stole Marvin Gaye's song period |
|
Aug 25th 2013 | 222
|
| RE: them turkeys stole Marvin Gaye's song period |
|
Aug 25th 2013 | 225
|
| RE: them turkeys stole Marvin Gaye's song period |
|
Aug 25th 2013 | 227
|
| RE: time to nip this in the bud,right now |
|
Aug 25th 2013 | 228
|
| Look we all know what the song reminds of us........... |
|
Aug 25th 2013 | 202
|
| Pharell is a Fraud and a Joke and jacks songs with nothing to it |
|
Aug 25th 2013 | 210
|
| Pharell is not even in my top 20 of all time greats........ |
|
Aug 25th 2013 | 215
|
| they need to pay the Marvin Gaye estate and be sentenced ..... |
|
Aug 25th 2013 | 223
|
| RE: Pharell is not even in my top 20 of all time greats........ |
|
Aug 25th 2013 | 224
|
| The video for Blurred Lines is pretty cool. |
|
Aug 25th 2013 | 204
|
| Yeah. It's enjoyable. |
|
Aug 26th 2013 | 233
|
| slid the headphones and listened to both songs real good |
|
Sep 02nd 2013 | 234
|
Printer-friendly copy 
Email this topic to a friend
The Lesson
