| Subject |
Author |
Message Date |
ID |
 man those snippets have me drooling! |
|
Nov 16th 2011 | 1
|
 ^^This |
|
Nov 21st 2011 | 6
|
| awesome |
|
Nov 16th 2011 | 2
|
| My impressions |
|
Nov 16th 2011 | 3
|
| Eddie "STATS" 10 Out of 10: Track By Track Preview |
|
Nov 16th 2011 | 4
|
| If you find any more reviews post em here |
|
Nov 20th 2011 | 5
|
| Press: ?uestlove on the Huffinton post |
|
Nov 21st 2011 | 7
|
| Like on on-going PHD thesis going no where. |
|
Nov 21st 2011 | 8
|
| LittleX: like a hose that is forever huffed. |
|
Nov 22nd 2011 | 9
|
| sounds like a cunninlynguists album n/m |
|
Nov 22nd 2011 | 10
|
 yeah, it does sound like a dope album |
|
Nov 24th 2011 | 11
|
 LOL |
|
Nov 26th 2011 | 16
|
| I'm saying like that's a bad thing lol |
|
Nov 29th 2011 | 24
|
| i didn't mean it in a bad way at all. |
|
Nov 29th 2011 | 56
|
| oh. okay |
|
Dec 02nd 2011 | 121
|
| which ones better? |
|
Dec 07th 2011 | 190
|
| yeah..it's epically great. |
|
Dec 20th 2011 | 238
|
| The Roots played a snippet Kool On on Jimmy Fallon |
|
Nov 24th 2011 | 12
|
| prolly the only time they'll do it live ... |
|
Dec 08th 2011 | 196
|
| These ?uest interviews are like the liner notes,,new interview |
|
Nov 25th 2011 | 13
|
| definitely a dope read on this one! |
|
Nov 25th 2011 | 14
|
| I didn't even know there was a new album. |
|
Nov 25th 2011 | 15
|
| Ny Daily news review |
|
Nov 26th 2011 | 17
|
| |
|
Nov 28th 2011 | 18
|
| Just finished listening... pretty blown away |
|
Nov 28th 2011 | 19
|
| haven't heard the stream |
|
Nov 29th 2011 | 20
|
| oh, yeah? |
|
Nov 29th 2011 | 21
|
| I haven't heard a single negative thing said about the album |
|
Nov 29th 2011 | 22
|
| Same here, be back later with thoughts n/m |
|
Nov 29th 2011 | 23
|
| where are y'all hearing it? |
|
Nov 29th 2011 | 25
|
| A low quality rip of a stream was ripped |
|
Nov 29th 2011 | 26
|
| how can i hear this? |
|
Nov 29th 2011 | 27
|
| I streamed it n/m |
|
Nov 29th 2011 | 31
|
| Everything I've Heard So Far (Most of It) |
|
Nov 29th 2011 | 28
|
| the album sounds great. |
|
Nov 29th 2011 | 29
|
| RE: The Roots - Undun reviews |
|
Nov 29th 2011 | 30
|
| Shit... |
|
Dec 01st 2011 | 95
|
| album is streaming, in full, at NPR (link) |
|
Nov 29th 2011 | 32
|
| has anyone seen a vinyl pre-order? |
|
Nov 29th 2011 | 33
|
| goddammit at these fuckin choruses |
|
Nov 29th 2011 | 34
|
| I disagree |
|
Nov 29th 2011 | 35
|
| good, cause i like make my! |
|
Nov 29th 2011 | 37
|
| nah, i i don't see any issues with the choruses. |
|
Nov 29th 2011 | 36
|
| good it gets better |
|
Nov 29th 2011 | 38
|
| only one bad to me is One Time. a struggle chorus if i ever heard one. |
|
Nov 29th 2011 | 40
|
| I liked that |
|
Nov 29th 2011 | 41
|
| no problems with the content - it's just horribly delivered. |
|
Nov 29th 2011 | 44
|
| I Think Dice Did A Great Job On The Hooks |
|
Nov 29th 2011 | 45
|
| I agree Dice did great on the hooks |
|
Nov 29th 2011 | 57
|
| they aren't great but |
|
Nov 30th 2011 | 85
|
| Co-Sign |
|
Dec 01st 2011 | 106
|
| these choruses |
|
Dec 06th 2011 | 165
|
| i like them...it brings balance |
|
Dec 07th 2011 | 184
|
| I felt this way at first but after letting the album soak in I hear them... |
|
Dec 12th 2011 | 225
|
| i wish tip the scale was available as an mp3 |
|
Nov 29th 2011 | 39
|
| are you kidding me? only a few tracks in |
|
Nov 29th 2011 | 42
|
| RE: The Roots - Undun reviews |
|
Nov 29th 2011 | 43
|
| It's Great |
|
Nov 29th 2011 | 46
|
| What the fuck is this? Kool On ? |
|
Nov 29th 2011 | 47
|
| Porn was a beast on HIGO |
|
Nov 29th 2011 | 48
|
| that's why i'm scratching my head. |
|
Nov 29th 2011 | 49
|
| RE: Porn was a beast on HIGO |
|
Nov 29th 2011 | 50
|
| fuck me, forgot this is his third |
|
Nov 30th 2011 | 83
|
| Phenomenal. |
|
Nov 29th 2011 | 51
|
| the end of tip the scale is beautiful. |
|
Nov 29th 2011 | 52
|
| I kind of agree |
|
Nov 29th 2011 | 55
|
| I'm lovin Lighthouse |
|
Nov 29th 2011 | 53
|
| Kool On is probably my fav though |
|
Dec 03rd 2011 | 134
|
| Kool on and Lighthouse of my favorite songs of the year really. |
|
Dec 20th 2011 | 239
|
| off my first few listens, im not into this at all |
|
Nov 29th 2011 | 54
|
| I just finished listening to the album, it gave me a "Water" type feel |
|
Nov 29th 2011 | 58
|
| RE: I just finished listening to the album, it gave me a "Water" type fe... |
|
Dec 01st 2011 | 102
|
| I think you may be right |
|
Dec 01st 2011 | 109
|
| Listened to it front to back 4 times so far today. Lovin it!!! |
|
Nov 29th 2011 | 59
|
| To be honest, on first spin, parts I didn't really dig. But it grows on... |
|
Nov 30th 2011 | 60
|
| same here. |
|
Nov 30th 2011 | 61
|
| 14 to 1. |
|
Nov 30th 2011 | 62
|
| thanks. |
|
Nov 30th 2011 | 63
|
| I'm hoping the cliff notes for the life sequence is ... |
|
Nov 30th 2011 | 64
|
| i gave them on this very site. |
|
Nov 30th 2011 | 65
|
| cliff notes from 15 |
|
Nov 30th 2011 | 75
|
| 15 - Did you consider letting people figure it out for themselves |
|
Nov 30th 2011 | 77
|
| I See What You Mean But |
|
Nov 30th 2011 | 78
|
| Huh? |
|
Dec 01st 2011 | 111
|
| boom n/m |
|
Dec 02nd 2011 | 113
|
| no, it's me that misread bentagain. |
|
Dec 02nd 2011 | 115
|
| It was the fist comparison that came to mind |
|
Dec 02nd 2011 | 117
|
| RE: 15 - Did you consider letting people figure it out for themselves |
|
Dec 19th 2011 | 237
|
| I feel like a fool ... |
|
Nov 30th 2011 | 82
|
| Initial impressions: Solid |
|
Nov 30th 2011 | 66
|
| Felt effortless |
|
Nov 30th 2011 | 67
|
| agree with all of this |
|
Nov 30th 2011 | 84
|
| Also surprised that some of the songs work outside of the context |
|
Dec 06th 2011 | 159
|
| wow... |
|
Nov 30th 2011 | 68
|
| RE: The Roots - Undun reviews |
|
Nov 30th 2011 | 69
|
| think it was one track and they had to |
|
Nov 30th 2011 | 72
|
| RE: The Roots - Undun reviews |
|
Nov 30th 2011 | 74
|
| listen to the stream.... |
|
Nov 30th 2011 | 70
|
| Glide Magazine @@@@1/2 |
|
Nov 30th 2011 | 71
|
| Still waiting for Tuesday but |
|
Nov 30th 2011 | 73
|
| I Tried To Hold Out But I Gave In |
|
Nov 30th 2011 | 76
|
| RE: The Roots - Undun reviews |
|
Nov 30th 2011 | 79
|
| So far, so good |
|
Nov 30th 2011 | 80
|
| Love The Album, The Ambition, The Theme |
|
Nov 30th 2011 | 81
|
| RE: Love The Album, The Ambition, The Theme |
|
Dec 04th 2011 | 135
|
| incredible album. grown man hip hop. fav track is... |
|
Nov 30th 2011 | 86
|
| ?uestlove on Soundcheck podcast |
|
Nov 30th 2011 | 87
|
| love it, of course. |
|
Nov 30th 2011 | 88
|
| it's simply a different album |
|
Nov 30th 2011 | 89
|
| The Other Side....... |
|
Nov 30th 2011 | 90
|
| Bilal Man |
|
Dec 01st 2011 | 101
|
| wow bilal wow |
|
Dec 03rd 2011 | 128
|
| Bilal and them organs. favorite track |
|
Dec 06th 2011 | 170
|
| iPhone and iPad app out NOW |
|
Nov 30th 2011 | 91
|
| the only time I ever wished I had apple products ... |
|
Nov 30th 2011 | 92
|
| Greg P.O.R.N.......is a problem! |
|
Dec 01st 2011 | 93
|
| It's really too bad OKP records didn't really take off... |
|
Dec 01st 2011 | 94
|
| "Kool On" and "Stomp" are ridiculous. |
|
Dec 01st 2011 | 96
|
| Entertainment Weekly review (A-) |
|
Dec 01st 2011 | 97
|
| The Independent uk review (Positive) |
|
Dec 01st 2011 | 98
|
| To 15 and the whole crew.....Thank You |
|
Dec 01st 2011 | 99
|
| BBC review (Positive) |
|
Dec 01st 2011 | 100
|
| I REALLY like Dice and PORN on this |
|
Dec 01st 2011 | 103
|
| lol |
|
Dec 01st 2011 | 104
|
| third verse!!! |
|
Dec 01st 2011 | 105
|
| Pithcfork interview |
|
Dec 01st 2011 | 107
|
| this is brilliant guys... |
|
Dec 01st 2011 | 108
|
| This shit resonates. |
|
Dec 01st 2011 | 110
|
| this album is beautiful man. |
|
Dec 02nd 2011 | 112
|
| DICE & G PORN are dope on this. |
|
Dec 04th 2011 | 136
|
| The Guardian (UK): 3 out of 5 stars (link) |
|
Dec 02nd 2011 | 114
|
| I want to write for the Guardian and EW |
|
Dec 02nd 2011 | 118
|
| NPR First Listen (LINK) / nom nom nom can't wait bart scott |
|
Dec 02nd 2011 | 116
|
| why is Just Blaze getting credit for Stomp? |
|
Dec 03rd 2011 | 129
|
| Chicago Tribune review (4 of 4 stars) |
|
Dec 02nd 2011 | 119
|
| hey, i'm credited on "make my!" |
|
Dec 02nd 2011 | 120
|
| excellent |
|
Dec 02nd 2011 | 122
|
| NSU Review |
|
Dec 02nd 2011 | 123
|
| The Globe and Mail review (Canada) - 3.5 of 4 stars |
|
Dec 02nd 2011 | 124
|
| Thee Business |
|
Dec 03rd 2011 | 125
|
| hows this compare to prince paul Prince Among thieves or sticky's |
|
Dec 03rd 2011 | 126
|
| Review: my original uncut review of undun |
|
Dec 03rd 2011 | 127
|
| THS ALBUM IS FUCKING AMAZING |
|
Dec 03rd 2011 | 130
|
| I really dig "I Remember" & "Tip The Scale". |
|
Dec 03rd 2011 | 131
|
| woooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo!!!!!!!! |
|
Dec 03rd 2011 | 132
|
| Hold up though, why this Illmatic time length? |
|
Dec 03rd 2011 | 133
|
| short album, easier to digest as a fan |
|
Dec 05th 2011 | 152
|
| Songs in the key of life disagrees with you |
|
Dec 06th 2011 | 158
|
| what an inane response. |
|
Dec 14th 2011 | 227
|
| Redford sounds like some Radiohead |
|
Dec 04th 2011 | 137
|
| it's a portion of sufjan steven's song of the same name |
|
Dec 04th 2011 | 138
|
| I'm thinking I might be liking this album more backwards |
|
Dec 04th 2011 | 139
|
| thoughts.... |
|
Dec 04th 2011 | 140
|
| So no skits huh?? |
|
Dec 04th 2011 | 141
|
| PopMatters 8/10 (personal swipe, wish we had 8.5s) |
|
Dec 04th 2011 | 142
|
| Philadelphia Examiner: * * * 1/2 |
|
Dec 04th 2011 | 143
|
| Soul Culture (UK): 4 1/2 out of 5 |
|
Dec 05th 2011 | 144
|
| HipHopDX: 5 out of 5 |
|
Dec 05th 2011 | 145
|
| dice's hooks are the low for me |
|
Dec 05th 2011 | 146
|
| which ones? |
|
Dec 05th 2011 | 147
|
| the hook on One Time nearly ruins the song for me |
|
Dec 05th 2011 | 148
|
| one time is okay, but it does sound off |
|
Dec 05th 2011 | 150
|
| I've had that song on repeat today |
|
Dec 08th 2011 | 194
|
| sound like he recorded that in the shower, gargling water. |
|
Dec 09th 2011 | 214
|
| still not a fan of "make my" |
|
Dec 05th 2011 | 149
|
| see, i love make my |
|
Dec 05th 2011 | 151
|
| basically all of them |
|
Dec 05th 2011 | 154
|
| shit he killed these hooks come a long way form Rising Down |
|
Dec 07th 2011 | 185
|
| hooks are better, he needs to not sing them |
|
Dec 08th 2011 | 205
|
| Front-Free.com: positive review |
|
Dec 05th 2011 | 153
|
| The Other Side is a classic Roots track |
|
Dec 06th 2011 | 155
|
| Pitchfork Media: 7.3/10 |
|
Dec 06th 2011 | 156
|
| Out of curiosity |
|
Dec 06th 2011 | 160
|
| RE: Out of curiosity |
|
Dec 06th 2011 | 162
|
| those albums are suited for the pitch4ork crowd too |
|
Dec 06th 2011 | 164
|
| |
|
Dec 06th 2011 | 157
|
| 1st (Black) Thoughts |
|
Dec 06th 2011 | 161
|
| re: Dice's choruses |
|
Dec 06th 2011 | 163
|
| yeah I recently posted about this above. |
|
Dec 06th 2011 | 175
|
| Los Angeles Times Undun Review 3.5 stars (out of 4) |
|
Dec 06th 2011 | 166
|
| Rolling Stone 3.5 |
|
Dec 06th 2011 | 167
|
| when is the last time RS rated a hip hop album above 3.5? |
|
Dec 06th 2011 | 174
|
| really? |
|
Dec 06th 2011 | 176
|
| AllHipHop.com: 8.5 out of 10 |
|
Dec 06th 2011 | 168
|
| Spin 7/10 (link) |
|
Dec 06th 2011 | 169
|
| i think the notion that Redford lacks individuality is valid |
|
Dec 06th 2011 | 172
|
| Heavy Album.... |
|
Dec 06th 2011 | 171
|
| Paste magazine = 8.4 |
|
Dec 06th 2011 | 173
|
| So is that Mercedes on "I Remember" ? |
|
Dec 06th 2011 | 177
|
| Word! She kinda reminded me of Solange tho. |
|
Dec 07th 2011 | 186
|
| The "Make My" breakdown reminds me a lot |
|
Dec 06th 2011 | 178
|
| First spin...Stomp! |
|
Dec 06th 2011 | 179
|
| Iheartdilla review |
|
Dec 07th 2011 | 180
|
| Holy shit. This album is a masterpiece. Wow. |
|
Dec 07th 2011 | 181
|
| define masterpiece |
|
Dec 07th 2011 | 187
|
| The A.V. Club review (A) |
|
Dec 07th 2011 | 182
|
| All Music review - (4.5 of 5 stars) |
|
Dec 07th 2011 | 183
|
| this is a great fucking album |
|
Dec 07th 2011 | 188
|
| one more side note |
|
Dec 07th 2011 | 189
|
| same thought I've been having all day |
|
Dec 08th 2011 | 191
|
| hard to argue with that... |
|
Dec 08th 2011 | 192
|
| I like the previous 3 albums quite a bit. |
|
Dec 08th 2011 | 193
|
| people in Redford's life as opposed to playing him from different angles |
|
Dec 08th 2011 | 197
|
| I thought ?uest said on here that |
|
Dec 08th 2011 | 203
|
| different personalities of Redford |
|
Dec 09th 2011 | 213
|
| actually it was confirmed that they're all Red |
|
Dec 09th 2011 | 216
|
| Quest already said its all Redford though |
|
Dec 08th 2011 | 208
|
| this is a great album, make my, kool on & tip the scale and the |
|
Dec 08th 2011 | 195
|
| Straight.com - Vancuver |
|
Dec 08th 2011 | 198
|
| comments like this really irk me... |
|
Dec 08th 2011 | 199
|
| GREAT album, gets better with each listen, and BANGS in the car. |
|
Dec 08th 2011 | 200
|
| a complete live version of this album would kill |
|
Dec 08th 2011 | 201
|
| ^^^there it is |
|
Dec 08th 2011 | 204
|
| For as important as the lyrics are for this, why aren't they in the book... |
|
Dec 08th 2011 | 202
|
| RE: Dice's hooks |
|
Dec 08th 2011 | 206
|
| this would be a copout and an excuse |
|
Dec 08th 2011 | 209
|
| jesus, let it go. |
|
Dec 09th 2011 | 210
|
| heaven forbid we discuss something on a discussion board |
|
Dec 09th 2011 | 212
|
| harping endlessly on about something makes for wonderful discussion. |
|
Dec 09th 2011 | 220
|
| 'Kool On' & 'Lighthouse' are my favorites |
|
Dec 08th 2011 | 207
|
| IGN |
|
Dec 09th 2011 | 211
|
| 40+min of blank space, i wish the album played chronologically. |
|
Dec 09th 2011 | 215
|
| Even if it's not meant to be heard that way? Interesting |
|
Dec 09th 2011 | 218
|
| yeah. |
|
Dec 14th 2011 | 229
|
| yea this was the basis of my PopMatters review |
|
Dec 10th 2011 | 222
|
| >< |
|
Dec 14th 2011 | 230
|
| This could be their Berlin (Lou Reed) |
|
Dec 09th 2011 | 217
|
| Look at OKC review |
|
Dec 09th 2011 | 219
|
| would have been cool to let Thought sing a hook or 2 IMO |
|
Dec 09th 2011 | 221
|
| um, that's the jazzyfatnastees on I Remember |
|
Dec 11th 2011 | 223
|
| fair enough but I think the hook could use more |
|
Dec 18th 2011 | 236
|
| Lighthouse is amazing |
|
Dec 12th 2011 | 224
|
| 100 Albums, 100 Weeks: A/A- |
|
Dec 13th 2011 | 226
|
| Dice Raw sounds great. |
|
Dec 14th 2011 | 228
|
| WBEZ review - 3.5 out of 5 |
|
Dec 16th 2011 | 231
|
| out of 4. |
|
Dec 16th 2011 | 233
|
| News-mail.AU 4.5 out of 5 |
|
Dec 16th 2011 | 232
|
| NPR- Weekend Edition (story + 10 audio minute review) |
|
Dec 18th 2011 | 234
|
| Relevant Magazine Review |
|
Dec 18th 2011 | 235
|
| late, but got dang @ 'Lighthouse'. |
|
Dec 22nd 2011 | 240
|
| Rap Reviews |
|
Dec 23rd 2011 | 241
|
| debuts at #17 on billboard hot 200. 2nd week, falls to #70 |
|
Dec 23rd 2011 | 242
|
| seriously... this might be the most satisfying Roots album in years. |
|
Dec 23rd 2011 | 243
|
| The Smoking Section |
|
Dec 27th 2011 | 244
|
| MetaCritic score: 88/100 |
|
Dec 29th 2011 | 245
|
Printer-friendly copy 
Email this topic to a friend
The Lesson
