|
My issue with this episode though was how much was riding on it. I liked the episode for what it was, but as I mentioned up above the entire season was riding on strong execution of episode 3 and 7. They made a big decision to split those two episodes up with several in between with one showing a different perspective. Love the idea. But for it to work in a satisfying way there would need to be some kind of big reveal or twist involved. This was much more subtle in terms of perspective, essentially just revealing that there were multiple small mistakes by several characters leading to a tragic result and not any one or two characters who did something terrible. Which is fine.
But if it was a subtle perspective difference, then this could have just been shown together in one of episode. Or at most, in back to back episodes. The entire season was hinting about something terrible that Sol was hiding, with him continually saying “okay I’m about to tell you what happened” but getting interrupted. To make the decision to split it up like this, not have a huge twist, and still leave several questions unanswered (what is Qimir’s involvement in all this, what did he mean by saying he was a Jedi a long, long time ago, what did they do to create Mae and Osha (beyond there just being a force vergence, they were actively created, and what happened with Mother Koril because she bounced before the other witches were killed), etc.)
We’ll see how they land the airplane with the finale next week but I feel like there is too much left on the table at this point to make it truly satisfying.
That being said, this is Star Wars and I love it. We finally got to see an adult Wookie Jedi in live action fighting, and it was amazing. Plus the added seasoning of him being under witch control. That was terrifying. I love what they are showing with the Jedi in this series in terms of different kinds of flaws. Sol is great. I wonder why he is so connected with Osha, but I love his passion, the decisions he made, etc. I love that we got more of Indara and her perspective (and flaws - she almost snapped on Sol in that one scene.) Master Korbin as well - cool to see how his mind was invaded, and she essentially amplified a feeling that he had which ended up leading to him making the choice to ruin everything by going to break back into the coven to get proof of the vergence so he could go home.
Again, I love how everyone made small mistakes that added up to tragedy. Life the overall story. I just wish this was executed better.
|