|
I've only watched it once so far. I'm sure my appraisal will change somewhat upon repeat viewings.
I don't normally say this or even notice it, but I don't think it ended as strongly as it started. I worry that I might come off like one of those insufferable "The Last Jedi" haters. But Star Trek is more important than Star Wars.
I still adored the season as a whole, and there were some things I genuinely appreciated in the finale, but it didn't deliver all of what I'd wanted it to deliver. Ironically, I think the problem is that it's now a multi-year series. Even though that was officially the plan from the beginning, and even though they were greenlit for season 2 before the first episode even aired... still, I was viewing it as something more like a miniseries than a full series. I wanted more finality.
It felt like the writers were dithering a bit on what the endgame would be, and they ended up with something that cheapened nearly all of their options. The idea of bringing in the irumodic syndrome from the TNG finale, and using it as a driving emotional (and logistical) center for all that followed, that was my favorite thing about how they conceptualized this series. And then they just threw it all away with the dumb "golem" thing. Picard sacrifices his life to save humanity! Then, lucky us, there was a golem right here (with conveniently unformed biological tissues) and a guy who knows something about transferring memories from a human brain! Nothing has to change. Jean Luc survives after all! And he's an android now. Sort of. He's a biological android, but he doesn't have any "special powers" like the others do. The body is the same as it ever was. We never have to mention ever again that he's now a "synth." He's still an old man. He's still gonna die, some day. The only thing that's different is they fixed his parietal lobe, magically took away the disease that he'd been coming to terms with this whole time. Does this mean they've now cured ALL diseases, even death itself? Sadly, no, because Bruce Maddox only built the one golem before he was killed. Dammit Aggie!
Wasn't there a classic Simpsons bit about everything comes back to normal at the end of every episode. I got the feeling here that everything was going back to normal, way too easily.
It reminds me of the end of Discovery season 2, when suddenly everyone decides (for some reason I don't even remember) "we will never talk about Michael Burnham or the Discovery or the spore drive or Control ever again."
There were so many different paths they could have taken. The three that were going through my head:
* Picard dies but Data is resurrected into the golem. From there on Captain Data leads a new crew (with Raffi, Rios, Elnor, and conveniently-pardoned Jurati as senior officers) in a new ship named in Picard's honor.
* Picard survives but still suffers from the irumodic syndrome. Season 2 (as a recurring side story) involves an even deeper exploration of his mental deterioration. Maybe there's a "new data," maybe not.
* Picard and Data are somehow 'merged' in the golem's consciousness (RIP Tuvix). The new character could be played by Stewart, Spiner, or someone else.
* The most satisfying ending would have probably been the most obvious one. Picard sacrifices himself for Soji, saves the universe, dies, the show continues (I guess) as the crew carries on in his name. This is what I thought was happening right up until he walked into the light. I honestly thought they were doing the afterlife scene really well. I will say, I'm GLAD it didn't go this particular way, because Patrick Stewart really was the best part of this show. So I'm glad we didn't lose him.
Anyway, I'm VERY glad Alton Soong didn't turn out to have been Lore all along. A lot of people seemed to be expecting that in reviews of episode 9. And I like the fact that they strongly implied, without outright saying, that it wasn't actually a super-advanced synthetic civilization they were contacting; it was just "Control" from Discovery. I guess they'll be able to explore that some more in Discovery season 3, which I'm now really looking forward to.
I'm a little disappointed that we didn't get to find out whether the Admonition was left by the Tkon empire, and more, that we didn't get to find out more about the Tkon empire. Maybe that'll be a part of what happens next season. Or maybe it was all just idle Trekkie hypothesizing. I rewatched The Last Outpost a few days ago. Shitty episode! But there's something romantic about a long-lost ancient society in Star Trek. I wish they did it more.
Despite all my quibbles (which are really almost entirely isolated to the golem thing), I still think this show has been as good as Star Trek has ever been. I'm looking forward to the next season, whenever it's safe again for an 80 year old man to spend long days on shooting sets. Thankfully, from what I understand, they finished all the filming for Discovery S3 before Coronavirus came along. That might be all the Star Trek we get for the next few years. But I'm looking forward to it. They're finally free of the shackles of prequelism and able to do big new things.
Oh, one last thing: "Blue Skies" is a dumb fucking tune. I'm glad we don't have to hear it again.
|