|
>The lyrics may have had personal resonance for her, but they >were not "personal lyrics." May seem like a purely semantic >distinction, but it's a relevant one.
Lol
No, its an idiot distinction from someone who thinks that they need to tell me that Cynda Williams didn't write a 60 year old song, for the love of god.
She is singing the lyrics with personal resonance, and the choice of THAT song isn't random. She could have sung any fucking song, and sung THAT one. From within the story, it fits. From the filmmakers perspective, it fits.
It fits unless you're an insecure overanalyzer.
>That much being said, if you listen to the lyrics they don't >seem to reflect the situation between Bleek and Clarke much at >all.
Jesus Christ.
Stop it.
Yes, they do.
>Except she's not doing either one of those things. > >http://youtu.be/Me3-NI1xfYo > >There's nothing in the blocking, the camera moves, the editing >or the acting that infers she's singing to Bleek, and she does >not appear any more emotional than one would expect a singer >to project during the performance of a ballad.
She's staring dead at Bleek the minute the she notices him standing there, sparky. That's how the song ends.
>And her chemistry seems to be directed towards Wesley. That's >the dude she's connecting with there... not Denzel.
That's because Denzel isn't in the fucking club when she starts singing, for god's sakes.
>Of course you don't care, because it completely demolishes >whatever stupid point you think you're making and which you >will continue to defend (as is your wont) in spite of all >evidence to the contrary.
Negroid-
You're over here nitpicking the quality of her singing, talked about how it ruined the scene.
No, it didn't.
Like, at all.
>But for the sake of those who actually value concrete evidence >over delusion, here's a quote from Spike on his intentions in >the scene: > >"You'll notice 'Harlem Blues' is not scripted. I never made a >formal revision to the script, but it was added after I >decided that Clarke should be a good singer and not just a >wannabee {sic}. Raymond's arrangement of 'Harlem Blues' had >been in the back of my mind for a year. Not only is it a great >song, but it was the perfect vehicle for Cynda Williams' debut >as a singer."
LOL -- that doesn't mean her singing was random and wasn't constructed to fit within the landscape of the story. That film is a masterpiece, full of unscripted and organic energy that was worked in nicely.
Shush.
>It's really neither one of those. It's her just singing a song >as a professional, not to spite Bleek...
LOL -- nobody said that, dumb nigga.
though Bleek's >expression shows that he realizes he was wrong. She doesn't >even particularly acknowledge that he's there while she's >singing... which makes it worse, because Bleek realizes he's >irrelevant now.
Yes, she does. And his performance that night is PLANNED, which means she knows he's going to be there *ahead* of time.
>Funny thing is that I'm just talking about shit that actually >happens in the movie, and citing things that the >writer/director of the movie said he was intending in the >movie and you claim that I'm overanalyzing shit... meanwhile, >you've moved outside the movie to start analyzing (badly btw) >what supposedly makes a good jazz singer... None of that shit >has anything to do with the movie.
Nah, you're overanalyzing.
>Personally, I don't think Cynda's singing was that good. It >was not bad, but neither was it as good as the scene wanted it >to be. That's my opinion, though, and really neither here nor >there as it concerns the bigger picture.
Lol
>(I'll thank you not to refer to me by "nigger" btw... I >realize that it's your trollish proclivity to try to get under >people's skins but I really don't have time for that game. I >felt like engaging in a civil discussion about one of my >favorite films, but if you want to take things *that way* I >will not go with you)
Lol
----------------------------
O_E: "Acts like an asshole and posts with imperial disdain"
"I ORBITs the solar system, listenin..."
(C)Keith Murray, "
|