|
Any kid that grew up on some variation of Jimi Hendrix, Bob Marley, Bob Dylan, The Stones, The Beatles, Sly Stone, Stevie Wonder, Led Zep, Sabbath, AC/DC, Marvin Gaye, Al Green, Miles Davis, P-Funk, James Brown, Pink Floyd, and so on can say the same.
By high-school and at the latest up thru first year or two of college, that stuff had all found its way into my eardrums and most of it was spread amongst my social circles as well.
I'm sure I'm not alone in that either, most of that shit was pretty easy to find either though radio, uncles, older siblings/cousins, cool friends that knew more shit than you did, etc.
I still loved Nirvana & the like as it came out but I wasn't under some misguided impression that the rock genre was peaking just at the time I happened to be alive.
Anybody that's an avid music fan rather than just a casual listener is gonna go back and check the past to see what they like or don't.
The rap I was listening to growing up obviously skewed more towards what was coming out right in the moment but that's because it hadn't even fully blossomed to its artistic/commercial zenith yet being that it was less than ten years old at the time (and really less than five in terms of being album-driven).
That was one of the most interesting things about it, it was a form of music that was actually created & being expanded upon during the time I actually existed.
Now, that's not really the case. Kids now are literally being born the same year Doggystyle, Illmatic, 36 Chambers were dropping.
They don't even remember a life before this stuff like I don't remember a world where Jimi Hendrix or Bob Marley appeared in the flesh rather than as a poster on a wall.
Rap has almost surely seen it's commercial apex (particularly with the entire music industry exploding into itself) sometime at the end of the 90's bleeding into the early 2000s.
While there's still great shit dropping every year, unlike people our age there's quite a backlog of established classic shit to check in with which was not the case for a kid born in the mid-to-late-70s.
I've actually been surprisingly impressed by how much the teenage kids I speak to actually do know about the rap music of at least the 90's (the late 80's gets a bit trickier, that's begun to feel more like the mid-to-late-50s of rock where folks know Little Richard/Chuck Berry/Elvis/Buddy/etc but nobody's really *listening* to it for pleasure).
I feel better than ever about some of the people I see/hear doing rap shit (as opposed to say, 10 years ago) because at this point it's so obvious there's not much money in it that most of the youngest practitioners are clearly lovers of the craft who did study those old records.
PE, on the other hand, is an odd case.
They were without question *the biggest* group in terms of impact/import during a three-year-period (88-90), at least on the east-coast where the music started & the tastemakers resided at the time.
But they were so strange & anachronistic even in their heyday that you didn't really have people copying them then and nowadays (unlike peers like Slick Rick, Kane, Rakim & even to a degree Too Short) you don't even have folks listening to them at all.
Comparing It Takes A Nation to Loveless, Nothing's Shocking or Daydream Nation isn't a proper parallel.
Those records were college-rock/SpinMag-style curiosities while the vast majority of rock fans in 1988 were knee-deep in Appetite For Destruction.
It Takes A Nation was more like Exile On Main Street, There's A Riot Goin On, The White Album for its genre.
A left turn that became one of the first & biggest early musical statements in hip-hop that now seems on the brink of being forgotten by the majority of it's genres fans nowadays.
Part of that is because of how less-than-stellar a lot of their seemingly endless post-91 musical output has been, another is Flav's becoming a reality sideshow, some of it could be a backlash to their adoption into the rock music circle (hence why their induction to the R&RHOF this year was such a lock even over NWA) and probably more than a little has to do with the dense/layered early Bomb Squad production not even being an option legally nowadays so the youth doesn't have the same ear for it.
But for those reasons & a few others I'm leaving out, PE has went from being looked at as 'our Zeppelin' to more like The Kinks or MC5 in the minds of rap music fans: groups rock fans either know only thru a few of their biggest songs or from reading about their rebellion long after the edges had been sanded down to dust.
That's worth taking notice of and I'm fairly sure the answer is a lot more inscrutable than the facile 'young cat vs old head' or 'they came out 25 years ago' explanation you're offering there.
|