"The 1,000 Most Recommended Artists of All Time (swipe)"
Before getting worked up because of how wrong he is, you should read the article so you understand how he developed the list. Also, there are links to other lists (3,000 songs and 6,000 albums) in the Mental Floss article.
By day, Henrik Franzon is a tax agent in Stockholm, working for the Swedish equivalent of the IRS. In his off hours, the statistician uses his skills to sort through a much hipper set of data. It could be argued that more than anyone at Pitchfork or Rolling Stone or NME, this bureaucrat is the ultimate oracle of just how respectable your musical tastes are.
Franzon collects music critics’ lists the way botanists collect seeds. Some are lists of the best songs or albums ever. Others are parsed by genre or country or era. He draws them from magazines, the ever-expanding online music press, and a few books. Using a complex algorithm, he has aggregated these to create massive lists of the most acclaimed albums, songs, and artists of all time. Since 2003, the continually updated results have been published on his website, AcclaimedMusic.net. Right now, the site contains ranked lists of the 1,000 artists, 3,000 albums, and 6,000 songs most beloved to music writers around the globe.
He admits his hobby is odd. “When I showed to my friends, they thought I was insane,” Franzon recalls. But as a lover of both music and statistics, he kept refining his formula and collecting and inputting lists. “I like to work with this kind of data,” he says. “There’s no right or wrong,” as to which music is actually best, “which makes it different than other statistics.”
Franzon, 42, grew up on acts like Depeche Mode and The Cure during the blossoming of the print-media music press. He says he’s been interested in these lists since a retrospective on the best albums of all time in a Swedish music magazine expanded his tastes.
His aggregate rankings don’t simply measure the number of times a song or album winds up on a list. “There are a lot of parameters,” says Franzon. All-time lists count for more than more limited lists, like year-end round-ups or lists ranking the best of a genre. Lists representing the view of a publication or institution (like the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame’s Songs that Shaped Rock and Roll) count for more than lists of an individual critic (like Greil Marcus’ book The History of Rock ‘n’ Roll in Ten Songs). Lists that come from a place that doesn’t produce a lot of lists (i.e., outside the critics’ bubbles of New York and London) get more weight. But lists that contain a bunch of picks not usually on such lists get less weight, as a guard against deliberately provocative musical musings. Newer lists count for more than older lists. A song or album’s place on a ranked list is factored in. The algorithm also incorporates ratings from sites like AllMusic and Metacritic.
To put it succinctly, Franzon gathers up critical accolades, factors in a few parameters to steer the results towards reflecting global critical opinion of the best of the best, and then crunches the numbers. AcclaimedMusic.net provides his footnotes. Click on an item and you’ll see which lists it’s on.
By design, the top results won’t surprise vinyl geeks quick to click such lists whenever they’re published by the likes of Rolling Stone.
The top 15 albums: 1. The Beach Boys, Pet Sounds 2. The Beatles, Revolver 3. Nirvana, Nevermind 4. The Velvet Underground, The Velvet Underground & Nico 5. The Beatles, Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band 6. The Clash, London Calling 7. Marvin Gaye, What's Going On 8. The Rolling Stones, Exile on Main St. 9. Bob Dylan, Blonde on Blonde 10. Radiohead, OK Computer 11. Bob Dylan, Highway 61 Revisited 12. The Sex Pistols, Never Mind the Bollocks - Here's the Sex Pistols 13. The Beatles, The Beatles (“The White Album”) 14. The Jimi Hendrix Experience, Are You Experienced? 15. Van Morrison, Astral Weeks
The top 15 songs: 1. Bob Dylan, “Like a Rolling Stone” 2. Nirvana, “Smells Like Teen Spirit” 3. The Beatles, “A Day in the Life” 4. The Beach Boys, “Good Vibrations” 5. The Rolling Stones, “(I Can't Get No) Satisfaction” 6. Marvin Gaye, “I Heard It Through the Grapevine” 7. The Ronettes, “Be My Baby” 8. The Beatles, “Strawberry Fields Forever” 9. Aretha Franklin, “Respect” 10 . Marvin Gaye, “What's Going On” 11. Joy Division, “Love Will Tear Us Apart” 12. Chuck Berry, “Johnny B. Goode” 13. Bruce Springsteen, “Born to Run” 14. The Who, “My Generation” 15. Elvis Presley, “Heartbreak Hotel”
The top ten artists (as determined by an algorithm incorporating the number of their works in Franzon’s information matrix and the ranks of those works):
1. The Beatles 2. Bob Dylan 3. The Rolling Stones 4. David Bowie 5. Bruce Springsteen 6. Radiohead 7. Neil Young 8. Elvis Presley 9. The Beach Boys 10. Prince
Expanding from there, the top few hundred songs and albums offer some more of the expected: seas of classic rock, vintage soul and work from ’50s-era pioneers, with a few islands for punk, early hip-hop, dance music, alt-rock, and the unclassifiable Prince.
But there are some surprises, particularly for American audiences. British rock from the alternative spectrum competes very well, even in the cases of singles that never got much U.S. airplay. Standing beside the Elvis and Dylan classics in the top 100 songs are Pulp’s “Common People” (#41), Massive Attack’s “Unfinished Sympathy” (#50), The Specials’ “Ghost Town” (#77), and three by The Smiths: “There Is a Light That Never Goes Out” (#78), “How Soon Is Now?” (#83), and “This Charming Man” (#84).
This is because the British music press can be somewhat insular, and heavy acclaim within it can make up for obscurity, hence Portishead's four songs in the top 1,000 to AC/DC’s three. “In the U.K., they have a lot of famous magazines,” says Franzon. “But they don’t reflect the whole world.”
Alternatively, one could argue that American ears have been sadly deaf to much of the best stuff to come from across the pond since the ’80s.
21st-century acts do crack the upper echelons. The top 100 songs boast nine from the new millennium, and the top 100 albums have eight. Newer songs turn up on the year-end lists that music pubs churn out in droves. A single year-end list doesn’t count for much, but Franzon has refined his algorithm so that a song or album in the top of almost every such list rockets ahead. He argues that if a song like M.I.A.’s 2008 smash “Paper Planes” (#42) or Daft Punk’s 2013 international hit “Get Lucky” (#55) makes it onto almost every list for which they’re eligible, they should move ahead of older songs, which might show up on more best-of-all-time lists but then make a smaller percentage of other lists. Such an album or song will drop quickly if it doesn’t keep picking up accolades.
His parameters and ways of pruning his lists have been debated on his website’s forum, which Frazen says has stayed quite friendly by the standards of people discussing music on the Internet.
There are unlimited ways to divide and subdivide Franzon’s data, and AcclaimedMusic.net is full of sub-lists parsed by year, genre and country of origin. There are even lists of the most acclaimed artists from every state in the U.S. (In case you were wondering, the five most acclaimed artists from Pennsylvania are Nine Inch Nails, The Roots, Todd Rundgren, Stan Getz, and The War on Drugs, in that order.) The site is dotted with Spotify playlists to help you enjoy these miniature lists.
As a statistician, Franzon says he’d never allow his personal tastes to affect his data, but he does cheer when his favorite Depeche Mode song, “Enjoy the Silence,” goes up a rank. (It’s currently #415.) His favorite song of all time is “All Is Full of Love” by Björk (#3,636)—the single version, not the album version, he specifies—and his favorite album is Songs of Leonard Cohen (#149).
Even though Franzon says his coworkers don’t quite understand his off-hours obsession, they do sometimes use it to break up the tedium of a day at the Swedish tax office. He and his colleagues have developed a game: One will name a year and a number, and ask to hear the song ranked at that number on Franzon’s sub-list for that year. Franzon will cue it up on Spotify and the tax agents will try to name that tune.
“Usually, they don’t get it,” says Franzon. “A lot of them don’t even know Nirvana.”