| Subject |
Author |
Message Date |
ID |
 Best Writer |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 1
|
 joss wheadon. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 33
|
| Brian K. Vaughn. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 37
|
 Co-sign |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 63
|
| Co-Sign |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 80
|
| yeah...yeah, okay |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 109
|
| yeah |
|
Nov 19th 2005 | 202
|
 yep. |
|
Nov 20th 2005 | 230
|
| Grant Morrison |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 151
|
| Next year's gonna be great too |
|
Nov 19th 2005 | 220
|
| RE: Best Writer |
|
Nov 19th 2005 | 228
|
| yes |
|
Nov 22nd 2005 | 266
|
| RE: Best Writer |
|
Nov 22nd 2005 | 270
|
| Best Artist |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 2
|
| this one is a little tougher... |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 34
|
| really tough coice, but i favor Eduardo Risso. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 39
|
| Tie: John Cassady and Tony Harris |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 69
|
| RE: Tie: John Cassady and Tony Harris |
|
Nov 22nd 2005 | 271
|
| Eric Powell. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 119
|
| co-sign |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 135
|
| Stuart Immonem |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 152
|
| Best Overall Comic Book |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 3
|
| The Ultimates 2. Nothing else compares. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 35
|
| Ex Machina |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 42
|
| I think I'm gonna hafta cosign here |
|
Nov 19th 2005 | 218
|
| JSA |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 153
|
| I have to say JSA as well |
|
Nov 29th 2005 | 282
|
| RE: Best Overall Comic Book |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 196
|
| Astonishing X-Men |
|
Nov 19th 2005 | 214
|
| yup. |
|
Nov 22nd 2005 | 267
|
| Kabuki - David Mack |
|
Nov 21st 2005 | 233
|
| Best Story Arc |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 4
|
| Anything surrounding Infinite Crisis. Possibly, Sacrifice. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 36
|
| JLA: Crisis of Conscience |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 87
|
| Sacrifice |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 154
|
| Best Single Issue |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 5
|
| Countdown to Infinite Crisis. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 38
|
| Seven Soliders: Guardian #4 |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 126
|
| Solo #5(?) The Darwyn Cooke issue. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 155
|
| Yep |
|
Nov 19th 2005 | 221
|
| Another contender: The Incredible Hulk #82: "Dear Tricia..." |
|
Nov 23rd 2005 | 275
|
| Best Hero |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 6
|
| Wolverine. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 40
|
| Wolverine |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 156
|
| Mayor Hundred |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 188
|
| Best Villain |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 7
|
| I don't know if this counts, but... |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 43
|
| Danger |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 74
|
| King Crab from Shaolin Cowboy #2 |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 138
|
| yessir. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 145
|
| Jason Todd |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 157
|
| Best Anti-Hero |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 8
|
| Again... |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 45
|
| Batman |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 48
|
| definitely Batman |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 136
|
| Catman |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 78
|
| Batman. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 158
|
| Desolation Jones |
|
Nov 19th 2005 | 203
|
| Best Marvel Book |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 9
|
| The Ultimates 2. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 46
|
| Ultimates |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 51
|
| Ultimates 2 |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 159
|
| Astonishing X-Men |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 194
|
| Runaways |
|
Nov 19th 2005 | 204
|
| Best DC Book |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 10
|
| Justice or Infinite Crisis. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 47
|
| Gotham Central. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 50
|
| SOLO |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 148
|
| yeah, i gotta second that. |
|
Nov 21st 2005 | 232
|
| JSA |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 160
|
| Villains United |
|
Nov 19th 2005 | 205
|
| Best Indie |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 11
|
| B.P.R.D. count as indie? |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 53
|
| nah, Dark Horse is the third-rated comic company |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 92
|
| Stray Bullets |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 89
|
| easily |
|
Nov 19th 2005 | 206
|
| The Goon |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 100
|
| Local |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 161
|
| RE: Local |
|
Nov 21st 2005 | 262
|
| I'm saving my Local votes for next year |
|
Nov 22nd 2005 | 263
|
| Best Graphic Novel |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 12
|
| Ice Haven |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 96
|
| Best Moment |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 13
|
| oops |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 14
|
| last page of Astonishing #12. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 55
|
| Cosign. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 162
|
| RE: Best Moment |
|
Nov 22nd 2005 | 273
|
| Best Team |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 15
|
| It will always be the X-Men (I include all of them as one big group), bu... |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 58
|
| The Six |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 82
|
| The Ultimates |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 142
|
| Ultimate Xmen |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 163
|
| RE: Best Team |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 197
|
| Best Fight |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 16
|
| This is tough. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 60
|
| Deathstroke vs. Hawkman, Green Lantern, Flash, Green Arrow... |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 98
|
| this was a fantastic climax |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 103
|
| Cosign. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 164
|
| Danger vs X-Men from Astonishing X-Men |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 99
|
| Best Turnaround for a once shitty comic. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 17
|
| Ultimate Fantastic Four |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 76
|
| Wolverine |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 165
|
| Best Movie Based on A Comic Book Character |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 18
|
| Batman Begins |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 22
|
| Batman Begins. Hell this is movie of the year period. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 61
|
| Sin City |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 79
|
| Yes |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 97
|
| Cosign! |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 166
|
| RE: Cosign! |
|
Dec 01st 2005 | 283
|
| Batman Begins |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 101
|
| Batman Begins |
|
Nov 19th 2005 | 212
|
| Best Miniseries |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 19
|
| We3 |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 49
|
| We3 was gonna be my choice too |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 59
|
| HUGE CO-SIGN. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 62
|
| I woulda said this but the two best issues came out in 2004. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 83
|
| Villains United |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 56
|
| This is my runner-up |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 102
|
| Vimanarama |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 167
|
| Space Ghost. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 120
|
| that did kinda kick ass, didn't it? |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 121
|
| great writing and artwork |
|
Nov 19th 2005 | 207
|
| bullseye. i changed my mind. |
|
Nov 24th 2005 | 277
|
| Best 'Oh Shit!' Moment |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 20
|
| last page of Astonishing #12. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 65
|
| Clint a.k.a. Hawkeye getting murked in Ultimates 2 |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 168
|
| cannot believe i forgot that one. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 190
|
| this is tougher than i expected |
|
Nov 18th 2005 |
|
| Best 'Event' |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 21
|
| Seven Soldiers |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 23
|
| Infinite Crisis |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 54
|
| Yup. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 66
|
| Infinite Crisis |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 111
|
| This isn't an event it's an epic! |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 169
|
| Best Mini Series |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 24
|
| that's easy Villans United |
|
Nov 26th 2005 | 278
|
| Best First Issue |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 25
|
| ummm... i'm gonna say All Star Superman |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 27
|
| I'm with you... I think |
|
Nov 19th 2005 | 226
|
| Infinite Crisis #1 |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 95
|
| ^^Never lies. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 170
|
| Nat Turner. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 143
|
| It's almost 2006, and I STILL can't find that joint |
|
Nov 19th 2005 | 227
|
| Best Punch Thrown |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 26
|
| Green Lantern knocking Batman on his ass in 'Rebirth' |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 44
|
| IC #1- Earth-2 Superman punching his way thru REALITY |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 150
|
| Jason Todd clocking Timmy Drake |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 171
|
| Biggest Disappointment |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 28
|
| PAD's return to the Hulk |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 57
|
| RE: PAD's return to the Hulk |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 198
|
| House of M and All-Star Batman and Robin. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 68
|
| 'Identity Crisis' #7 - Jean Loring?!?! |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 70
|
| i dunno... |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 72
|
| I was okay with Jean Loring, but the rest of the issue sucked |
|
Nov 19th 2005 | 213
|
| Rann-Thanagar War |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 172
|
| ghost rider |
|
Nov 19th 2005 | 208
|
| House of M |
|
Nov 19th 2005 | 225
|
| i got another one... RUNAWAYS. |
|
Nov 21st 2005 | 243
|
| Captain Marvel's continued wussification at DC |
|
Nov 28th 2005 | 281
|
| the conclusion of NYX |
|
Dec 01st 2005 | 285
|
| Worst Writer |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 29
|
| I am sorry, but its... |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 84
|
| Frank Miller on All-Star God-Damned Batman and Robin |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 173
|
| Worst Artist |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 30
|
| Rob Liefield in Teen Titans |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 52
|
| haha yep |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 104
|
| COSIGNED! |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 174
|
| Worst Single Issue |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 31
|
| All-Star Batman & Robin #2 |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 77
|
| i could agree with this. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 88
|
| The gay prison sex issue of Outsiders. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 175
|
| i thought it was funny |
|
Nov 26th 2005 | 279
|
| Worst Story Arc |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 32
|
| "The Insiders" Teen Titans/Outsiders |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 176
|
| the one where the Gwen Stacey/Norm Osborne love twins show up |
|
Nov 19th 2005 | 224
|
| most underrated comic. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 41
|
| Grounded n/m |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 64
|
| i have all 3 issues but i've read only the first so far |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 67
|
| X-Men b/c of Salvador's art. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 71
|
| co sign |
|
Nov 19th 2005 | 215
|
| Lucifer |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 73
|
| wow... you're the only person i know who reads this book |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 93
|
| The Walking Dead |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 107
|
| yep |
|
Nov 19th 2005 | 209
|
| why do people stay sleeping on this title? |
|
Nov 24th 2005 | 276
|
| I think a lot of people got lost with the whole horror revival...... |
|
Dec 01st 2005 | 284
|
| Ultimate X-men |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 177
|
| kinda early, and i dont even know if they will continue with it but... |
|
Nov 22nd 2005 | 272
|
| Best New Ongoing Series |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 75
|
| probably All-Star Superman. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 86
|
| Young Avengers |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 131
|
| DMZ |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 178
|
| Runaways |
|
Nov 19th 2005 | 223
|
| Best Comic You Think No One Is Reading |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 81
|
| tie: Legion of Superheroes and Manhunter |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 94
|
| Winter Men |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 106
|
| what is this book about? school me. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 110
|
| so far it's sort of this Russian spy thriller |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 147
|
| G0dland |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 118
|
| (tie) Lucifer & The Losers |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 130
|
| The Legion of Super-Heroes |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 179
|
| Fables |
|
Nov 26th 2005 | 280
|
| Most Underrated Writer |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 85
|
| Will Pfeifer |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 105
|
| Brian Wood. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 180
|
| He did sorta win an Eisner |
|
Nov 19th 2005 | 216
|
| Alot of people catch Zs on him; thus he's over looked! |
|
Nov 22nd 2005 | 265
|
| RE: Brian Wood. |
|
Nov 22nd 2005 | 274
|
| Dave Gibbons... or Stan Sakai |
|
Nov 19th 2005 | 217
|
| 2006 will be the year of __________ |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 90
|
| Marvel. I think they got some BIG plans. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 91
|
| Superman |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 108
|
| 2006 will be the year of the Xmen. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 181
|
| Hell yea! |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 189
|
| Best Warren Ellis Book |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 112
|
| Desolation Jones |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 115
|
| yep |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 123
|
| I concur |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 134
|
| Best Short |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 113
|
| Batman A Go-Go from SOLO #7, by Mike Allred |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 116
|
| ^^Yes! |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 183
|
| Cooke's Batman story in SOLO |
|
Nov 19th 2005 | 210
|
| Best TPB Collection |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 114
|
| Absolute Watchmen seems like the obvious choice |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 117
|
| i wouldn't call it a TPB, though |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 124
|
| haha... oh yeah. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 133
|
| Best Cover |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 122
|
| Allred's SOLO |
|
Nov 19th 2005 | 211
|
| yeah, probably |
|
Nov 19th 2005 | 219
|
| Seven Soldiers #0 or JLA #118 |
|
Nov 21st 2005 | 259
|
| Best Bendis Book |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 125
|
| Daredevil |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 127
|
| Daredevil |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 139
|
| Best Death |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 128
|
| Maxwell Lord |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 141
|
| Blue Beetle |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 184
|
| Co-sign. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 191
|
| Best Seven Soliders Mini |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 129
|
| Manhattan Guardian. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 144
|
| Klarion the Witch Boy |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 185
|
| Best Series You Just Started Reading This Year (not debuting in 2005) |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 132
|
| Eightball |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 140
|
| Ex Machina. wait. did that debut this year or last? |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 146
|
| Adventures of Superman |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 186
|
| Avengers (New) |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 192
|
| TIE |
|
Nov 21st 2005 | 234
|
| Best Comeback (Character) |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 137
|
| Catman |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 149
|
| Zatanna |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 187
|
| Seven Soldiers |
|
Nov 19th 2005 | 222
|
| Worst Death |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 182
|
| if someone comes back from the dead, then that will be the worst. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 193
|
| yeah, I almost wanna say Hawkeye, from HoM #7 |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 195
|
| im digging Piotr's "Bloodlines" tho |
|
Nov 21st 2005 | 231
|
| The wizard SHAZAM! |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 199
|
| Cheesiest villain?! |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 200
|
| The Top. |
|
Nov 18th 2005 | 201
|
| The Fiddler (R.I.P.) |
|
Nov 20th 2005 | 229
|
| Best cover artist |
|
Nov 21st 2005 | 235
|
| James Jean |
|
Nov 21st 2005 | 247
|
| Best up-and-coming writer |
|
Nov 21st 2005 | 236
|
| Is Brian Wood up-and-coming? |
|
Nov 21st 2005 | 250
|
| Nah, he's been around for a minute. |
|
Nov 21st 2005 | 251
|
| Well, yeah, I know that. My point is... |
|
Nov 21st 2005 | 253
|
| I dunno about that |
|
Nov 21st 2005 | 256
|
| okay, how about this then: |
|
Nov 21st 2005 | 260
|
| I meant more on the lines of a newjack |
|
Nov 22nd 2005 | 268
|
| I can dig it |
|
Nov 22nd 2005 | 269
|
| Best up-and-coming artist |
|
Nov 21st 2005 | 237
|
| Frazier Irving (S7: Klarion) |
|
Nov 21st 2005 | 244
|
| Ryan Kelly |
|
Nov 21st 2005 | 254
|
| Best non-comic comic related item (magazine, action figure, book etc.) |
|
Nov 21st 2005 | 238
|
| Thanos action figure |
|
Nov 21st 2005 | 242
|
| Frank Cho Sketchbook Vol 2 |
|
Nov 21st 2005 | 246
|
| POLYBAGS!!! |
|
Nov 21st 2005 | 255
|
| Worst book from a good writer |
|
Nov 21st 2005 | 239
|
| AKA, worst Warren Ellis book: Ocean |
|
Nov 21st 2005 | 245
|
| It was so bad. I just forgot it ever happened. |
|
Nov 21st 2005 | 249
|
| Outsiders by Judd Winick |
|
Nov 21st 2005 | 257
|
| Worst book from a good artist |
|
Nov 21st 2005 | 240
|
| Alan Davis on Uncanny X-Men... OR |
|
Nov 21st 2005 | 252
|
| cosign on alan davis. |
|
Nov 21st 2005 | 261
|
| The "I can't believe they printed this bullshit" award. |
|
Nov 21st 2005 | 241
|
| Liberality for All |
|
Nov 21st 2005 | 248
|
| definitely |
|
Nov 22nd 2005 | 264
|
| House of M |
|
Nov 21st 2005 | 258
|
Printer-friendly copy 
Email this topic to a friend
Pass The Popcorn 
#/media/File:Firefly.png)
