Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby Okay Sports topic #2688366

Subject: "In retrospect: How high is Bo on your GOAT NFL running backs list" Previous topic | Next topic
COOLEHMAGAZINE
Member since May 22nd 2007
5563 posts
Wed Feb-20-19 09:44 AM

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
"In retrospect: How high is Bo on your GOAT NFL running backs list"


          

Obviously he didn't play full seasons, and his career was cut short, so we are not looking at aggregate stats here. That said, for those who watched him play, where do you rank him now that we are so far removed from both the hype, and the pain of seeing him get hurt.

It's a good time to talk about running backs because the way the NFL is going we are not going to see as many great athletes at running back, and when we do they will probably be catching the ball as much as they carry it. Additionally the tendency to platoon backs, while not even calling many run plays, and the creeping ubiquity of the spread, make evaluation even harder. Lastly, the only plays a lot of these guys get to run are shotgun draw plays that don't suit every type of back, and are more about keeping people honest in the passing game than actually putting the back in a position to make plays.


First question; was he actually BETTER than Marcus Allen?


What about the stars of the era that's ending now; Adrian Peterson? Marshawn Lynch?



Is he up there with guys like Barry and Walter?

I'm from the lost black tribe of Israel, the Yos

http://coolehmag.com/frontEnd/

  

Printer-friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote


In retrospect: How high is Bo on your GOAT NFL running backs list [View all] , COOLEHMAGAZINE, Wed Feb-20-19 09:44 AM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
I have him second behind Walter
Feb 20th 2019
1
RE: I have him second behind Walter
Feb 20th 2019
2
      I believe that you asked a general question...
Feb 20th 2019
6
           RE: I believe that you asked a general question...
Feb 20th 2019
10
                just like in most sports but especially in football its tough to compare...
Feb 20th 2019
12
                RE: just like in most sports but especially in football its tough to com...
Feb 20th 2019
17
                     what?!
Feb 20th 2019
23
                          RE: what?!
Feb 20th 2019
34
                               nah...
Feb 20th 2019
38
                                    RE: nah...
Feb 20th 2019
45
                                    RE: nah...
Feb 20th 2019
54
                                    then why arent the top 25 recruits all RBs every year?
Feb 20th 2019
50
                                         because football players come in different sizes and shapes...
Feb 20th 2019
55
                                              lol
Feb 21st 2019
61
                RE: I believe that you asked a general question...
Feb 20th 2019
19
                     RE: I believe that you asked a general question...
Feb 20th 2019
35
                          Here’s why I would...
Feb 20th 2019
36
                               Barry not sharing the backfield with someone else is an argument
Feb 21st 2019
69
                                    RE: Barry not sharing the backfield with someone else is an argument
Feb 21st 2019
71
obviously he career was incomplete, at his peak nobody was better...
Feb 20th 2019
3
RE: obviously he career was incomplete, at his peak nobody was better...
Feb 20th 2019
4
      Any great RB at their “height” can be seen as the GOAT
Feb 20th 2019
7
      you can't really rank him overall, he's in the incomplete category with....
Feb 20th 2019
9
           RE: yo can't really rank him overall, he's in the incomplete category wi...
Feb 20th 2019
11
                RE: yo can't really rank him overall, he's in the incomplete category wi...
Feb 20th 2019
14
                     RE: yo can't really rank him overall, he's in the incomplete category wi...
Feb 20th 2019
18
                          RE: yo can't really rank him overall, he's in the incomplete category wi...
Feb 20th 2019
24
                               RE: yo can't really rank him overall, he's in the incomplete category wi...
Feb 20th 2019
28
                                    RE: yo can't really rank him overall, he's in the incomplete category wi...
Feb 20th 2019
39
                                    RE: yo can't really rank him overall, he's in the incomplete category wi...
Feb 20th 2019
41
Too short to really rank him properly
Feb 20th 2019
5
Frank Gore deserves more respect
Feb 20th 2019
8
RE: Frank Gore deserves more respect
Feb 20th 2019
13
yeah he gets props for longevity but no way he's top 5...
Feb 20th 2019
16
i mean there are so many parameters, but why not Gore?
Feb 20th 2019
20
      Nah.. dude is special tho
Feb 20th 2019
21
      So you have Gore ahead of AP? Dickerson? Faulk?
Feb 20th 2019
22
      yeah, Faulk is definitely arguable
Feb 20th 2019
26
           no its not lol...
Feb 20th 2019
40
      RE: i mean there are so many parameters, but why not Gore?
Feb 20th 2019
25
           yeah we are using diff criteria then
Feb 20th 2019
27
                RE: yeah we are using diff criteria then
Feb 20th 2019
29
                     alright my bad my bad. ill play this game then
Feb 20th 2019
31
                          RE: alright my bad my bad. ill play this game then
Feb 20th 2019
32
                               AP is the man... i look at Marshawn as a slight tier above him
Feb 20th 2019
33
                               where did LT carry a team that AP didn't? and Marshawn is...
Feb 20th 2019
56
                               LT > AP for my money
Feb 20th 2019
51
                               RE: LT > AP for my money
Feb 21st 2019
70
                               Forgot about LT
Feb 20th 2019
53
His best years were some of the 49ers worst
Feb 21st 2019
75
      RE: His best years were some of the 49ers worst
Feb 21st 2019
76
not very. Durability matters
Feb 20th 2019
15
RE: not very. Durability matters
Feb 20th 2019
30
on ability as good as anyone to ever do it innit?
Feb 20th 2019
37
Marcus Allen was really good
Feb 20th 2019
42
RE: Marcus Allen was really good
Feb 20th 2019
46
      Based on what they did in college? Marcus.
Feb 20th 2019
48
      Is Ki-Jana Carter still on the board?
Feb 20th 2019
49
           RE: Is Ki-Jana Carter still on the board?
Feb 20th 2019
57
In the top-5 of my Woulda-Coulda-Shoulda List...
Feb 20th 2019
43
He is like Gayle Sayers. You enjoy the highlights.
Feb 20th 2019
44
Delete this shit. He had a few short good years. Stop it.
Feb 20th 2019
47
Barry's worst 2 yr rushing total (min 16 gm): 2656 yds 22 TD
Feb 20th 2019
52
I’m saying. And people in this post putting Barry and Bo in the same
Feb 20th 2019
58
RE: Barry's worst 2 yr rushing total (min 16 gm): 2656 yds 22 TD
Feb 21st 2019
65
RE: Delete this shit. He had a few short good years. Stop it.
Feb 20th 2019
59
      Bo has less than 3K yards. He's not in any conversation. End post.
Feb 21st 2019
60
           RE: Bo has less than 3K yards. He's not in any conversation. End post.
Feb 21st 2019
63
Those youtube clips have everyone hyped.
Feb 21st 2019
62
RE: Those youtube clips have everyone hyped.
Feb 21st 2019
64
I have no problem at all with your original post - it's a good question.
Feb 21st 2019
66
RE: I have no problem at all with your original post - it's a good quest...
Feb 21st 2019
67
You mad. And secondly, I watched Bo in college and the NFL.
Feb 21st 2019
72
      RE: You mad. And secondly, I watched Bo in college and the NFL.
Feb 21st 2019
74
you may be partially right...
Feb 21st 2019
68
      RE: you may be partially right...
Feb 21st 2019
73

Lobby Okay Sports topic #2688366 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com