Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby Okay Sports topic #2479513

Subject: "RE: do they have to be realistic?" Previous topic | Next topic
mashpg89
Member since Dec 08th 2004
2867 posts
Tue Sep-29-15 10:52 AM

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy listClick to send message via AOL IM
11. "RE: do they have to be realistic?"
In response to In response to 10


  

          


>EHH i dont mind this. Normal shooting motion could be a hard
>judgement call.
>I would just say if you jump into the defender once you get
>him in the air, no foul on either party - play on unless its
>egrigious.

I see this at least 3x a game (maybe cause Mirotic does it a lot). It's pretty simple, from a set shot all players basically jump straight up when they're trying to get a shot off. They don't jump to the left or right, and don't jump forward 2 feet. If it's a legitimate attempt at a shot then reward them FTs, if it's just an attempt to draw contact, train the refs to see it as such and give them the ball side out or no call. The refs were trained to determine the same factors for the rip through move, so it's plausible.



>For me these arent realistic but id love
>
>1 and 1 Fts til you hit a double bonus. I hate automatic 2 fts
>on shooting penalty.

I'm down with anything that would speed the game up, especially for the first 3 quartes.

>If you slide under a player who is already in the air it
>should be a block not a player control foul.
>
>Once a guy launches he cant really change his flight pattern,
>if you slide under him thats on you. Should be a defensive
>foul.

haha, pretty sure that's already a rule:

A defensive player must allow an alighted player the distance to land and then stop or change direction when the offensive player is outside the lower defensive box.

http://www.nba.com/analysis/rules_c.html?nav=ArticleList

totally agreed though, in fact I'd love to see what an NBA game is like without any charges.

  

Printer-friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote


P.S. its NBA MEdia Day for most the League: 15-16 Pre-season Chatter [View all] , ShawndmeSlanted, Mon Sep-28-15 11:56 AM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
running thru the 6 w/ better-than-grandmama
Sep 28th 2015
1
At least he gets a passionate hug from Drake.
Sep 28th 2015
3
As I prefer to call it, the day immediately before reality sets in.
Sep 28th 2015
2
10 observations from Pistons media day:
Sep 28th 2015
4
before the season gets started, what rules would you like to see changed...
Sep 29th 2015
5
do they have to be realistic?
Sep 29th 2015
10
lol that's what the rule is...refs jjust need to be better.
Oct 01st 2015
20
RE: before the season gets started, what rules would you like to see cha...
Sep 30th 2015
18
Kyrie to drive less, pass more
Sep 29th 2015
6
That's very insightful.
Sep 29th 2015
7
Media Day Interviews (link)
Sep 29th 2015
8
AKA the last day I watch Sportscenter
Sep 29th 2015
9
its been a solid 2 years since i watched any CFB shows
Oct 03rd 2015
25
word is the #2KnicksReunion is gonna be deferred
Sep 29th 2015
12
Pistons rookie Johnson impresses on first day of camp
Sep 29th 2015
13
RE: Pistons rookie Johnson impresses on first day of camp
Sep 29th 2015
14
      i kind of like that small ball lineup
Oct 03rd 2015
24
Cavs practice to be Facebook's first live sports simulcast
Sep 29th 2015
15
Dorrell Wright's Open Letter to Delon about Rookie year
Sep 30th 2015
16
Proki doing Russian Bear Circus Tricks
Sep 30th 2015
17
Some bits from the Wolves live training camp the other day
Oct 01st 2015
19
Harden adn Adidas make it official
Oct 01st 2015
21
:)
Oct 02nd 2015
22
Ps game 1 is on now: Denver vs clippers
Oct 02nd 2015
23
Deangelo went down hard and was helped off
Oct 06th 2015
26

Lobby Okay Sports topic #2479513 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com