Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby Okay Sports topic #2107121

Subject: "Better Career & Player: Magic or Kobe?" Previous topic | Next topic
melmag
Charter member
18469 posts 		Wed Jan-09-13 12:24 PM

Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
"Poll question: Better Career & Player: Magic or Kobe?"


  

          

this was posed on ESPN last nite with Kobe winning by a 52% to 48% margin..

but I've noticed that when this question is posed, its basically code for "who is/was the better player" lol


I say Magic easily on both accounts. I wont even go into how Magic is the better player because, really, if you saw Magic in his prime, aint no way Kobe compares.

But career wise might be more debateable but I still give the edge to Magic. Only reason this is even worthy of debate is cus Magic career was cut short

but what says OKS tho?

Poll result (41 votes)
Magic: better player & better career (25 votes)Vote
Magic: better player only (1 votes)Vote
Magic: better career only (0 votes)Vote
Kobe: better player & better career (10 votes)Vote
Kobe: better player only (1 votes)Vote
Kobe: better career only (4 votes)Vote

  

  
Printer-friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote


Better Career & Player: Magic or Kobe? [View all] , melmag, Wed Jan-09-13 12:24 PM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
Magic better player. tied for careers nm
Jan 09th 2013
1
^ where I'm at.
Jan 09th 2013
11
agreed
Jan 09th 2013
19
how is it a tie for careers though?
Jan 10th 2013
58
Kobe better player and career. Magic is more iconic though
Jan 09th 2013
2
dint you start watching b-ball when AI got drafted tho?
Jan 09th 2013
3
      RE: he's arguably a GOAT player
Jan 09th 2013
24
both careers are phenomenal, but Magic is the FAR better player
Jan 09th 2013
4
Magic = better player and career by far...
Jan 09th 2013
5
Don't matter, both top 5 all-time
Jan 09th 2013
6
WRONG
Jan 09th 2013
7
Kobe got more rings that Bron, Dream and Oscar combined...
Jan 09th 2013
9
      and none of em had a player nearly as good/dominant as Shaq
Jan 09th 2013
27
Kobe barely cracks top-5 Lakers
Jan 09th 2013
8
      I love the extremes on both sides. Only Cap and Magic were better
Jan 09th 2013
16
      dude come on, wilt was a better player but not a better LAKER
Jan 10th 2013
60
Some of your poll options are synonymous, lol.
Jan 09th 2013
10
how so?
Jan 09th 2013
13
      Magic better player only = Kobe better career only, etc.
Jan 09th 2013
25
#32 better player, more all time epic games, true leadership
Jan 09th 2013
12
Magic by a landslide. Magic is top 3 or 5 all time. Kobe isn't
Jan 09th 2013
14
Magic was a better all-around player, HIV gave Kobe a better career tho
Jan 09th 2013
15
probably right. But careers is close. nm
Jan 09th 2013
17
Kobe's getting all those legacy/cumulative numbers tho
Jan 09th 2013
21
      But is just playing longer a better career though
Jan 09th 2013
23
           no but El thinks Pierce had a better career than AI so I'm trying
Jan 09th 2013
26
           full disclosure on that....
Jan 09th 2013
43
                how is AI not better than Pierce?
Jan 09th 2013
45
                AI is first ballot, Pierce second, both HOF'ers
Jan 10th 2013
64
           RE: But is just playing longer a better career though
Jan 09th 2013
41
                Well, you didn't refute any of the statements I made
Jan 10th 2013
54
                     RE: Well, you didn't refute any of the statements I made
Jan 10th 2013
68
even with HIV, magic;s career was better, dude
Jan 10th 2013
59
better question would this LA squad be below .500 w/ Magic?
Jan 09th 2013
18
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Jan 09th 2013
30
^ putting it in context right here.
Jan 09th 2013
31
depends, 34 year old magic or 16th year in the league magic?
Jan 09th 2013
32
Uh you do remember missing the 2005 playoffs, right?
Jan 10th 2013
61
      that's a different question
Jan 10th 2013
66
I'll say this. Magic would be better on this squad, but for the 2006
Jan 09th 2013
34
17 years in with Pau and Dwight hurt? nigga are you serious? nm
Jan 10th 2013
50
      lol you act as if Dwight was a no show till he got seriously hurt
Jan 10th 2013
55
      did magic have any years like 2005, 2006 and 2007?
Jan 10th 2013
62
RED
Jan 09th 2013
20
Magic won a chip in HS, NCAA, NBA + Olympic gold medal...
Jan 09th 2013
22
Magic 'died' a hero, kobe lived long enough to become a villian
Jan 09th 2013
28
lol he was always a villain, get over it
Jan 10th 2013
65
lol..earvin on both counts
Jan 09th 2013
29
Remember this?
Jan 09th 2013
33
      i compliment bitches eryday...its what i do
Jan 09th 2013
38
      "best ever" ... that's one hell of a compliment
Jan 09th 2013
40
           i knew tweedle dumb would show up..magic still better
Jan 09th 2013
42
      Awwww shit!!!
Jan 09th 2013
44
Magic in a blowout
Jan 09th 2013
35
You DO know Magic ran a coach out too, right?
Jan 09th 2013
37
nigga said eddie jones lite...lol
Jan 09th 2013
39
      caught that shit too
Jan 10th 2013
48
Magic is clearly better but careers are very close
Jan 09th 2013
36
Magic by a wide margin, personally
Jan 09th 2013
46
funny how this could be referring to sex or basketball with these guys
Jan 10th 2013
47
Kobe is the Ray Lewis of basketball
Jan 10th 2013
49
RE: Better Career & Player: Magic or Kobe?
Jan 10th 2013
51
Kobe only has better athleticism/off. skillset, except court vision
Jan 10th 2013
52
Andre Miller agrees
Jan 10th 2013
53
both guys found style in function and function in style but magic ...
Jan 10th 2013
63
name another point a guard in recent memory that
Jan 10th 2013
56
Red, obviously, but it's a rough comparison because of style
Jan 10th 2013
57
Kobe = Better Scorer Magic = Better Teammate nm
Jan 10th 2013
67

Lobby Okay Sports topic #2107121 Previous topic | Next topic
   

Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com