Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby Okay Sports topic #2097576

Subject: "How can one justify giving Andrew Luck a ROY vote?" Previous topic | Next topic
micMajestic
Charter member
22708 posts
Sun Dec-23-12 10:58 PM

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
"How can one justify giving Andrew Luck a ROY vote?"


  

          

In what capacity has his performance been superior to RG3's or Russell Wilson's?
_________________________________________
The Combat Jack Show is the best hip-hop related internet radio show
http://thecombatjackshow.com/

I put bread on your head like powdered toast man

  

Printer-friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote


How can one justify giving Andrew Luck a ROY vote? [View all] , micMajestic, Sun Dec-23-12 10:58 PM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
Based on things you can't measure numerically like "clutch" and "white"
Dec 23rd 2012
1
lol
Dec 23rd 2012
2
^^^
Dec 23rd 2012
13
2-14 is a number.
Dec 25th 2012
85
he's been playing like an asshole since the Miami game
Dec 23rd 2012
3
There's no arguing that all three are having amazing seasons.
Dec 23rd 2012
5
Kirk Cousins getting a win kinda throws shade on RG3 tho..
Dec 23rd 2012
4
So if you feel that's a blemish then you vote for Wilson. Right?
Dec 23rd 2012
6
Right today, probably Wilson but the bottom line is all 3 are legit
Dec 24th 2012
54
keep pushing it.
Dec 23rd 2012
7
      Morris is 3rd in the league in rushing and also a rookie..
Dec 23rd 2012
10
           Morris w/ RG3 - 4.9 YPC. Morris w/ Cousins - 3.2 YPC. Just saying.
Dec 24th 2012
17
                but Morris is still a rookie and 3rd in the league in rushing..
Dec 24th 2012
53
                     dude just stop
Dec 24th 2012
61
                     This isn't even 1% true
Dec 24th 2012
70
                     smh
Dec 25th 2012
73
                     ONE GAME? he supposed to be the franchise player and we're ...
Dec 25th 2012
90
                          lol
Dec 26th 2012
110
several clutch wins. most passing yds ever for a rookie
Dec 23rd 2012
8
So you'd be comfortable taking a degree of difficulty argument over
Dec 23rd 2012
9
I think Wilson's numbers would be off the charts w/o this tho
Dec 24th 2012
20
sub 55% completions, 18 ints, 27th rated passer
Dec 23rd 2012
11
If you don't count RG3, Russell can have it.
Dec 23rd 2012
12
Playoffs
Dec 23rd 2012
15
lol
Dec 24th 2012
25
      Give RGIII that Seattle defense and we already have the division won
Dec 24th 2012
36
      Give Dangeruss that NFC Least division and we do too
Dec 24th 2012
41
      but the NFC East is better overall than the West
Dec 24th 2012
42
      NFC West is 3-1 vs the NFC Least this year
Dec 24th 2012
49
           that means nothing
Dec 24th 2012
69
                your opinion of that means nothing
Dec 25th 2012
77
                     team rankings
Dec 25th 2012
80
      Dangeruss! Awesome nickname jigga
Dec 24th 2012
58
      I can't take credit for that. Can't recall where I first heard it either...
Dec 25th 2012
79
           THAT'S HIS TWITTER.
Dec 25th 2012
94
      ARI and STL are still in the NFCW right?
Dec 24th 2012
59
           77
Dec 25th 2012
78
                RG3 is the current OROY leader
Dec 25th 2012
81
      I'm glad somebody said it. Washington's D has
Dec 24th 2012
68
      GET 'EM SMUTS!
Dec 24th 2012
37
      let me give you this again:
Dec 24th 2012
72
           if only his best performances counted
Dec 25th 2012
74
                HUH?
Dec 25th 2012
76
                     who goes by since wk x?
Dec 26th 2012
106
                          lol. escalate? you gonna whip my ass? really GTFOH.
Dec 26th 2012
114
                               last chance
Dec 26th 2012
122
Whoopdeedoo.
Dec 24th 2012
16
cant wait to send the seagulls home cryin on a flight outta DC
Dec 24th 2012
38
      You wanna Snickers while you're waitin?
Jan 07th 2013
136
Cmon dude. Absolutely there is a strong argument for Russel Wilson.
Dec 24th 2012
18
God, you are an idiot
Dec 24th 2012
19
      no he's right, yall just got that propaganda the NFL fed you...
Dec 24th 2012
39
           you're an even bigger idiot
Dec 24th 2012
43
                hey hey lol, fuck you buddy
Dec 24th 2012
45
                     I already entertained it with a rational discussion
Dec 24th 2012
47
                          it's my belief that Irsay, as owner, is powerful enuf to impact all thos...
Dec 24th 2012
48
                               the roster was inherently flawed
Dec 24th 2012
50
yea but hes a redskin
Dec 24th 2012
23
that's basically the only argument against RG3
Dec 24th 2012
27
This post is bleeding Burgundy and Yellow
Dec 24th 2012
30
this post bleeds Alex Smith or whatever you're on about.
Dec 24th 2012
32
      the vagina of one close to you (if not you) bleeds from Alex Smith
Dec 24th 2012
35
           you said "Yards=fantasy football points."
Dec 24th 2012
62
                There's no need
Dec 24th 2012
66
                     http://tinyurl.com/ckkzwr2
Dec 25th 2012
75
                     you made an exceptionally stupid comment
Dec 25th 2012
82
                          no you just got butthurt and tried to take it out of context
Dec 25th 2012
102
RG3 is also tied with Alex Smith in passer rating
Dec 24th 2012
71
      Alex Smith is basically a walking example
Dec 25th 2012
83
           it's only meant to be a measure of passing efficiency
Dec 26th 2012
118
his INT rate is average
Dec 24th 2012
29
      GW drives is a mixed stat
Dec 24th 2012
31
           Like this?
Dec 24th 2012
33
           none of that had anything to do with my point.
Dec 24th 2012
60
           people asked how it was possible, i made a case
Dec 26th 2012
115
                Here is why I don't like the "game winning drive" argument for any QB
Jan 02nd 2013
126
wait, I'll make my argument soon *finishes putting on whiteface makeup*
Dec 23rd 2012
14
i don't think either of them is a bad choice.
Dec 24th 2012
21
I'd vote for RG3 though I said Luck would be better ultimately
Dec 24th 2012
22
^^^^Coming in here trying to be all rational and shit.
Dec 24th 2012
26
aka, why Adrian Peterson won't win MVP either
Dec 24th 2012
28
i dunno, he might, what interests me more than MVP is CPOY
Dec 24th 2012
34
Having seen RG3 play well in the pocket all year why do you
Dec 24th 2012
46
      mainly sticking to my guns, lol, but i mean ...
Dec 24th 2012
52
Russ vs Luck common opponents
Dec 24th 2012
24
Luck has done a lot with that team....
Dec 24th 2012
40
On The Flipside
Dec 24th 2012
56
ppl will give him votes just to not look stupid over preseason
Dec 24th 2012
44
RE: How can one justify giving Andrew Luck a ROY vote?
Dec 24th 2012
51
Because ALL HE DO IS WIN
Dec 24th 2012
55
a) No Marshawn Lynch b) Throws more than screens
Dec 24th 2012
57
Neither of Them Have a Reggie Wayne though
Dec 24th 2012
63
I dunno why this is so hard to understand...
Dec 24th 2012
64
      yea you can look at his attempts and tell that he is throwing for wins
Dec 24th 2012
65
      yeah Luck is just as much in the convo as any of the rest of them
Dec 24th 2012
67
people here are confusing achievements and being OROY
Dec 25th 2012
84
wilson is finishing strong, that helps, but then again he is in seattle
Dec 25th 2012
87
RE: people here are confusing achievements and being OROY
Dec 25th 2012
88
A playoff appearance by the actual #1 drafting team. 2-14.
Dec 25th 2012
86
1st #1 pick QB to lead his team to the playoffs...
Dec 25th 2012
89
if it were the NBA, his usage rate would be sky high lol
Dec 25th 2012
91
right...
Dec 25th 2012
92
this terrible team argument.....
Dec 25th 2012
93
any way you cut it, he deserves a ton of credit IMO
Dec 25th 2012
95
the 2011 team lost about six starters from 2010
Dec 25th 2012
99
honorable mention for best comedy in this post
Dec 25th 2012
96
      You want it one way but it's the other way.
Dec 25th 2012
97
           the team is good bc of RG3
Dec 25th 2012
98
                I see, so Morris is a non factor.. got it..
Dec 25th 2012
100
                     dumb and pointless.
Dec 25th 2012
101
Gotta admit, the pro-Luck arguments in here are awful
Dec 25th 2012
103
Let's suppose all three teams end up making the playoffs.
Dec 26th 2012
104
you should report this to your local sports talk station
Dec 26th 2012
105
Come On Man
Dec 26th 2012
111
You think I made this post to "complain to OKP"?
Dec 26th 2012
112
      I don't think you should bring up Reggie Wayne if you want
Dec 26th 2012
116
no one is really arguing for Luck winning the award though
Dec 26th 2012
108
Luck is going to win it and its unfortunate.
Dec 26th 2012
107
eh, there have been greater travesties
Dec 26th 2012
117
i think RGIII is the ROY, but give Morris some credit folks
Dec 26th 2012
109
why should they give Morris some credit tho?
Dec 26th 2012
113
give RG3 some credit too for Morris.
Dec 26th 2012
119
RGIII is now a Pro Bowl QB...
Dec 26th 2012
120
Simple... Consensus #1 pick for 2 years running lives up to hype
Dec 26th 2012
121
if RG3 wins today, he's the ROY imo
Dec 30th 2012
124
RE: How can one justify giving Andrew Luck a ROY vote?
Dec 30th 2012
123
another STRONG ARGUMENT(smuts mad) for Russ v. RG3
Jan 02nd 2013
125
lol @ Peter King
Jan 02nd 2013
132
      come on now, King ain't shit
Jan 02nd 2013
133
           I care about RG3 and wins
Jan 02nd 2013
134
                I'm glad your eyes are on the prize
Jan 02nd 2013
135
Honestly, as much as I ride for RGIII
Jan 02nd 2013
127
I think the choice between Griffin & Wilson is difficult
Jan 02nd 2013
129
Alfred Morris sucks btw....
Jan 02nd 2013
128
You're going to have to hold on to this agenda for multiple years
Jan 02nd 2013
130
1st off, it's not an agenda..
Jan 07th 2013
140
      According to RG3malia, Morris was only good b/c of RG3
Jan 07th 2013
142
           I'm sayin... I don't understand how that's not a two way street
Jan 07th 2013
144
keep trying.
Jan 02nd 2013
131
Hey where was Alfred & Kirk last night?
Jan 07th 2013
139
      Alfred had a great game; Kirk was on the bench, healthy
Jan 07th 2013
141
      Morris avg 5ypc & made key contribution on BOTH those TD drives
Jan 07th 2013
143
           Never said that.
Jan 07th 2013
145
                my only real point was that you can't ignore the contribution
Jan 07th 2013
147
Got my vote.
Jan 07th 2013
137
Won't get my ROY vote, will get my 'Franchise QB From Here Out' vote tho
Jan 07th 2013
138
I can get with this...Russell 3X #2
Jan 07th 2013
146

Lobby Okay Sports topic #2097576 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com