Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby Okay Sports topic #2579120

Subject: "Gotta disagree with you there. Eli has always been much more of " Previous topic | Next topic
Mignight Maruder
Member since Nov 30th 2003
7728 posts
Mon Nov-28-16 08:47 AM

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
23. "Gotta disagree with you there. Eli has always been much more of "
In response to In response to 21


  

          

a focal point on his team. He's had a some nice weapons to work with, but has never had a consistently dominant OL, RB, and WRs like Aikman had. He had some great RBs/WRs for a moment like Tiki and WRs like Plaxico, Victor Cruz, and now ODB, but not the same level of consistent support.

Manning put his teams on his back (with the help of good defense) whereas Troy just kept things moving in a positive direction and limited his mistakes.

This isn't to say one is better than the other. It's just highlighting that their roles were vastly different.

Also, gotta disagree about the Cowboys should have won more. They won 3 SBs which is a lot. I'd argue that's more impressive than Bron with the Heat (comparatively speaking). Also, they had to run the gauntlet of the NFC that featured some great Green Bay and San Francisco teams.

  

Printer-friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote


*looking at Troy Aikman's stats* [View all] , Basaglia, Sun Nov-27-16 10:36 PM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
stick to not-knowing-shit-about Basketball...
Nov 27th 2016
1
What's your argument for why he belongs in the HOF?
Nov 27th 2016
2
I don't have to concede shit...
Nov 27th 2016
5
      Okay. I obviously do not agree. Aikman on that Namath.
Nov 27th 2016
6
           I wouldn't suspect that you would know enough about
Nov 27th 2016
8
                We disagree on what a lot of football folks think of aikman's legacy
Nov 27th 2016
10
                     legacy is measured by more than stats...
Nov 27th 2016
11
                          Mike Irvin is considered to have been the leader by everyone
Nov 28th 2016
13
Lolol
Nov 28th 2016
20
Larry Allen's a HOFer
Nov 28th 2016
22
      he wishes
Nov 28th 2016
27
      They won 2 super bowls before they got Larry Allen....
Nov 28th 2016
29
NOPE! THREE RINGS!! THE OLD LEGEND!!!
Nov 27th 2016
3
lol...man, Bomani FRIES Aikman like twice a year...
Nov 27th 2016
4
playing your entire career with the all time leading rusher
Nov 27th 2016
7
      not as easy as you think....
Nov 27th 2016
9
           and he choked...and lost big game...lol..Troy didn't do that n/m
Nov 28th 2016
12
                figured that'd be all you could reply with....have a great night
Nov 28th 2016
14
                     the guy that didn't choke is better than the guy that did..n/m
Nov 28th 2016
15
they're definitely not that impressive.
Nov 28th 2016
16
lmao...nah, dogg, i'm comparing his numbers to HIS era.
Nov 28th 2016
17
      yeah, they're not great.
Nov 28th 2016
18
           i grew up thinking bradshaw was God.
Nov 28th 2016
19
Aikman was the Eli Manning of his time.
Nov 28th 2016
21
He was the beneficiary of some incredibly talented teams, BUT
Nov 28th 2016
24
LOOKING AT TROY AIKMANS FANGAS...............
Nov 28th 2016
25
He was basically a glorified DLG QB but he stepped up big time in that.....
Nov 28th 2016
26
still champion bashing, huh?
Nov 28th 2016
28
i go back and forth with aikman.
Nov 28th 2016
30
yeah he didn't have flashy numbers but was very clutch and usually...
Nov 28th 2016
31

Lobby Okay Sports topic #2579120 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com