Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby Pass The Popcorn topic #745284

Subject: "I feel like saying Rogue One is better than Empire is pretty controversi..." Previous topic | Next topic
soulfunk
Charter member
10988 posts
Thu Jul-21-22 09:47 AM

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
10. "I feel like saying Rogue One is better than Empire is pretty controversi..."
In response to In response to 7


  

          

Rogue One has no John Williams, no Jedi, no Skywalkers (besides Vader), and no involvement from George Lucas. If you ask 10 SW fans what the best SW movie is, likely that 9 of them say Empire Strikes Back. Depending on their age, 1 or 2 might say Revenge of the Sith also.

  

Printer-friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote


I’m sorry, but Rogue One is the best movie in Star Wars canon. [View all] , soulfunk, Wed Jul-20-22 09:15 PM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
it's held up the best of anything post original trilogy
Jul 20th 2022
1
no apology needed, its true....
Jul 20th 2022
2
The apology is because it feels like blasphemy to put it above ESB.
Jul 20th 2022
4
can't quite pinpoint why, but Luke in Mando 10x >>> Leia in RO
Jul 21st 2022
8
      The technology is getting better and better. Like you mentioned,
Jul 21st 2022
11
      someone improved it on YouTube
Jul 22nd 2022
25
Just finished all the Star Wars movies with my daughter...you're right.
Jul 20th 2022
3
For me, it's the 2nd best by Disney
Jul 21st 2022
5
I love Last Jedi. But it's impossible for me to evaluate separately from
Jul 21st 2022
9
yooo wtf?
Jul 21st 2022
15
Exactly. The deleted scene version is better for BOTH Finn and Phasma.
Jul 21st 2022
16
      Last Jedi is the most frustrating.
Jul 22nd 2022
26
RE: I love Last Jedi. But it's impossible for me to evaluate separately ...
Jul 22nd 2022
23
Last Jedi is the rare movie ruined by it's sequel.
Jul 22nd 2022
21
      I agree
Jul 22nd 2022
22
It will always be Empire, but it’s easily the best Disney SW product
Jul 21st 2022
6
you said this as if it's a controversial opinion
Jul 21st 2022
7
      Only a sith speaks in absolutes. You declared it as if it’s a fact.
Jul 21st 2022
12
      All this is what I meant when I said ESB is the best "SW movie" but
Jul 21st 2022
14
      most Star Wars is mediocre or just straight dogshit
Jul 21st 2022
13
For the record all things Disney suck
Jul 21st 2022
17
Do you watch them all together or spaced out?
Jul 22nd 2022
18
We watch in chronological order...
Jul 22nd 2022
19
Rogue One End Scene into A New Hope Opening Scene (link)
Jul 22nd 2022
20
it makes the sequels worse in comparison because it shows
Jul 22nd 2022
24
My kids are 14 and 8.
Jul 23rd 2022
27
I'm a RedLetterMedia guy and I totally get why they're down on this, BUT
Jul 23rd 2022
28
Returns to IMAX theaters this weekend (swipe)
Aug 26th 2022
29
No. But it can be YOUR FAVORITE
Aug 26th 2022
30
Not sure what issue there is here...
Aug 26th 2022
31
He's not Superman.
Aug 26th 2022
32
ehhhh...it's a really good flick, and the best Disney star wars by miles
Aug 26th 2022
33
Saw an IMAX screening tonight, it really gets better every rewatch
Aug 27th 2022
34
The whole saga is pretty mediocre.
Aug 27th 2022
35
.
Aug 30th 2022
All of this is why to me Rogue One > Empire.
Aug 30th 2022
38
Echuta.
Aug 30th 2022
39
The final hour is the best Star Wars movie ever
Aug 29th 2022
36
To me the first half is absolutely worth it. On first watch in the
Aug 30th 2022
37

Lobby Pass The Popcorn topic #745284 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com