Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby Pass The Popcorn topic #736289

Subject: "What are your thoughts about Marty's comments about Marvel movies?" Previous topic | Next topic
obsidianchrysalis
Member since Jan 29th 2003
8750 posts
Fri Oct-11-19 06:17 PM

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
"What are your thoughts about Marty's comments about Marvel movies?"


  

          

Without reading the entire interview or watching the comment in 'real-time' and gathering context, on face value his comments are right but also reflect that he hasn't watched at least the better of the comic book movies.

Endgame does have more in common with Star Wars: Galaxy's Edge than Taxi Driver. But this doesn't mean that there aren't genuinely emotionally touching moments in Endgame and many high-level comic book movies.

The Marvel movies and the Nolan movies didn't have the best special effects and stunts - although they were good. But the performances made the circumstances of men, women, and celestial beings running around clobbering each other in tights emotionally believable. The movies don't work otherwise. Just look at the DC movies. The special effects and technical aspects of the movies are roughly similar but the basic storytelling mechanics aren't there and as a result they haven't been as well received.

Scorsese's never done an outright tentpole blockbuster. That's probably because he doesn't want to and that he hasn't been offered one. And so he may likely have the opinion that summer movies just aren't something he's interested to do.

The feedback from Sam Jax, Downey Jr., and James Gunn was pretty measured and reasoned which was good to see. I presume they were showing deference for Scorsese's age and accomplishments. I can't think that even Tarantino would get that level of respect he said the same.

https://pagesix.com/2019/10/04/martin-scorsese-says-marvel-movies-arent-cinema-theyre-theme-parks/

Martin Scorsese says Marvel movies ‘aren’t cinema,’ they’re ‘theme parks’

By Alex HeiglOctober 4, 2019 | 9:26pm

Marty’s not feeling very Marvel-ous.

In a new interview with Empire, Martin Scorsese addressed the zeitgeist-dominating influence of the Marvel Cinematic Universe. To put it mildly, he finds them … wanting.

“I don’t see them. I tried, you know? But that’s not cinema,” Scorsese told the magazine. “Honestly, the closest I can think of them, as well made as they are, with actors doing the best they can under the circumstances, is theme parks. It isn’t the cinema of human beings trying to convey emotional, psychological experiences to another human being.”

To be fair, Scorsese’s legacy of capital-c Cinema does seem fairly incompatible with the streamlined, quip-heavy, crowd-pleasing, popcorn fare that comprises the MCU. But “Joker” director Todd Phillips has namechecked grimy Scorsese faves like “Taxi Driver” and “King of Comedy” in his press tour — and even went so far as to bring in “King of Comedy” star Robert De Niro for a part in “Joker.” Maybe Scorsese’s just is a DC fan?
Marty’s latest is, of course, “The Irishman,” out on Netflix Nov. 27.

  

Printer-friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote


What are your thoughts about Marty's comments about Marvel movies? [View all] , obsidianchrysalis, Fri Oct-11-19 06:17 PM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
i agree 100%.
Oct 12th 2019
1
He's old school. No one should care.
Oct 12th 2019
2
He's old a old fucking idiot
Oct 13th 2019
3
its hilarious how upset people got over it
Oct 13th 2019
4
i don't see anything wrong with the comment
Oct 13th 2019
5
Why was this clickbait bullshit even posted here?
Oct 13th 2019
6
To be fair, this was actually one of the more even handed descriptions
Oct 13th 2019
7
obviously it's a snobbish statement and a tired debate
Oct 14th 2019
8
RE: obviously it's a snobbish statement and a tired debate
Oct 14th 2019
10
      exactly
Oct 14th 2019
11
      "cbm are pushing out indie & mainstream films from theaters"....?
Oct 14th 2019
12
           RE: "cbm are pushing out indie & mainstream films from theaters"....?
Oct 14th 2019
13
seems like an old man yells at clouds moment, to me
Oct 14th 2019
9
I've never wondered what scorsese thinks of the MCU. never will.
Oct 15th 2019
14
Haters gonna hate.
Oct 16th 2019
15
and Ain'ters Gonna Ain't
Oct 16th 2019
16
All Cinema Doesn't Have To Be The Same.
Oct 18th 2019
17
he says he never saw them. debate over.
Oct 19th 2019
18
He's 100% right, but y'all middle aged nerds are too "emotionally attach...
Oct 20th 2019
19
he's not right, and you're missing the point
Oct 21st 2019
24
Coppola takes it even further
Oct 20th 2019
20
there's something strange or just sad about this
Oct 20th 2019
21
Coppola's comments seem perplexing given the context...
Oct 20th 2019
22
      RE: Coppola's comments seem perplexing given the context...
Oct 20th 2019
23
           Agreed
Oct 23rd 2019
30
Apparently Coppola's comments were taken from a poor translation
Oct 30th 2019
35
      Oh...
Oct 31st 2019
36
      not surprising
Oct 31st 2019
37
That and the Disney remakes are killing movies
Oct 21st 2019
25
C'mon, fam. They aren't killing anything
Oct 22nd 2019
26
      I said the people have spoken. And they're are giving us the same
Oct 22nd 2019
27
      that's a you problem
Oct 23rd 2019
28
      Green Book made 85 mil domestically!
Oct 23rd 2019
29
           I hope you're wrong
Oct 24th 2019
34
It's funny to me the guy who made Jack
Oct 23rd 2019
31
While I agree it’s silly to say that without having seen one...
Oct 23rd 2019
32
same
Oct 24th 2019
33
old and mad
Oct 31st 2019
38
And another thing...
Oct 31st 2019
39
he doesn't care how many people love the movies
Nov 04th 2019
40
He doubled down! *link*
Nov 05th 2019
41
blah blah blah
Nov 05th 2019
42
He sounds jealous that he had to fight for funding & Marvel prints money...
Nov 05th 2019
43
I get it, and think it's silly anybody got worked up over it
Nov 05th 2019
44
I don't think he was dismissing the Marvel phenomenon
Nov 05th 2019
45
Marvel movies aren't the reason major studios passed...
Nov 05th 2019
46

Lobby Pass The Popcorn topic #736289 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com