Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby Pass The Popcorn topic #706280

Subject: "I mean, I agree to a large extent. The most ''damning'' thing to me..." Previous topic | Next topic
The Analyst
Member since Sep 22nd 2007
4621 posts
Mon Jan-04-16 03:12 PM

Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
14. "I mean, I agree to a large extent. The most ''damning'' thing to me..."
In response to In response to 12


  

          

is that she'd told her bosses she was uncomfortable going to the Avery property because of how he acted on past occasions (like waiting for her outside in only a towel), and that he was *67-ing his (multiple) calls to her on the day she disappeared.

None of that is evidence of his guilt, of course, but it suggests he was pretty fixated on her. It's easier to believe he could abduct, rape and murder her if he was borderline obsessed and quasi-stalking her over the phone over the course of a long length of time than if she just randomly showed up on his doorstep one day.

At the end of the day, there was clear and obvious police misconduct, which in and of itself should have been enough to ensure he wasn't convicted. The evidence was clearly tainted. I absolutely believe they planted the key and blood. In getting a more complete painting of the facts, however, I'm more inclined to believe the police planted evidence to ensure a conviction, rather than outright framing him. (Which is very close to being just as bad...but not quite.)

And, like I said above, even if Avery actually did it, it doesn't undermine any of the larger points the documentary is making, all of which are extremely important. I'm just not surprised this "new" evidence is hurting their credibility in the eyes of many people who now think they were twisting the facts to be more pro-Avery.

----

  

Printer-friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote


Netflix Has Done It Again: Making A Murderer [View all] , Reeq, Wed Dec-23-15 09:39 PM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
RE: Netflix Has Done It Again: Making A Murderer
Dec 23rd 2015
1
Incredible. Disheartening.
Jan 02nd 2016
2
It's incredibly well done. Better than Serial. But....
Jan 02nd 2016
3
At least here there's evidence pointing to a conspiracy.
Jan 02nd 2016
4
      That we only see the defense's case makes this so much more compelling
Jan 02nd 2016
5
      Evidence pointing to tampering for sure.
Jan 02nd 2016
6
           I didn't forget any of that.
Jan 02nd 2016
7
3 hours in I can't believe there are 7 more eps to watch
Jan 04th 2016
8
Quietly, one of the most problematic pieces of evidence to me was:
Jan 04th 2016
9
this ^^^
Jan 04th 2016
10
I keep coming back to this:
Jan 04th 2016
13
THIS and *spoilers?*
Jan 05th 2016
24
Damning evidence against Avery that was omitted from the doc (SWIPE):
Jan 04th 2016
11
Unfortunately, literally all of that evidence can be discredited.
Jan 04th 2016
12
     
      But who provided this testimony?
Jan 04th 2016
15
      plus if there's one thing that the Serial season 1 taught us
Jan 04th 2016
16
           This isn't even really true, though.
Jan 04th 2016
17
                more than I thought I he was bad, I thought he was dumb
Jan 04th 2016
19
                eh, I felt like these things were sorta written off n/m
Jan 05th 2016
22
      so the thing about this is...
Jan 04th 2016
18
      RE: so the thing about this is...
Jan 04th 2016
20
           I still don't love this line of reasoning...
Jan 04th 2016
21
      Strang refuted the "she was afraid to go back over" thing
Jan 08th 2016
29
      Does the law work this way, though?
Jan 08th 2016
30
Filmmakers: juror said he convicted out of "fear for his safety."
Jan 05th 2016
23
This thing is deeply affecting
Jan 05th 2016
25
Dean Strang is DAT DUDE
Jan 06th 2016
26
Im 5 eps in and dont know if I can continue...only because..
Jan 07th 2016
27
I pretty much finished every episode like...
Jan 08th 2016
28
Considering taking the plunge.
Jan 08th 2016
31
If you watch one episode, u will feel furious
Jan 08th 2016
32
      u keep watching hoping the situation gets better...its gotta right....
Jan 08th 2016
33
Finished it last week
Jan 08th 2016
34
this shit made me so sad.
Jan 11th 2016
35
I tried looking at this from all angles
Jan 11th 2016
36
i wonder if Steven's defense would be more persuasive today
Jan 11th 2016
37
      He just got some new counsel
Jan 11th 2016
38
           it won't matter if he's not granted a new trial.
Jan 11th 2016
39
This part was HUGE imo
Jan 11th 2016
40

Lobby Pass The Popcorn topic #706280 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com