>Now...let's talk about Dobby. > >I can't believe they decided to end the series with them >CRYING OVER A FUCKING PUPPET!!! Augh. I guess since Dobby has >been missing pretty much since the 2nd film, and also since >the film never went into how DEEP Hermione was with the House >Elf Liberation movement or whatever they called it....it >didn't resonate with me. Plus...it was like they were trying >too hard to give Dobby a Gollum-esque appeal...when Gollum was >a character unto himself with idiosyncracies and shit. Dobby >is just a House Elf that was MUCH funnier early in the series. >That being said...Dobby did get a few chuckles.
I hated Dobby in the books, and felt it was a heavyhanded metaphor the entire time he was used. Then they cut nearly his entire story out of the films... but still use him as this big cry-inducing finale. Cmon. One of the rare missteps Yates has made.
To his credit, my entire audience was very sad over Dobby and I heard audible sniffles all around. So maybe I'm just anti-Dobby.