Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby Pass The Popcorn topic #542358

Subject: "Gigantic cosign of this." Previous topic | Next topic
Frank Longo
Member since Nov 18th 2003
86681 posts
Fri Nov-19-10 10:54 AM

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
10. "Gigantic cosign of this."
In response to In response to 7


  

          


>Now...let's talk about Dobby.
>
>I can't believe they decided to end the series with them
>CRYING OVER A FUCKING PUPPET!!! Augh. I guess since Dobby has
>been missing pretty much since the 2nd film, and also since
>the film never went into how DEEP Hermione was with the House
>Elf Liberation movement or whatever they called it....it
>didn't resonate with me. Plus...it was like they were trying
>too hard to give Dobby a Gollum-esque appeal...when Gollum was
>a character unto himself with idiosyncracies and shit. Dobby
>is just a House Elf that was MUCH funnier early in the series.
>That being said...Dobby did get a few chuckles.

I hated Dobby in the books, and felt it was a heavyhanded metaphor the entire time he was used. Then they cut nearly his entire story out of the films... but still use him as this big cry-inducing finale. Cmon. One of the rare missteps Yates has made.

To his credit, my entire audience was very sad over Dobby and I heard audible sniffles all around. So maybe I'm just anti-Dobby.

My movies: http://russellhainline.com
My movie reviews: https://letterboxd.com/RussellHFilm/
My beer TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@thebeertravelguide

  

Printer-friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote


Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 1 (Yates, 2010) [View all] , bwood, Mon Nov-15-10 05:56 PM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
2:26
Nov 15th 2010
1
good
Nov 15th 2010
2
i'm so excited for this damn movie
Nov 15th 2010
3
Quint and I have the same exact feelings on this movie
Nov 16th 2010
4
Midnight show check in...
Nov 18th 2010
5
i wish.
Nov 18th 2010
6
Okay....my review *POSSIBLE SPOILERS*
Nov 19th 2010
7
Mannn
Nov 19th 2010
13
      while I agree with him being an important part of the Mythology
Nov 19th 2010
16
RE: Okay....my review *POSSIBLE SPOILERS*
Nov 19th 2010
18
i enjoyed it
Nov 19th 2010
8
is this shit actually gonna be good?
Nov 19th 2010
9
A few thoughts after the midnight show:
Nov 19th 2010
11
i thought it ended in a good place
Nov 19th 2010
12
But Dobby's barely been in the films.
Nov 19th 2010
14
      even still
Nov 19th 2010
15
When they started the film on him
Nov 19th 2010
17
this is disappointing
Nov 19th 2010
19
Dobby and Snape *spoilers* maybe
Nov 20th 2010
21
they got stuck when it came to Dobby
Nov 21st 2010
25
      I just wondered, was there no better place to split it?
Nov 21st 2010
26
           when I finished the book, I thought
Nov 21st 2010
28
                Yeah, I liked neither Dobby nor Hedwig, lol.
Nov 21st 2010
29
RE: Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 1 (Yates, 2010)
Nov 20th 2010
20
I haven't seen 1 Harry Potter movie...
Nov 21st 2010
22
i have to say that this movie was great
Nov 21st 2010
23
mostly agree.
Nov 21st 2010
24
You didn't like the scene in the tent?
Nov 21st 2010
27
RE: You didn't like the scene in the tent?
Nov 22nd 2010
32
CO-SIGN
Nov 22nd 2010
33
      exactly. i would have thought that they would have at least
Nov 22nd 2010
34
           i just assumed it was going to come up in p. 2.
Nov 23rd 2010
35
                me too, but i would have appreciated if the three of them
Nov 29th 2010
47
Thought it was great!
Nov 21st 2010
30
Damn that shit was depressing......
Nov 21st 2010
31
Not as good as HBP, which really isn't fair since it's not yet complete
Nov 24th 2010
36
perfect description 'it ended on a commercial break'
Nov 24th 2010
37
Zoo while I get where your coming from...
Nov 25th 2010
40
i liked how it showed the differences in the trio's upbringing
Nov 24th 2010
38
oh. and emma watson is a babe too.
Nov 25th 2010
39
these people are stupid
Nov 26th 2010
41
yes, it was an odd place to end it
Nov 26th 2010
43
      it was more an "OH SHIT!!" moment...
Nov 26th 2010
44
infinitely better than HBP
Nov 26th 2010
42
Fam, these shits is like 6 hours long my nigga. Come on.
Nov 28th 2010
45
well done
Nov 28th 2010
46
RE: Harry Potter is an acquired taste
Feb 05th 2011
48

Lobby Pass The Popcorn topic #542358 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com