Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby Pass The Popcorn topic #499545

Subject: "On the idea of Fire in Space:" Previous topic | Next topic
Whiteout
Member since Aug 30th 2005
3577 posts
Tue Jan-26-10 02:35 PM

Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
"On the idea of Fire in Space:"
Tue Jan-26-10 02:36 PM by Whiteout

  

          

Working under the premise of the human understanding of fire we know, as common knowledge, that fire will not exist in an environment lacking oxygen, like Outer Space for example (and in some people's heads).

So why...

in every piece of cinema I can think of featuring an explosion in Outer Space, is there fire of some kind?

It makes no sense, and as a viewer, I always expect it not to happen...

but then it does... and I get upset...

I can't help but wonder what the fuck gives.

Is this a conscious decision on the part of directors to emphasize the tragedy?

going on 40 years after Star Wars now...

You'd think someone would have caught on by now.

What say y'all?

. . .
psn: sirius_fruits

but that shit's stupid though.

  

Printer-friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote


On the idea of Fire in Space: [View all] , Whiteout, Tue Jan-26-10 02:35 PM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
I ain't no scientist
Jan 26th 2010
1
me neither
Jan 26th 2010
3
^
Jan 26th 2010
7
      should it explode or implode?
Jan 26th 2010
9
           why would imploding make more sense?
Jan 26th 2010
20
                basically air and fire in a bubble
Jan 27th 2010
22
                     ...
Jan 27th 2010
24
                          I'm not even approaching it scientifically past fire/oxygen thing
Jan 27th 2010
34
                               RE: I'm not even approaching it scientifically past fire/oxygen thing
Jan 27th 2010
39
                                    you're just not high enough
Jan 27th 2010
41
                                         lol, I guess not
Jan 28th 2010
43
I'm more annoyed by the sound effects.
Jan 26th 2010
2
as long as the creatures have three titties
Jan 26th 2010
4
that bothers the shit outta me too!
Jan 26th 2010
10
Which recent space movie did cool things with silent destruction of ship...
Jan 26th 2010
18
      yep
Jan 27th 2010
32
On: The idea of every human being as white in 'Lord of the Rings'
Jan 26th 2010
5
you mean every "good" human being in LOTR is white
Jan 26th 2010
6
what colour was saruman the white?
Jan 26th 2010
15
      Did I say every white human being in LOTR was good?
Jan 27th 2010
29
      saruman's not a human being.
Jan 29th 2010
49
just had to postjack on some racebait unrelated...
Jan 26th 2010
8
I think if fits
Jan 26th 2010
12
      you right
Jan 26th 2010
16
don't even get me started on that bullshit.
Jan 26th 2010
11
This has bugged me since I was about 7
Jan 26th 2010
13
it has to be done tho.
Jan 28th 2010
47
the books were written as English mythology.
Jan 26th 2010
14
I'm not being a boho activist about it.
Jan 27th 2010
36
      yeah, fair enough.
Jan 27th 2010
38
apparently minorities don't exist in the future or far off worlds
Jan 27th 2010
26
Oxygen from the destroyed ship?
Jan 26th 2010
17
Its wrong but its one of those things that are standard
Jan 26th 2010
19
But the shit looks cool.
Jan 27th 2010
21
on the idea of nitpicking:
Jan 27th 2010
23
basically
Jan 27th 2010
25
both you do it, too
Jan 27th 2010
35
People with a firm understanding of what's so
Jan 27th 2010
30
      but nobody here has been to space
Jan 28th 2010
44
           You dont' have to go to the North Pole to know there's no penguins there
Jan 28th 2010
45
                but i dont have to care either. its cold. theres ice.
Jan 29th 2010
50
Sunshine got it right
Jan 27th 2010
27
"it's gonna be cold"*wraps self in insulation, fires self into space*
Jan 27th 2010
40
      Now why'd you gotta go & do that? Tryin to make a point (c)Fenster
Jan 27th 2010
42
Honestly, though, here's the real answer:
Jan 27th 2010
28
A classic article.
Jan 27th 2010
31
How was there fire on Pandora?
Jan 27th 2010
33
We don't know there wasn't oxygen
Jan 27th 2010
37
HOW CAN SEAN CONNERY BE A RUSSIAN NAVY CAPTAIN
Jan 28th 2010
46
Sean Connery can play one part only:
Jan 28th 2010
48
he was also an Egyptian Spaniard that sounded like groundskeeper Willie
Jan 29th 2010
51

Lobby Pass The Popcorn topic #499545 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com