Frank Longo Member since Nov 18th 2003 86673 posts
Fri Jan-11-08 02:48 PM
15. "The message, sure. But the voice and style are totally different." In response to In response to 14 Fri Jan-11-08 02:49 PM by Frank Longo
It's not really the themes that are different between these filmmakers as their voices and directing styles.
If you see 5 scenes, each by a different writer/director (Anderson, Smith, Baumbach, Allen, and Ephron, for example), you'd be able to tell what scene belonged to who, even if the subject matter and actors were exactly the same. It's the delivery of the message that differs, not the message itself.
Plus, like I said, I thought the nature of the dad's terminal illness and the way it was handled made this more than your typical "Life sucks, but it's better than death" film.