Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby Pass The Popcorn topic #288238

Subject: "that's a very different thing from saying "her nickname is Annie."" This topic is locked.
Previous topic | Next topic
janey
Charter member
123124 posts
Tue Jun-12-07 06:10 PM

Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
48. "that's a very different thing from saying "her nickname is Annie.""
In response to In response to 34


  

          

I never disputed the "based on," but I do dispute the idea that this is some kind of documentary or other true-to-life portrayal. I think it would be an insult to her to say that she had won an academy award for just acting like her own little nutty self. That's not to say that she's not quirky. She is. But it's still a narrative feature, and even movies that are biopics smooth out details and contradictions in order to tell a single, coherent story with a beginning, a middle and an end.

I understand from a friend who recently watched one of her more recent movies (I don't recall which one, I'm not actually a big fan of the movies she's done lately) that she has a line in that film about collecting a particular kind of pottery. Which she does in real life. And she has probably the second largest collection of this pottery in the country. So does that mean that the rest of the film is true to life?

  

Printer-friendly copy


Most Accurate Depiction of a Relationship In A Movie Is... [View all] , Melanism, Tue Jun-05-07 01:00 PM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
Hmm...Eternal Sunshine?
Jun 05th 2007
1
the
Jun 05th 2007
5
Bad Santa
Jun 05th 2007
2
Disappearing Acts
Jun 05th 2007
3
book yes, movie HELL NO!!!
Jun 05th 2007
7
      why so?
Jun 06th 2007
19
           the relationship in the book was very long, and slow moving
Jun 11th 2007
41
                ur avi made me smile
Jun 11th 2007
43
My Best Friend's Wedding
Jun 05th 2007
4
I think I love my wife.
Jun 05th 2007
6
Love Jones
Jun 05th 2007
8
Scenes From A Marriage (Bergman) and
Jun 05th 2007
9
RE: Scenes From A Marriage (Bergman) and
Jun 05th 2007
10
High Fidelity
Jun 05th 2007
11
co-sign
Jun 06th 2007
20
Brokeback Mountain
Jun 05th 2007
12
Annie Hall was pretty good, wasn't it?
Jun 05th 2007
13
^^^Great relationship that would never actually happen^^^ n/m
Jun 05th 2007
15
Uhhhh...
Jun 06th 2007
29
      *based on*
Jun 06th 2007
31
           Woody called her Annie
Jun 06th 2007
34
               
i met this girl a while back
Jun 05th 2007
17
Something New
Jun 05th 2007
14
I was always fond of the relationship in Love & Sex
Jun 05th 2007
16
Love me If You dare
Jun 06th 2007
18
Mr. Jealousy
Jun 06th 2007
21
No votes for Baby Boy? nm
Jun 06th 2007
22
reply #10 nm
Jun 06th 2007
23
Closer
Jun 06th 2007
24
^^^^WINNER^^^^
Jun 11th 2007
39
RE: Most Accurate Depiction of a Relationship In A Movie Is...
Jun 06th 2007
25
Leaving Las Vegas
Jun 06th 2007
26
The Notebook
Jun 06th 2007
27
the neglect for their kids and grandkids was disgusting in that movie
Jun 06th 2007
30
^My alltime favorite date movie
Jun 06th 2007
28
eep
Jun 06th 2007
33
My Sassy Girl
Jun 06th 2007
32
eternal sunshine (and if hbo counts) brenda and nate in 6ftVVVV
Jun 06th 2007
35
When A Man Loves A Woman
Jun 07th 2007
36
Chasing Amy
Jun 07th 2007
37
Love and Sex ....with famke janssen and jon favreau
Jun 07th 2007
38
I thought I was the only one who saw that movie.
Jun 11th 2007
40
that makes three of us
Jun 11th 2007
44
RE: Love and Sex ....with famke janssen and jon favreau
Jun 12th 2007
49
She Hate Me
Jun 11th 2007
42
RE: Most Accurate Depiction of a Relationship In A Movie Is...
Jun 11th 2007
45
L'Atalante
Jun 11th 2007
46
Soul Food
Jun 12th 2007
47
prime. the relationship w/ uma and dude was realistic, the plot was not
Jun 12th 2007
50

Lobby Pass The Popcorn topic #288238 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com