Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby Pass The Popcorn topic #236091

Subject: "Two great finds" This topic is locked.
Previous topic | Next topic
janey
Charter member
123124 posts
Mon Dec-18-06 01:31 PM

Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
18. "Two great finds"
In response to In response to 0
Mon Dec-18-06 01:46 PM by janey

  

          

One new, one older:

Cross-X, by Joe Miller.

This is a GREAT story about inner city high school kids (Kansas City, MO) who go to a high school that has lost its accreditation and is classified as "academically deficient" but who nonetheless rank nationally in debate. How do they do it? Yeah, dedicated teacher. Yeah, personal attention. In some ways, it's a story that has been told frequently, but one of the things that makes this story stand out is that the writer, who is white, is writing as much about the process of realizing the assumptions that he has made about the kids, not even necessarily the most obviously racist ones like Inner City Black Kids Are Scary, but more like Debate Is A Meritocracy or Debate Is Color Blind or even the whole idea about how the white debate coach and the white journalist can help the kids overcome institutional and personal obstacles, and challenging the assumptions in the context of his relationship to the kids, to debate in general, to himself, to other adults in the debate world, etc. It is GREAT. The only real criticism I have is that he too frequently ends a chapter by saying, "Little did I know that just a few days later, my entire outlook on debate -- indeed, my entire outlook on life -- would change!" I mean, it's mostly true, but his entire outlook changes like five times in the book. And framing it as he does, it seems like he's going to switch opinions 180 degrees each time, when really it's more like uncovering layers.

Color Blind, by Ellis Cose

This is the first book of his that I've read, but it certainly won't be the last. He's just this really great, balanced, powerful writer who questions some assumptions about various identity politics, and even though he and I agree on most issues, he still entertains the arguments of the opposition in a way that allows the reader to see what part is and what part is not reasonable. And what logically follows and what does not, and what assumptions are made in the arguments. And in some cases to see that there is no clear answer, like the question of whether bi- or multi-racial people should have separate race classifications (such as for the US Census) and what that means in the context of, for example, the fact that in one poll the majority of people who checked "biracial" were white people who had a grandparent who was thought to be exotic (but who was not actually of a different classifiable race), or what it means in the context of the South African apartheid model of white, black and "colored," all of this juxtaposed with examples of people in inter-racial marriages, say one is Black and one is white, and the problems that arise for the kids when they are asked or expected to identify as a single race, that that means they must deny a significant part of themselves and one parent. Etc. I'm loving it. I keep putting it down and discussing the issues with the cats

  

Printer-friendly copy


Holiday/End of Year Book Wrap Up. [View all] , janey, Wed Dec-06-06 02:36 PM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
Finally done reading for School
Dec 06th 2006
1
Mark Helpirn?
Dec 06th 2006
2
      Yeah thats his name
Dec 06th 2006
3
RE: Holiday/End of Year Book Wrap Up.
Dec 07th 2006
4
that exact Gould recording
Dec 07th 2006
5
      RE: that exact Gould recording
Dec 07th 2006
7
           You know, I read the review of Pynchon's new one recently
Dec 07th 2006
8
                RE: You know, I read the review of Pynchon's new one recently
Dec 07th 2006
10
RE: Holiday/End of Year Book Wrap Up.
Dec 07th 2006
6
Lunar Park is crazy...
Dec 28th 2006
38
The Third Policeman - Flan O'Brien
Dec 07th 2006
9
Neil Gaiman's "Neverwhere" is up next
Dec 07th 2006
11
I tore through that book
Dec 18th 2006
20
Janey, we struck gold last year
Dec 08th 2006
12
lol, now they think you're psychic or something
Dec 08th 2006
14
      Re -- The Echo Maker
Dec 08th 2006
15
100 years...
Dec 08th 2006
13
I'm missing The Wire something fierce, so I need a Pelecanos fix.
Dec 11th 2006
16
okay, how much have I raved about The Zero?
Dec 12th 2006
17
I need a recommendation:
Dec 18th 2006
19
well, well, well
Dec 18th 2006
22
      These look promising...
Dec 18th 2006
24
           Also, look for the thread here
Dec 18th 2006
25
Update:
Dec 18th 2006
21
wouldn't it be wonderful if Helpirn were a great writer?
Dec 18th 2006
23
      agree
Dec 18th 2006
26
           and at least we know McCarthy can write
Dec 18th 2006
27
The Shipping News by Ann Proulx
Dec 18th 2006
28
so then I read The Omnivore's Dilemma, by Michael Pollan
Dec 26th 2006
29
so then I read an old Jess Walter novel
Dec 26th 2006
30
so then I read The Looming Tower, by Lawrence Wright
Dec 26th 2006
31
so now I'm reading three
Dec 26th 2006
32
started Lunar Park a few days ago
Dec 27th 2006
33
that's a weird one
Dec 27th 2006
34
nah its better to assume everything is true in that book
Dec 28th 2006
41
it was hard for me to put down also
Dec 28th 2006
39
The Road
Dec 27th 2006
35
The Road
Dec 27th 2006
36
Got The Last Samurai for Christmas!
Dec 28th 2006
37
just started Beasts of no Nation
Dec 28th 2006
40
Writing on the Wall by Simon Morley
Dec 28th 2006
42
so now I'm reading Man Gone Down by Michael Thomas
Dec 28th 2006
43

Lobby Pass The Popcorn topic #236091 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com