Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby Pass The Popcorn topic #134958

Subject: "never heard of him." This topic is locked.
Previous topic | Next topic
buckshot defunct
Member since May 02nd 2003
26345 posts
Sat Dec-31-05 09:17 PM

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
46. "never heard of him."
In response to In response to 45


  

          

Sorry... I was meaning to reply to this earlier. Forgot. Let's see here...

>>>"I'm thinking specifically here whether Harry Potter can be considered a kind of superhero, since he is set apart from "normal" human beings, even if he is just a regular ol wizard. I guess within the wizard world, he is a HERO but since everyone of that world is magically-inclined, he doesn't "completely" stand apart, even if his did survive Voldemort when noone else could. "<<<

See, I'm wondering if this should even be brought into consideration. Let's compare these points to Superman. I choose Superman because I'm pretty sure we can all agree that he is, without question, a super-hero.

Superman is faster than a speeding bullet, more powerful than a locomotive, can leap tall buildings in a single bound, etc etc... so in that sense he is most definitely set apart from the "normal" world.

Set in a "real world" context, Superman is fantastic.

But set in Superman's world, on the other hand...

He hangs out with the Justice League, he fights aliens, wizards, evil geniuses and giant gorillas on a regular basis, protecting a planet that's very existence seems to be threatened on a daily basis etc. etc. So you could possibly argue the point that in Superman's world, he's not really all that special.

I don't know if Harry Potter is a "superhero" or not. But I do think that the "super" aspect should be determined based on a real-world context, not the fictional one the stories are set in.

  

Printer-friendly copy


Your top 5 superhero movies [View all] , AnonymousCoward, Wed Dec-28-05 11:31 AM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
Para mi:
Dec 28th 2005
1
My list
Dec 28th 2005
2
heres my list:
Dec 28th 2005
3
RE: heres my list:
Jan 03rd 2006
59
My top 5
Dec 28th 2005
4
Mine:
Dec 28th 2005
5
RE: Your top 5 superhero movies
Dec 28th 2005
6
That Kiss movie where they have super powers
Dec 28th 2005
7
I have no illusions... 99% of superhero movies suck
Dec 28th 2005
8
top 7 superhero movies
Dec 28th 2005
9
RE: top 7 superhero movies
Dec 28th 2005
10
      RE: Top 5 superhero movies
Dec 28th 2005
11
      RE: Top 5 superhero movies
Dec 29th 2005
17
      RE: top 7 superhero movies
Dec 28th 2005
13
      well, comics have very little to do with it in my eyes
Dec 28th 2005
16
           I don't really see the Crow as a superhero, tho-
Dec 29th 2005
23
           *slips on slope*
Dec 29th 2005
25
                RE: *slips on slope*
Dec 29th 2005
28
                NEO and other oddities
Dec 30th 2005
41
                     NOONE has thoughts on Harry Potter?
Dec 31st 2005
45
                    
                     I need to get back to this.
Dec 31st 2005
48
           If we're going down the Neo/Crow path
Jan 09th 2006
60
      Sin City not a "typical" superhero movie
Dec 29th 2005
24
Playing along
Dec 28th 2005
12
RE: Your top 5 superhero movies
Dec 28th 2005
14
RE: Your top 5 superhero movies
Dec 28th 2005
15
RE: Your top 5 superhero movies
Dec 29th 2005
21
      RE: Your top 5 superhero movies
Jan 01st 2006
51
           RE: Your top 5 superhero movies
Jan 01st 2006
53
                RE: Your top 5 superhero movies
Jan 03rd 2006
57
RE: Your top 5 superhero movies
Dec 29th 2005
18
RE: Your top 5 superhero movies
Dec 29th 2005
19
here's my list
Dec 29th 2005
20
      RE: here's my list *edit*
Dec 29th 2005
26
      RE: here's my list *edit*
Dec 29th 2005
27
      RE: here's my list
Dec 29th 2005
29
           RE: here's my list
Dec 29th 2005
30
                RE: Superman
Dec 29th 2005
31
Tough one
Dec 29th 2005
22
What bout BLANKMAN!!!
Dec 30th 2005
32
I'm ride or die for Superman III
Dec 30th 2005
33
This made me laugh:
Dec 30th 2005
36
origin in Burton's Batman was simpler & more psychological
Dec 30th 2005
34
      RE: origin in Burton's Batman was simpler & more psychological
Dec 30th 2005
35
           Good points
Dec 30th 2005
37
                "batman" & "batman begins"
Dec 30th 2005
38
                     more good points
Dec 30th 2005
43
                          RE: more good points
Dec 31st 2005
47
                          RE: more good points
Jan 03rd 2006
58
Orgazmo...post over
Dec 30th 2005
39
OH YEAH
Dec 30th 2005
40
      I am Sancho.
Dec 30th 2005
44
I'm not counting The Incredibles or Unbreakable
Dec 30th 2005
42
why the hell not?
Jan 01st 2006
54
      How the hell you gonna tell me my list is invalid?
Jan 10th 2006
63
RE: Your top 5 superhero movies
Jan 01st 2006
49
RE: Your top 5 superhero movies
Jan 01st 2006
50
RE: Your top 5 superhero movies
Jan 01st 2006
52
X2, Incredibles, Spiderman 2, Batman Begins, Superman 2
Jan 01st 2006
55
RE: Your top 5 superhero movies
Jan 02nd 2006
56
The indisputable 5:
Jan 09th 2006
61
RE: Your top 5 superhero movies
Jan 10th 2006
62
super man is my favorite hero but 1 and 2 are just not good
Jan 10th 2006
64
RE: Your top 5 superhero movies
Jan 10th 2006
65

Lobby Pass The Popcorn topic #134958 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com