Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby Pass The Popcorn topic #738276

Subject: "Love Garland and most involved but this was a big miss." Previous topic | Next topic
khn
Member since Jan 20th 2015
700 posts
Mon Apr-20-20 02:56 PM

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
11. "Love Garland and most involved but this was a big miss."
In response to In response to 0


          

In no way did this show sell me on the "tramlines" well enough to make for a satisfying payoff. Ultimately, perhaps, it's working too hard against its medium - stories are fundamentally *about* characters making choices. So all of the hand-wringing about agency (or lack thereof) didn't come off as credible. Just banal. Regardless of how pretty the machine looks.

Apart from that, Lilly was a putrid lead character. I don't know enough about Sonoya Mizuno's work to assess her as an actress but, oof, nothing worked. Assign that blame to any combination of the acting, writing and/or direction. The story dragged, often badly, when she was involved, and I really struggled to find anything compelling or special about her character in any way. Which became increasingly suspect as the story took more and more time to have its other, better, characters deliberately point out how special she was. Please.

  

Printer-friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote


Devs (ALEX MF'ING GARLAND, FX/Hulu) [View all] , benny, Tue Mar-24-20 03:15 PM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
Barrow slaughtered the Annihilation soundtrack.
Mar 24th 2020
1
Found this pretty weak
Mar 28th 2020
2
we just found this this week...
Mar 29th 2020
3
I love it, episode 5 was the best one yet
Mar 29th 2020
4
Ep 6 was sneakilly tense...
Apr 03rd 2020
5
WHO-LY #$#!!! Ep7....
Apr 10th 2020
6
It really was
Apr 12th 2020
7
The soundtrack of Devs is so unsettling.
Apr 18th 2020
8
I love the Jan Garbarek-y sax they use for certain drone shots
Apr 19th 2020
9
This whole show was audio/visual. I loved it but it has several flaws
Apr 20th 2020
10
I haven't watched Devs yet but this is how I felt about Ex Machina
Apr 20th 2020
12
I hear this
Apr 20th 2020
13
The Binge Mode podcast was a good bit of levity for me.
Apr 20th 2020
14
Couldn't disagree with this more
Apr 21st 2020
15
fantastic. Garland's shit really gets better with time
Aug 19th 2022
16
I didn't go back over what I/others may have said
Aug 19th 2022
17
      re:
Aug 21st 2022
18
      Yeah, my read on her was always that she was following direction.
Aug 28th 2022
19
      finally watched Sunshine this weekend
Sep 06th 2022
20
           2007 had to be a confounding year to sell movies
Sep 08th 2022
21

Lobby Pass The Popcorn topic #738276 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com