Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby Pass The Popcorn topic #621657

Subject: "OKPs: List your own Sight & Sound-esque Top 10 list here." Previous topic | Next topic
Frank Longo
Member since Nov 18th 2003
86830 posts
Sun Aug-05-12 10:41 PM

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
"OKPs: List your own Sight & Sound-esque Top 10 list here."
Sun Aug-05-12 10:42 PM by Frank Longo

  

          

Here's what we want:

- List your Top 10 best movies ever. No order. Put the title and the director.

- You can have multiple per director if you so desire. No restrictions.

- Put the ten BEST films in your opinion. This isn't just your favorite films of all time-- although many times your favorites and the films you think are the best overlap. But for example, I won't put "Dirty Work (Saget)" on my list, even though I love it dearly, because while it's enjoyable for a number of personal reasons, I don't believe it's a "great." (Note: that doesn't mean comedies or mainstream films aren't great. What you believe is great is up to you. Just try not to put jokey shit.)

- If we get enough lists, we can compile them to determine our boards' total list.

- Post your lists as a reply to the respective reply below, so we can keep them somewhat organized.

Questions for answering (and I'll put a second place to reply for commentary/debate):
1. Should we let ANYONE post their list? Or should we instead do what S&S does and select a smaller number of posters who we feel represents the best of PTP? Or is that too artsy?
2. Because we will have waaaaaay fewer "ballots," is trying to tally them even worth the effort? Should this just be an area for lists and debating people's lists, rather than trying to make a big hullabaloo when we simply lack the manpower (or personpower, if you will).

My movies: http://russellhainline.com
My movie reviews: https://letterboxd.com/RussellHFilm/
My beer TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@thebeertravelguide

  

Printer-friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote


OKPs: List your own Sight & Sound-esque Top 10 list here. [View all] , Frank Longo, Sun Aug-05-12 10:41 PM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
LISTS:
Aug 05th 2012
1
This is hard
Aug 06th 2012
3
This is Hard
Aug 07th 2012
5
Children of men was on my list and I changed it
Aug 07th 2012
6
RE: LISTS:
Aug 07th 2012
8
The Game. Nice.
Aug 08th 2012
11
off the top of my head
Aug 07th 2012
9
A quick & dirty list...
Aug 08th 2012
10
Took me like 45 minutes and I already disagree with my choices, lol
Aug 09th 2012
13
RE: LISTS:
Aug 09th 2012
14
RE: LISTS:
Aug 09th 2012
15
My list today:
Aug 09th 2012
16
Pleased to see you did it for Randolph Scott
Aug 10th 2012
17
      RAAAAANDOOOOLPH SCOOOOOOOTT!
Aug 18th 2012
44
RE: LISTS:
Aug 10th 2012
18
Wordman's list
Aug 10th 2012
19
I thought for a long time about this and then wrote it in 30 seconds.
Aug 11th 2012
20
That's a solid fucking list right there.
Aug 11th 2012
21
      seriously though, how is Wizard of Oz getting no love?
Aug 11th 2012
24
           Guilty as charged
Aug 11th 2012
25
           It's the only omission from S&S top 100 that makes me actively angry
Aug 11th 2012
26
                The crazy part is...
Aug 11th 2012
27
                     I am so glad to see Gone with the Wind go the way of its title
Aug 20th 2012
48
                          There's quite a lot in that movie that's hard to root for
Aug 21st 2012
49
           i think cause ten is such a small number
Aug 12th 2012
28
                It's not just here though
Aug 12th 2012
33
                     biggest mark against it
Aug 13th 2012
35
                          No Disney, but that makes sense in a "Tokyo Story is Ozu's best" way
Aug 13th 2012
37
B. Wood's list
Aug 11th 2012
22
clearly you love epics
Aug 11th 2012
23
this was tough, and i feel like i'm forgetting shit
Aug 12th 2012
29
My joint, as of now
Aug 12th 2012
30
Scatterbrained
Aug 12th 2012
31
expires in, oh, about 10 minutes (no order)
Aug 12th 2012
32
Whatever. I'll go with this for now (in alphabetical order):
Aug 13th 2012
36
this feels entirely inadequate
Aug 18th 2012
43
This is just a first crack, changes come at any minute...
Aug 22nd 2012
50
DEBATE/COMMENTARY:
Aug 05th 2012
2
I forgot to add "To Die For" to my list
Aug 09th 2012
12
i wish Netflix
Aug 13th 2012
38
      I've been wishing TCM would schedule a run of these.
Aug 18th 2012
39
      that would make a wole lot of sense, really
Aug 18th 2012
40
      I believe Hulu Plus
Aug 18th 2012
42
           hmmm
Aug 18th 2012
45
Are we going to do this instead of a "5 years later modern classics" lis...
Aug 06th 2012
4
Was that five years ago?
Aug 07th 2012
7
mi lista sin orden
Aug 13th 2012
34
i respect the originality of this list
Aug 18th 2012
41
10
Aug 19th 2012
46
Hrm
Aug 20th 2012
47
RE: OKPs: List your own Sight & Sound-esque Top 10 list here.
Aug 23rd 2012
51

Lobby Pass The Popcorn topic #621657 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com