Frank Longo Member since Nov 18th 2003 86830 posts
Sun Aug-05-12 10:41 PM
"OKPs: List your own Sight & Sound-esque Top 10 list here." Sun Aug-05-12 10:42 PM by Frank Longo
Here's what we want:
- List your Top 10 best movies ever. No order. Put the title and the director.
- You can have multiple per director if you so desire. No restrictions.
- Put the ten BEST films in your opinion. This isn't just your favorite films of all time-- although many times your favorites and the films you think are the best overlap. But for example, I won't put "Dirty Work (Saget)" on my list, even though I love it dearly, because while it's enjoyable for a number of personal reasons, I don't believe it's a "great." (Note: that doesn't mean comedies or mainstream films aren't great. What you believe is great is up to you. Just try not to put jokey shit.)
- If we get enough lists, we can compile them to determine our boards' total list.
- Post your lists as a reply to the respective reply below, so we can keep them somewhat organized.
Questions for answering (and I'll put a second place to reply for commentary/debate): 1. Should we let ANYONE post their list? Or should we instead do what S&S does and select a smaller number of posters who we feel represents the best of PTP? Or is that too artsy? 2. Because we will have waaaaaay fewer "ballots," is trying to tally them even worth the effort? Should this just be an area for lists and debating people's lists, rather than trying to make a big hullabaloo when we simply lack the manpower (or personpower, if you will).