He's written more than any other comic writer this past decade.
That's not to justify bad material, but if his batting average is just as good as any other comic writer with TWICE as many at bats...
I think his Marvel stuff is good/great. Obviously there's gonna be some duds in there, but his AVENGERS stuff has been great, his DAREDEVIL run is arguably the best since MILLER, he made MOON KNIGHT work (trust, that is a lot harder than it looks). He helped shaped the current world of Marvel and for the most part did it really well.
All of that coincides with how great his indie stuff's been.
I think cats get mad because his SPIDER-MAN stuff wasn't good; that, and like every other comic cat when they're "driving the car," fans get very familiar with his style and start basing their views on that, as opposed to the material.


"Your current frequencies of understanding outweigh that which has been given for you to understand." Saul Williams