Frank Longo Member since Nov 18th 2003 86689 posts
Sun Nov-21-10 02:08 PM
26. "I just wondered, was there no better place to split it?" In response to In response to 25
I hear the argument up there that it's an emotional low for the gang... but since it's not gonna have that big an impact in the movie series because of his non-presence, there's no better place to end it? I need to go back and look at the book again to see if I can imagine a different place to cut it in two.
Considering how strong Yates' added-in scenes are, maybe even an added scene in a tent with no dialogue could have delivered that same distraught feeling in a more sweeping way than the Dobby death. I'm probably just being nitpicky.