Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby Pass The Popcorn topic #257108

Subject: "Civil War vs. Infinite Crisis" This topic is locked.
Previous topic | Next topic
Melanism
Charter member
20453 posts 		Thu Feb-22-07 08:42 AM

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
"Poll question: Civil War vs. Infinite Crisis"


          

They both had their great moments (Spidey's unmasking, the return of the Crisis of Infinite Earths survivors), their highly questionable moments (Clor? Superboy Prime moving planets and reality-altering punches), their questionable editorial decisions (delays, unfinished artwork) and both were 7 issues.

So which was the better of the two?

Poll result (27 votes)
Civil War (12 votes)Vote
Infinite Crisis (15 votes)Vote

  

  
Printer-friendly copy


Civil War vs. Infinite Crisis [View all] , Melanism, Thu Feb-22-07 08:42 AM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
i ain't read CW but it's GOT to be better than that craptacular IC
Feb 22nd 2007
1
nooooooooooooooooooo
Feb 23rd 2007
51
LOL
Feb 23rd 2007
56
      i didnt even follow annihilation
Feb 23rd 2007
58
ill show u CW in thirty seconds
Feb 23rd 2007
69
      Quiet as kept, that was kinda accurate... n/m
Feb 23rd 2007
70
      Yep. That's right on the money.
Feb 23rd 2007
71
      yeah, that's funny as hell
Feb 23rd 2007
72
      **BOSTON BRAND**
Feb 23rd 2007
73
      It's funny 'cause it's true, AF. He just saved you $20 on a trade.
Feb 23rd 2007
74
           damn... the ending was really like that?
Feb 23rd 2007
76
                yup....same thing Thing said
Feb 24th 2007
79
      His IC one was shorter and possibly better.
Feb 23rd 2007
77
           not better
Mar 04th 2007
80
civil war all the way
Feb 22nd 2007
2
C-Dubb
Feb 22nd 2007
3
Superboy's death>>>>>>>>>THOR-3PO getting hit by a hammer
Feb 22nd 2007
4
WRONG
Feb 22nd 2007
8
      and Superboy's death looks even more like some cynical shit
Feb 22nd 2007
9
      that too
Feb 22nd 2007
10
      Like DC I "respectfully disagree" with your ruling!
Feb 22nd 2007
11
           For me there wasn't enough build-up for there to have been an anti-clima...
Feb 22nd 2007
15
                fans' expectations are the only thing ruining CW for them.
Feb 23rd 2007
64
Civil War, but CW vs. 52 would be a better battle...
Feb 22nd 2007
5
No it wouldn't. Only if you want to have a reason to vote for DC.
Feb 22nd 2007
6
52 would win that one... but is it really a fair match up?
Feb 22nd 2007
7
      Yeah, 52 has a distinct advantage.
Feb 22nd 2007
12
I guess I'll go with CW
Feb 22nd 2007
13
civil war, EASY
Feb 22nd 2007
14
Offtopic- What didn't you like about Identity Crisis
Feb 22nd 2007
17
      it seemed really forced and really nonsensical and
Feb 22nd 2007
23
      I did the same, from the library. It was really good.
Feb 23rd 2007
65
SUB POST: Where does Annihilation fit in?
Feb 22nd 2007
16
The main mini-series was better than CW...
Feb 22nd 2007
18
It was better overall but it had less pressure
Feb 22nd 2007
19
      very true. But on the flipside....
Feb 22nd 2007
38
IC, only because it gave us 52!
Feb 22nd 2007
20
infinite crises by a mile
Feb 22nd 2007
21
^^^A gentleman and a scholar n/m
Feb 22nd 2007
22
I am going to log in under all my aliases to put IC in the lead
Feb 22nd 2007
24
better come up with some more aliases, buddy
Feb 22nd 2007
37
Spider-Man's unmasking >>>>>>>>>>>> anything that happened in IC
Feb 22nd 2007
25
true...but IC had some nice oh shit! moments itself
Feb 22nd 2007
31
The very end of issue #7 was very well done
Feb 22nd 2007
32
yeah, that moment was a lil too over the top
Feb 22nd 2007
41
the joker scene was dope n/m
Feb 22nd 2007
42
this line alone beats the whole of CW
Feb 23rd 2007
52
blue beetle's intelligence and death was better
Feb 22nd 2007
40
      ^^I AGREE! And the arc with Supes nearly murking Bats was classic!
Feb 23rd 2007
46
I'm going to vote Civil War based on focus
Feb 22nd 2007
26
a fair assessment
Feb 22nd 2007
29
what i didn't like about civil war
Feb 22nd 2007
27
I'm more curious to know what you liked about Infinite Crisis
Feb 22nd 2007
28
RE: I'm more curious to know what you liked about Infinite Crisis
Feb 22nd 2007
33
Whoa
Feb 22nd 2007
34
      but only wonder woman was out of character
Feb 22nd 2007
35
           Shall I go on
Feb 22nd 2007
36
                i never said it was perfect
Feb 22nd 2007
39
                Only one of these didn't work:
Feb 23rd 2007
44
                     and it's not like batman hasn't used a gun before
Feb 23rd 2007
45
crisis had..
Feb 23rd 2007
53
      Inifinite Crisis did not change the DCU in any significant way
Feb 23rd 2007
54
           well lets see
Feb 23rd 2007
55
                Hm. I was under the impression that 52 was a bit of an afterthought
Feb 23rd 2007
57
                     OYL was announced arround issue 3
Feb 23rd 2007
59
Mac Gargan. Yup, former Scorpion.
Feb 23rd 2007
68
Civil War... Both should of been much better...
Feb 22nd 2007
30
Honestly
Feb 22nd 2007
43
man, WHAT is the qoute in your sig referring to?
Feb 23rd 2007
47
      RE: man, WHAT is the qoute in your sig referring to?
Feb 23rd 2007
75
Mongo's answer (edited).
Feb 23rd 2007
48
I was just talking about the miniseries not the aftermath
Feb 23rd 2007
49
Then ok. Throw it where you wanna.
Feb 23rd 2007
50
Damn, Mongo...nice breakdown.
Feb 23rd 2007
60
      RE: Damn, Mongo...nice breakdown.
Feb 23rd 2007
61
      On Thor:
Feb 23rd 2007
62
           I reiterate
Feb 23rd 2007
63
                that's why I referred to it as "the load".
Feb 23rd 2007
66
                     ah...yes.
Feb 23rd 2007
67
I'm just guessing, since I didn't read IC, but CW.
Feb 24th 2007
78
Civil war started off strong, then lost focus. But Im still a Marvel Gir...
Mar 04th 2007
81

Lobby Pass The Popcorn topic #257108 Previous topic | Next topic
   

Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com