I'm pretty sure that the critical acclaim for "Ironman" and "Supreme Clientele" was fairly unanimous.
Bulletproof Wallets, Fishscale, Pretty Toney, all got mixed reviews.
Funnily enough, as you talk about consensus "in the real world", you picked as your favorite one of his more poorly received records.
Speaking of consensus, it's pretty much settled that Ghost is the most popular and most critically acclaimed MC in the Wu. So, how overrated could he be on OKP, when he is the best rapper in one of the top 3 rap groups of all time?
It's fine that you like "Pretty Toney" more than his "unanimous" classics. It just shouldn't surprise you that people will find that fact odd. Go into a Redman post and say that you think "Doc's Da Name" is his best LP and you will get the same reaction.