Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby The Lesson topic #2670115

Subject: "Subtle Ways Musical Artists Broke Tradition..." Previous topic | Next topic
Dr Claw
Member since Jun 25th 2003
132214 posts
Mon Mar-05-12 01:14 PM

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy listClick to send message via AOL IM
"Subtle Ways Musical Artists Broke Tradition..."


  

          

... recently, I got to thinking that one of the understated "Stevie-isms" is his affinity for the finger snap as percussion. I don't recall enough to claim that as something only Stevie did to great effect, but rather, it's one of those things when heard in certain contexts, reminds me most of him.

I think that was one of the most striking things about his music when he broke out from Motown's "factory mold", though -- it wasn't really seen heavily featured until his 1980s music. It's also one of the reasons why I felt the Gap Band did their homework when they (Charlie) emulated Stevie's work to great success.

Like most of the "little things", I almost forgot about this, until I made my routine venture to a local supermarket and I heard "If You Really Love" me over the PA; this prompted me to put on WHERE I'M COMING FROM (an oft-forgotten piece in Stevie's catalog) as soon as I got to the Volvo, and some time later in my drive, up came "Take Up A Course In Happiness".

It's one of my favorite Stevie records, though I don't really know how well it's known if only, because it is very much a "Motown" record -- minus the fact that Stevie replaced the requisite tambourines with finger snaps. It was a small, subtle move that made the song sound -that- much more his own. Like I felt "Signed, Sealed, Delivered" was one of the first real steps toward Stevie's independence musically, this, too... was a touch indicating Stevie's control of his own records.

It reminds me of Michael Jackson and his insistence on a certain guitar figure and certain percussion -- those things that sound like "Michael Jackson" on records he has nothing to do with (see: the beginning of Rufus's "Walk The Rockway", or the main groove of the Commodores' "Won't You Come Dance With Me").

As a side note, Stevie held to a restrained vocal is one of the surest signs of what has made him an enduring figure... but among all the Motown greats, he always struck me as one of those who could really not be restrained (David Ruffin and Dennis Edwards are two others). I'm always taken aback by his pre-'70s Motown work because I was so surprised he was "allowed" to sing in such an expressive voice, considering the law of the land over there.

And even so, once he was allowed to release his own compositions increasingly, Stevie became one of the more subversive figures in music. If James was secretly the "Black Conservative", Stevie was secretly the "Angry Race Man"... take a listen to his grumbles on "Rocket Love", on "Sweet Little Girl", or the right-in-your face "F.U." song, "I Want To Talk To You".

  

Printer-friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote


Subtle Ways Musical Artists Broke Tradition... [View all] , Dr Claw, Mon Mar-05-12 01:14 PM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
i'm coming back to this post.
Mar 05th 2012
1
james jamerson's bass used anchor the rhythm section AND play a melody.
Mar 05th 2012
2
damn right
Mar 05th 2012
3
i'm sure somebody did it before jameson,
Mar 05th 2012
6
yep yep.
Mar 05th 2012
25
that's a great track.
Mar 05th 2012
27
you will recognize the song, even w/ nothing else playing...
Mar 07th 2012
52
whoever the first reggae drummer was to put the kick on the third beat.
Mar 05th 2012
4
I always heard it was Scratch Perry
Mar 05th 2012
22
Prince & 'horns'
Mar 05th 2012
5
that is the thing that converted me.
Mar 05th 2012
7
Marvin Gayes innovations with multitracked harmonies.
Mar 05th 2012
8
i'd say MJ, prince, and stevie are equally good at that.
Mar 05th 2012
9
for sure. D'Angelo was on that w/Voodoo.
Mar 05th 2012
11
yeah. thing is, it was there to some extent w/ his first album, but
Mar 05th 2012
17
i dig that about Hargrove's work too.
Mar 05th 2012
19
D'Angelo examples:
Mar 06th 2012
40
This one should go to Les Paul.
Mar 05th 2012
15
let me add Michael McDonald (who got it from Steely Dan) to that,
Mar 05th 2012
18
      yes!
Mar 05th 2012
24
      here's the part from the video: http://splicd.com/waIBA6_0GQc/380/521
Mar 06th 2012
38
      Yeah, one song where I felt its influence
Mar 06th 2012
33
      yeah. i heart that song.
Mar 08th 2012
61
      how yall leave out Freddie Mercury
Mar 06th 2012
36
           link / splicd up a good example, please?
Mar 06th 2012
39
               
Mar 06th 2012
49
p-funk's deconstruction and reconstruction of the black music tradition.
Mar 05th 2012
10
RE: p-funk's deconstruction and reconstruction of the black music tradit...
Mar 05th 2012
20
Don't know for sure.....
Mar 05th 2012
26
word. gospel in there, too.
Mar 05th 2012
32
very true.
Mar 06th 2012
37
i don't know which song is the song that defines the p-funk sound.
Mar 07th 2012
56
      Mothership Connection. One Nation Under a Groove.
Mar 07th 2012
60
smokey robinson's voice challenges assumptions about gender.
Mar 05th 2012
12
this essay about smokey robinson is really good.
Mar 07th 2012
57
james brown made the entire band sound like a percussion instrument.
Mar 05th 2012
13
Two Words; Moog Bass
Mar 05th 2012
14
Great post.
Mar 05th 2012
16
^^^^
Mar 06th 2012
35
Got a few...
Mar 05th 2012
21
he was also one of the first to rap on a "regular" record too...
Mar 05th 2012
29
      .
Mar 06th 2012
34
      Melle Mel on Chaka Khan "I Feel For You"? n/m
Mar 07th 2012
55
           I said "one of" the first...not THE first...
Mar 07th 2012
58
                no. that wasn't an underground record.
Mar 07th 2012
59
I think Derrick May was the first to make Dance music "top heavy"
Mar 05th 2012
23
Examples...
Mar 06th 2012
46
      oh shit! i know what you talking about now.
Mar 06th 2012
47
           Nude Photo was '87, Kaos was '88
Mar 06th 2012
48
                damn. y u have to do the math on it? i was almost street legal
Mar 06th 2012
50
Uncle Luke
Mar 05th 2012
28
RE: Subtle Ways Musical Artists Broke Tradition...
Mar 05th 2012
30
The Beatles
Mar 05th 2012
31
Buju Banton----Til Shiloh
Mar 06th 2012
41
Sister Carol was doing that YEARS before Buju.
Mar 06th 2012
43
      A bunch of the 80's Dj's did it but Buju's Til Shiloh
Mar 07th 2012
54
can y'all youtube examples (or better yet, splicd)? that would make
Mar 06th 2012
42
awesome idea.
Mar 06th 2012
44
fair enough. I'll add it to mine.
Mar 06th 2012
45
Stanley Clarke: bass guitar as lead guitar.
Mar 07th 2012
51
i'm not too proud to say it..
Mar 07th 2012
53
Lonnie Johnson & the move to single-string guitar soloing
Mar 08th 2012
62

Lobby The Lesson topic #2670115 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com